1 / 57

Student Conduct: Discipline or Development?

Student Conduct: Discipline or Development?. A Review of N.J.A.C. 6A:16-7, Student Conduct Gary L. Vermeire geeeveee@yahoo.com. Purposes of this Session. Explain the minimum requirements for school policies and procedures for:

zaria
Download Presentation

Student Conduct: Discipline or Development?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Student Conduct:Discipline or Development? A Review of N.J.A.C. 6A:16-7, Student Conduct Gary L. Vermeire geeeveee@yahoo.com

  2. Purposes of this Session • Explain the minimum requirements for school policies and procedures for: • Promoting positive student development and student behavioral expectations; and • Intervening with and remediating student conduct concerns.

  3. Purpose of this Session, cont. • Identify areas for resource sharing, including training, technical assistance & support on policies and practices for addressing student conduct issues. • Identify opportunities for school and other agency staff to cooperate in assisting students at risk for school failure and involvement in the juvenile justice system.

  4. Concerns • “Zero Tolerance” Policies • Increase in out-of-school suspension primarily for non-dangerous, non-violent misbehavior, e.g. tardiness, “disrespect” (95%) with little or no academic benefit • Discrimination? • African-American students - 18% public enrollment; 40% of one or more suspensions • Disabled students – higher rates • Lifetime Negative Effects: work, military, financial aid, juvenile-criminal justice

  5. Summary Recommendations • Climate & Prevention • Comprehensive multi-tiered behavioral framework that engages the whole school community in establishing a positive, safe & nurturing school environment for all • Universal – School-wide strategies • Targeted – More intensive strategies for students exhibiting at-risk behavior • Indicated – Intensive services for students continuing to exhibit problem behavior, needing additional support

  6. Summary Recommendations, cont. • Clear & formal instruction for staff & students on responsible & respectful behavior in all school settings & activities • Clear, Appropriate, Consistent & Fair Expectations, Consequences & Rewards for Good Behavior • Code of student conduct aligned with student support services and academic program • Equity & Continuous Improvement • Build staff capacity & continuously evaluate

  7. Regulatory History • 2001 – NJDOE Working Group (9 focus groups) • Develop standards, but not overly prescriptive • Allow local decision making on specifics & consequences, but provide a framework in which schools can function • 2002 – State Board of Education Discussion Paper • 2005 – Adopted • 2006 – Re-adopted • 2014 – Re-adopted with Amendments

  8. Purposes of N.J.A.C. 6A:16-7 • Establish standards, policies & procedures for positive student development&student behavioral expectations • Promote a school climate that supports academic excellence and a positive work environment for staff • Organize existing case law, statutes & rulings on student conduct & due process of law • Support local authority for student conduct, while assuring student’s rights • Support the mission of the NJ State Board of Education

  9. Amendments/New Rules • Increase school flexibility and reduce state requirements recommended by the Educational Transformation Task Force (Exec. Order #58, 2011), where possible • Clarify and reorganize existing regulations • Make terms and language consistent across education regulations • Conform to associated statutes and case law • Refine/Amend definitions

  10. Amendments/New Rules, cont. Established new rules on: • Conduct away from school grounds • Attendance • Harassment, intimidation & bullying

  11. Code of Student Conduct (CSC)N.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.1 • Establishes a framework for the development of a school district CSC that: • Promotes positive student development & behavioral expectations - 7.1(a) • May be established in collaboration with parents, students & community members, representing school & community composition- 7.1(a)1 - Focus on Prevention -

  12. Code of Student Conduct, cont. • Establishes a framework for a district CSC that: • Is annually reviewed & updated, as appropriate - 7.1(a)2 • Is annually disseminated to students, parents & staff - 7.1(a)3 • Is equitably applied - 7.1(a)3 & c(5)iii • The regulations: • Require annual trainingon the CSC for all board of education (BOE) employees - 7.1(a)4 - Training must address the prevention, intervention and remediation of conduct violating the CSC

  13. Code of Student Conduct, cont. CSC PURPOSES - 7.1(b) • Foster the health, safety & social and emotional well-being of students; • Support the establishment and maintenance of civil, safe, secure, supportive & disciplined school environments conducive to learning; • Promote achievement of high academic standards; • Prevent the occurrence of problem behaviors;

  14. Code of Student Conduct, cont. CSC PURPOSES, cont. • Establish parameters for the intervention & remediation of student problem behaviors at all stages of identification; and • Establish parameters for school responses to violations of the CSC that take into account, at a minimum, the severity of the offenses, the developmental ages of the student offenders & students’histories of inappropriate behaviorsin accordance with 7.2 through 7.8, as appropriate.

