1 / 30

A Short Legal & Historical Framework for the Immigration Reform Debate

May Day, 2006: Millions of authorized and unauthorized immigrants and their allies demonstrated for amnesty across the U.S. and held the first nationwide, political general strike in U.S. history . A Short Legal & Historical Framework for the Immigration Reform Debate.

moses
Download Presentation

A Short Legal & Historical Framework for the Immigration Reform Debate

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. May Day, 2006: Millions of authorized and unauthorized immigrants and their allies demonstrated for amnesty across the U.S. and held the first nationwide, political general strike in U.S. history A Short Legal & Historical Framework for the Immigration Reform Debate

  2. Securing the Homeland: The War Abroad & At Home • Within 10 years, the Detention and Removal Program will ensure the departure of “all removable aliens through the fair and effective enforcement of our nation’s immigration laws.”

  3. U.S. Immigration: the First Two Hundred Years • First One Hundred: unrestricted immigration • 1790-1820: 250,000 immigrants arrived • 1820-1880: 10 million immigrants arrived • But the beginning of racist exclusions • Chinese Exclusion Act - 1882 • Suspended all Chinese immigration - was not repealed until 1943, finally allowing Chinese immigrants to become citizens

  4. Second Hundred Years: Xenophobia, Racism & Working Class Militancy Shape Early 20th Century Immigration Law • 1880s - 72% of immigrants were of northern & western European descent • 1990-1910 - 71% of immigrants were southern or eastern European (Italians, Slavs & Jews) • 1917 Immigration Act - • barred those unable to read & imposed an $8 head tax • Created the ‘Asiatic Barred Zone’ barring Asians • Anarchist Act of 1918 - • Political exclusion and expulsion of radical-minded European workers

  5. Post-World Wars: Quotas and Restrictions • 1920’s: Series of immigration acts limit immigration to small percentages of persons from European nationalities residing in US based on census data • Intended Effect - limit immigration from disfavored southern and eastern regions • Mexican/American border patrol begins • 1930’s - Depression led to deportations of 1/2 million • Post WW II - • Short period of liberalization allowing WW II refugees from Germany, Austria & Italy and later refugees fleeing Soviet takeover of E. Europe (all total, about 1/2 million) • Internal Security Act (1950) - barring anyone likely to engage in ‘subversive activity’

  6. Immigration & Nationality Act of 1952 • INA retained discriminatory national origin quotas & 150,000/year limit on immigrants from Eastern Hemisphere • Hierarchy within the quota system • First, entrants with skills needed for economy • Then persons with close family relations to citizens or permanent residents (immediate relatives - spouse/children outside quota system)

  7. Bracero Program- 1942-1964The largest U.S. labor contract program in the 20th Century • 4.5 million Mexicans legally contracted for seasonal agricultural work in the U.S. • 1 out of 2 seasonal migratory labor jobs was held by Mexicans • 1952 - The Bracero Program did not stop deportations. INS begins ‘Operation Wetback’; deporting more than 720,000 Mexicans (90% of those deported that year) • 1954 - INS deports 1 million workers • Deportations included U.S. citizens of Mexican descent denied due process and right to prove their claim of US citizenship • 1964/1965 - Caesar Chavez begins UFW grape boycott

  8. Prelude to “Reform” • 1980 - • almost 6 million unauthorized persons in the U.S. • Immigration & Naturalization Service (INS) • Employed 11,000 • Annual Budget $300 million • Annual deportations of unauthorized individuals routinely exceeds 1 million

  9. More $$ for immigration enforcement Prohibited discrimination based on national origin or citizenship status Reestablished a guest worker program Established an employment verification (I-9) system Criminal sanctions and civil fines if employer knowingly hires unauthorized workers Amnesty - one time, must show entered before 1/1/82 and had resided illegally and continuously in the US and meet requirements of immigrant admissibility or U.S. government aware of valid, but expired non-immigrant status. Disqualified newly legalized non-citizens from receiving public welfare assistance for 5 yrs (except Cuban/Haitian entrants) Immigration Reform & Control Act - 1986 (IRCA)

  10. 9-11 and Immigration Law: Patriot Act & Homeland Security Act • Established Dept. of Homeland Security • Immigration & Customs Enforcement (ICE) • Customs and Border Patrol (CBP) • Citizenship & Immigration Services (CIS) • Broadened definition of terrorist • Monitoring of Non-Citizens • Resulting in Profiling and Widespread Rights Violations of Muslims and Arabs

  11. Legal Status of Immigrants • 35.7 million foreign born • 11.3 million naturalized citizens • 10.4 million Legal Permanent Residents (LPR) 2.5 million Refugees (post 1980) • 1.2 million temporary legal residents • 10.3 million Unauthorized (Undocumented)

  12. How IRCA Classifies Immigrants • Lawful Permanent Residents (LPRs) • Naturalized (former LPR) • Refugee Arrivals • Temporary Legal Residents - 1.2 million • H1-B - highly skilled workers • H2-A - agricultural workers • H2-B - non-agricultural industries, e.g. forestry, landscaping, tourism, seafood processing • Non-immigrants (undocumented/unauthorized)

  13. Immigrants are essential to the U.S. Economy • 15% of civilian workforce • Majority non-citizens 12.7 million (63%) • Minority naturalized citizens 7.6 million (37%) • Immigrant are critical to future growth • New immigrants contributed at least 60% of growth in civilian labor force over past 5 years • Immigrants will account for • 1/2 working age population between 2006 & 2015 • All growth between 2016 and 2035

