1 / 37

United States Constitution

United States Constitution. INTRODUCTION. US Constitution is based upon Lockean liberal principles of Rule of law/Limited government Popular sovereignty/consent I ndividual liberty Separation of powers But it is also a political document, requiring compromise. The Framers’ Dilemma.

nealey
Download Presentation

United States Constitution

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. United States Constitution

  2. INTRODUCTION • US Constitution is based upon Lockean liberal principles of • Rule of law/Limited government • Popular sovereignty/consent • Individual liberty • Separation of powers • But it is also a political document, requiring compromise

  3. The Framers’ Dilemma • Federalists wanted to create greater order and security with a stronger national level government and an energetic executive. • But they had just fought a war of independence against a tyrannical government and did not want to threaten liberty.

  4. Articles of Confederation • First constitution, 1777-1789 • A loose confederation, weak central government • Equal state representation • Executive powers exercised by legislative committees • Limited powers to tax and raise an army • Important actions include Treaty of Paris and Northwest Ordinance

  5. Breakdown Under Articles of Confederation • Gold crisis and postwar depression • Lack of taxing power led to crisis of confidence in bonds • No powers to regulate interstate commerce • No enforcement powers—just an alliance • Other nation states were unwilling to sign treaties with US

  6. Shays’ Rebellion 1786-1787 • Failure to compensate farmers who fought for independence • Armed resistance to farm foreclosures • Difficulty quelling resistance with local militias • Lack of a regular army

  7. Constitutional Convention 1787 • Hamilton and others used Shays’ Rebellion to press for more national power • Did not exactly have the authority to replace Articles of Confederation

  8. Constitutional Principle: The Rule of Law • As opposed to rule by force or by a king • Need for lawful institutions to resolve dispute peacefully • A fundamental principle of a system of limited government • Federal government is limited to powers listed in the Constitution

  9. Constitutional Principle: Popular Sovereignty • Rule by the people based upon their consent • Delegates to convention chosen by state legislatures • Created a representative assembly (Congress) as principal decision making body • Constitution ratified by state conventions • BUT—no voting rights in original Constitution

  10. Constitutional Principle: Separation of Powers • Charles de Montesquieu 1689-1755Spirit of the Laws; concept also described by John Locke • To avoid tyranny, disperse power • Main functions of government: • Legislative (law making) • Executive (administering laws) • Judicial (interpreting laws and trying cases) • Place each function in separate gov’t institutions

  11. Overview of Articles Demonstrates Separation of Powers • Article I on Congress was first and longest article reflecting framers’ view that Congress was most important • Established representative government and popular sovereignty • Established “strong bicameralism”—two equal branches of government • Extensive list of “enumerated powers” but also implied powers created a strong central government

  12. Article II Executive Branch • President • chief executive, • head of state, • commander in chief • “Unitary executive” and broad executive powers created a powerful executive

  13. Article III Judiciary • Supreme Court • Judicial review not explicit but implicit, gives Supreme Court power to overturn acts of Congress, president, and state governments • Size of Supreme Court and system of lower courts left up to Congress

  14. Article IV States • Full Faith and Credit clause—states must accept each others laws and records as valid (such as birth certificates) • Privileges and Immunities clause—State laws can’t discriminate against residents of other states. • Provisions for creating new states—VT added 1791, KY 1792 …. • States must be republics—no kings!

  15. Article 5 • Amendment process—procedures for changing the Constitution • More on this at a later date….

  16. Article 6 • Miscellaneous but important provisions • Debts incurred under Articles of Confederation will be paid (established full faith and credit of US) • Supremacy Clause—Constitution and federal laws can preempt state laws if they conflict • No religious test to hold office—unlike Britain at the time; US government is secular

  17. Article 7 • Ratification of Constitution • Conducted by state ratifying conventions and not by state legislatures • When ratified by 9 states, it will go into effect in those states. • NY state was eleventh but crucial for unity • All 13 states ratified it

  18. Discussion • Federal govt outlaws marijuana but Colorado and others have legalized it. How is that? • How can Alabama ban all abortions when it is protected under federal law?

