1 / 12

Chapter 3

Chapter 3. Logic and Language. Preview of 3.1 - 3.3. Problem areas 3.1 Proposition 3.2 Subtlety of definitional terms 3.3 Largely unproblematic. Chapter 3.1. This chapter is about “What is actually meant by . . . .” Which of these concepts/terms were difficult? Proposition

vidar
Download Presentation

Chapter 3

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Chapter 3 Logic and Language

  2. Preview of 3.1 - 3.3 • Problem areas • 3.1 • Proposition • 3.2 • Subtlety of definitional terms • 3.3 • Largely unproblematic

  3. Chapter 3.1 • This chapter is about “What is actually meant by . . . .” • Which of these concepts/terms were difficult? • Proposition • Cognitive meaning • Emotive force • For the concepts/terms that were confusing, can someone clarify it for us by defining and giving at least one example, or the range of examples, of it? • Why is it important to understand these concepts/terms? • Review problematic exercises

  4. Chapter 3.2 • Which of these concepts/terms were difficult? • Ambiguity versus vagueness • Extensional definition • Ostensive • Enumerative • Subclassical • Intensional definition • Lexical (genus & differentia) • Stipulative • Precising • Theoretical • For the concepts/terms that were confusing, can someone clarify it for us by defining and giving at least one example, or the range of examples, of it? • Why is it important to understand these concepts/terms? • Review problematic exercises

  5. Why care about definitions? • ‘Define’ literally means to put ‘limits around’ (fr. L. de ‘about’ + finis‘limit’). • So, definition limitsmeanings. • Minimizes • vagueness (meaningsshading off into other areas) • ambiguity (more than one meaning) • Minimizes complications of “It all depends on what you mean by __________.”

  6. Definition by extension • Pointing (a.k.a. ‘ostensive’) • actually showing one or more cases • Enumeration • listing individual examples • Subclass • listing types or categories • Exhaustive v. non-exhaustive?

  7. Intensional definition • Stipulative: personal, ad hoc, coined or not • Lexical: positive, descriptive, dictionary-type, though not necessarily exclusively so • Precising: minimizes vagueness & ambiguity, to “put a fine point on it,” to distinguish precise meaning frompopular meaning • Theoretical: places a term in a particular context; may give meaning to both term and context • Persuasive: affective, subjective, emotive

  8. Definition by intension • Synonym • Another word (lit.  ‘similar’ +  ‘name’) • Etymology • Linguistic genealogy (lit. ‘true’ + s‘account’) • Test • Establishes criteria to be met • Genus + difference/differentia • “garden variety” definition technique: ‘x is a y [that . . . .]’

  9. Chapter 3.2, cont’d. • Which of these concepts/terms were difficult? • Genus versus difference/differentia • Definiendumversusdefiniens • Counterexample • For the concepts/terms that were confusing, can someone clarify it for us by defining and giving at least one example, or the range of examples, of it? • Why is it important to understand these concepts/terms? • What are the criteria for producing a good definition? • Not to wide • Not to narrow • Not obscure, ambiguous, figurative • Not circular • Not negative if it can be positive • Not use unsuitable criteria to determine extension • Review problematic exercises

  10. Ways of defining: terms • ‘definiendum’: word to be defined • ‘definiens’: words doing the defining • ‘extension’: set of objects in defined class • ‘intension’: properties of objects in class

  11. Rules • What is meant by essential characteristics (necessary & sufficient)? • How can the definiens be too broad or narrow? • What is meant by circularity? • Cite examples of ambiguity, obscurity, figurative or emotive language.

  12. Chapter 3.3 • Which of these concepts/terms were difficult? • Equivocation versus merely verbal dispute • Persuasive definition • For the concepts/terms that were confusing, can someone clarify it for us by defining and giving at least one example, or the range of examples, of it? • Why is it important to understand these concepts/terms? • Review problematic exercises

More Related