  14. Immigrants Face Inequality Working in the U.S. Labor Market • Over-represented in highest risk, lowest paid jobs • Lack access to basic social services • Deprived of workplace rights • Most denied lawful residence and path to citizenship

  15. Over-represented in highest risk, lowest paid jobs • Of 43.1 million low-wage workers, 8.6 million foreign born • 2 million immigrant workers earn less than minimum wage; 1 in 4 low wage workers is an immigrant • Average low-wage immigrant worker earns $14,400/yr • 1/2 of all immigrant workers earn less than 200% of minimum wage (compared to 32% of native born workers) • * Low wage is 200% minimum wage in the state of residence

  16. Lack of Access to Education & health care • Only 26% of immigrants have job-based health insurance • 28% of low wage immigrant workers have not completed 9th grade (2% for native born); almost 1/2 have not completed high school • 28% of immigrant labor force with less than a high school education has limited English language proficiency (LEP) • 62% of low wage immigrant workers are LEP

  17. Guest Workers and Undocumented • Failure of laws designed to protect workplace rights • Deprived of lawful residence and path to citizenship

  18. 12 Million - 30% of foreign-born - are unauthorized immigrants • 66% in the U.S. for less than 10 years • 40% less than 5 years • Men 49%, Women 35%, 16% Children * • 56% of undocumented workers are Mexican • 22% from the rest of Latin America, mostly C.A. • 850,000 undocumented workers enter yearly • 25-40% of undocumented workers enter the country legally and overstay their visas * 3.1 Million children are U.S. citizens who live in families where one parent or head of household is unauthorized (2/3 of children living in unauthorized families are children)

  19. The Futile Work of the U.S. Border Patrol: Arrest & Removal of Jobseekers Minuteman Border Proposal

  20. Undocumented Labor Force - By Industry - 2005 • 33% in service jobs (16% native workers) • 17% in ‘leisure & hospitality • 20% in construction • 15% in manufacturing/repair • 4% in farming • More men the women in workforce • Men - higher then native born (94% v. 83%) • Women - lower then native born (54% v. 72%)

  21. Undocumented Workers by Occupation -2005

  22. Denied Rights at Work • I-9 Requirements & SS no-match letters create vulnerability, discrimination & exploitation • Workplace raids by ICE - Danbury & New Bedford • Employer threats - veiled & overt • IRCA trumps federal workplace protections • Labor rights & anti-discrimination law - formal protection but • No remedies, weak remedies or difficulty of enforcement • Patchwork of state by state protections

  23. Guest Worker Programs “Indentured Servitude” • H-2 Program - Employer must obtain certification from DOL that: • Lack of sufficient U.S. workers able, willing & qualified at time and place needed • Wages/working conditions of U.S. workers will not be “adversely affected” • H-2 visas are only for individuals - family members not permitted • 121,000 H-2 workers in 2005

  24. H-2A entitlements 3/4 guarantee Free housing Workers’ Compensation Travel reimbursement after 50% of contract complete Health & Safety protection Eligible for federally funded legal services for work-related issues H-2A: agriculture H-2B entitlements No housing No 3/4 guarantee No DOL enforcement of prevailing wage No access to legal services No travel reimbursement No social security exemption H-2B: tourist, forestry, seafood industry, landscaping H-2 Program Standards

  25. H-2 - “… the closest thing I’ve seen to slavery” Charles Rangel, House Ways and Means Chair • Routine wage & hour violations • Misclassification to lower wages • Huge Fees Paid for Access to Jobs • Documents seizure by employers • Substandard Housing • Denied Medical Benefits

  26. Labor Brokers: Exploitation Begins at Home • Example: Hurricane Katrina & the Decatur Hotels in New Orleans • Each worker paid $3500 to $5000 for 9 month contract • Labor contractor earned $1200 for each of 290 workers brought from Peru, Bolivia & Dominican Republic • Promised 40/wk - worked less than 25 hrs • Prohibited from working other jobs • Forced to leave property or other collateral in exchange for contract to work in U.S.

  27. Wage & Hour Violations: A Race to the bottom • Forestry • Obligation to pay prevailing wage, but • Often paid by by # of seedlings planted • Employer obligated to pay difference • Employer fails to make up difference • Seafood Processing - Va. & N. Car. - 10 lawsuits since 1998 • Piece-rate that failed to reach minimum wage • Deductions for tools, travel and uninhabitable housing • Failure to pay time and one-half for over 40 hours • All lawsuits settled • Absence of free labor market and scant resources for enforcement of basic wage and hour laws guarantee exploitation of vulnerable guestworkers

  28. Injured, Blacklisted & No Government Enforcement • Workers’ Compensation - No clear rules • Cut-off when workers leave the country • Discouraged and pressured not to report • Threat of blacklisting • Systemic Discrimination • Women placed in less lucrative H-2B jobs • Differential wage rates based on nationality • Vulnerable to sexual harassment and abuse

  29. Amnesty - Path for Lawful Permanent Residence & Citizenship or Guest Workers? • For more information: • Mass. Immigrant & Refugee Advocacy Coalition: www.miracoalition.org • National Immigration Law Center www.nilc.org • AFL-CIO - www.aflcio.org • ACLU - www.aclu.org • National Employment Law Project www.nelp.org • Southern Poverty Law Center www.splcenter.org • Assoc. of Immigration Lawyers Assoc. www.aila.org • Pew Hispanic Center www.pewhispanic.org

More Related