  19. Answers • Federal govt has taken a wait and see approach but will still prosecute illegal drug trafficking. • The Alabama law will be challenged in federal court and might be overturned—or Roe v. Wade will be reversed.

  20. Constitutional Principle: Checks and Balances • MadisonFederalist #51 “Ambition must counteract ambition” • Neustadt: “Separated institutions sharing power” • Checks and balances require branches to share powers. • Separation of powers + checks and balances leads to compromise—or stalemate

  21. Discussion • What powers does the presidency share with Congress? • Powers Congress shares with the presidency?

  22. President’s Checks • Checks on Congress • partial vetoes, • veto override, • Can call for congress in for a special legislative session • state of union message to Congress • Checks on Judiciary • judicial nominations, • pardons

  23. Congress’s Checks • Checks on President • confirmation of cabinet appointments • Appropriations—power of the purse • Oversight hearings and investigations of executive branch • Impeachment and removal • Checks on judiciary • Confirmations of judicial appointments • Bicameralism • an internal check

  24. Parliamentary System Compared to Ours • Watch YouTube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4quK60FUvkY Note that most democracies are parliamentary systems.

  25. Discussion • What are the key differences between a parliamentary system and our system of Constitutional government?

  26. US Unlike a Parliamentary System • Parliamentary system has no separation of executive and legislative branches • The executive powers are exercised by a cabinet and prime minister—the majority party leaders of the parliament • Creates a more unified system • Other differences—unified party government greater party discipline, no set electoral calendar, prime minister is not the head of state

  27. Transition • US Constitution is not based entirely on our political principles. • It’s a political document that required extensive compromise to pass. • A key characteristic of American politics is the central role of compromise. American politics requires compromise and won’t work without compromise.

  28. Virginia Plan • “Rough draft” framework proposed by James Madison included an executive branch, a bicameral legislative branch, and proportional representation among the states in both chambers.

  29. Great Compromise • Small states would have lost equal state representation under VA Plan • New Jersey plan-small states objected and proposed equal state representation in House and Senate. • Roger Sherman proposed the Great (or “Connecticut”) Compromise—Representation by population in House, equal representation of states in the Senate

  30. Discussion • Why didn’t the framers start with a blank slate and redraw state boundaries to create more equal regional governments? • Does the US system of representation in Congress meet the standards of a representative democracy? • Why or why not?

  31. Answers • Delegates to Constitutional Convention were appointed by the states and the Constitution had to be ratified by the states. • But--citizens in large states like California and NY are now underrepresented in the Senate compared to citizens in small states like Delaware and Wyoming. • 21 smallest states, 12% of US population, can block legislation in Senate by filibustering.

  32. Three-Fifths Compromise • 6 Southern states feared they would be outnumbered in Congress and northern states would some day vote to abolish slavery. • 3/5 Compromise allowed slave states to count 60% of slaves for determining the number of seats in the House. • Constitution also prohibited passing any laws against slave trade for 20 years.

  33. Discussion • What impact did the Three-fifths Compromise have on American politics?

  34. Answers • It constitutionally recognized and protected slavery, undermining its legitimacy. • It established political inequality based on race that still affects our politics. • 3/5 Compromise gave Southern states additional votes in the Electoral College—nine of first fifteen presidents were southerners.

  35. Wm. Lloyd Garrison, The Crisis, 1832, on the Constitution • “ It was a compact formed at the sacrifice of the bodies and souls of millions of our race, for the sake of achieving a political object—an unblushing and monstrous coalition to do evil that good might come. Such a compact was, in the nature of things and according to the law of God, null and void from the beginning.” Abolitionist

  36. Final Question • In what ways was the political system created by Constitution in 1789 a democracy? In what ways was it not a democracy?

  37. Review • US Constitution is based on the principles of individual liberty, popular sovereignty, limited government, separation of powers, checks and balances. • But the Great Compromise and the Three-Fifths Compromise demonstrate that it is also a political document shaped by the interests of the age.

More Related