  15. Code of Student Conduct, cont. The regulations set forth the minimum types of content for CSCs, including - 7.1(c): • Student responsibilities – 7.1(c)1 • Behaviors resulting in suspension or expulsion – 7.1(c)2 • Student’s rights (7.1(c)3), including due process & appeal procedures – 7.1(c)3v

  16. Code of Student Conduct, cont. • The regulations require the CSC to have a: • Description of comprehensive behavioral supportspromoting positive development & student’s abilities to fulfill the behavioral expectations – 7.1(c)4 • Description of school responses to violations that are graded by severity of offenses & consider developmental ages & histories of inappropriate behavior – 7.1(c)5 - Continuum of actions for remediation and, where necessary, impose sanctions – 7.1(c)5i

  17. Code of Student Conduct, cont. • The regulations (7.1(c)6) require the CSC to be consistent with the BOE’s policies & procedures on: • Attendance (N.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.6) & • Harassment, intimidation & bullying (N.J.A.C. 76A:16-7.7). • School districts must maintain a current list of health & social service agencies & legal resources – 7.1(c)7

  18. Code of Student Conduct, cont. • When designed to maintain the order & integrity of the school environment, a BOE may deny, as sanctions, participation in (7.1(d)): • Extracurricular activities, • School functions, • Graduation exercises, or • Other privileges.

  19. Short-term SuspensionsN.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.2 DEFINITION Removal of a student for one but not more than 10 consecutive school days from the general education program or the special education program, in accordance with N.J.A.C. 6A:14-2.8, but not the cessation of the student’s educational services. (6A:16-1.3)

  20. Short-term SuspensionsN.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.2 • Includes regulations for: • Notification of charges to student (oral or written) (7.2(a)1) • When denied, an explanation of evidence is to be provided • Informal hearingprior to suspension – 7.2(a)2 • Student opportunity to give his or her version • Notice of school actions taken • Hearing & notice may take place at the same time – 7.2(a)2iv

  21. Short-term Suspensions, cont. Includes regulations for: • Notification (oral or written) to parents prior to end of school day, to include (7.2(a)3)): • Specific charges; • Facts on which charges are based; • Provisions of CSC accused of violating; • Student’s due process rights; and • Terms & conditions of the suspension.

  22. Short-term Suspensions, cont. Includes regulations for: • Supervision of the student during the school day – 7.2(a)4 • Provision of academic instruction either in school or out of school • Provided within five school days of the suspension – 7.2(a)5 • Report to CSA and BOE – 7.2(b) • Student returned to program at completion of suspension – 7.2(a)5ii

  23. Long-term SuspensionsN.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.3 DEFINITION Removal of a student for more than 10 consecutive school days from the general education program or the special education program, when the appropriate procedures set forth in N.J.A.C. 6A:14-2.8 have been followed, but notthe cessation of the student’s educational services. (6A:16-1.3)

  24. Long-term SuspensionsN.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.3 • Includes requirements for: • Notification of charges to student prior to removal (7.3(a)1) • Informal hearing prior to suspension – 7.3(a)2 • Student opportunity to give his or her version • Notice of the actions taken • Supervision of the student during school day – 7.3(a)4

  25. Long-term Suspensions, cont. • Parent notification – 7.3(a)3 & 5 • Immediate notificationof the removal; and • Written notification within two school days, stating: • Specific charges • Facts on which charges based • Student’s due process rights • Further engagement in conduct warranting expulsion amounts to a waiver of free public education right if the BOE decides to expel the student

  26. Long-term Suspensions, cont. • Includes requirements for: • Provision of a list of witnesses & their statements or affidavits – 7.3(a)6 • No later than five days before formal hearing • Information on the right to secure an attorney & available legal resources – 7.3(a)8 & 7.1(c)8 • Provision of comparable educational services within five school days of the suspension – 7.3(a)9 & (f)

  27. Long-term Suspensions, cont. • Includes requirements for: • Formal hearing – 7.3(a)10 • Occurs no later than 30 days following suspension • Student may confront & cross-examine witnesses if question of fact • Present own defense & produce oral testimony or written affidavits • Result in a BOE decision • Parent notification of the BOE’s decision – 7.3(a)11

  28. Long-term Suspensions, cont. • Includes requirements for: • Written parent notification of the BOE’s decisionwithin five days of the close of the hearing to include (7.3(a)11): • Charges considered; • Summary of all evidence; • Factual findings on each charge; • BOE determination of each charge; • The educational services to be provided; • Terms & conditions of the suspension; • Right to appeal to Commissioner of Education.

  29. Long-term Suspensions, cont. • Includes requirements for: • The return of a student – 7.3(a)12 & 13 • If it is found the student did not commit the offense; and • At the completion of a suspension. • Appeals – 7.3(b)

  30. Long-term Suspensions, cont. • Includes requirements for: • The continuation of suspensions & educational services – 7.3(c), (d) & (e) • Criteria for determining appropriate educational programs & support services – 7.3(f)

  31. ExpulsionsN.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.5 DEFINITION The discontinuance of educational services or the discontinuance of payment of educational services for a student. (6A:16-1.3)

  32. ExpulsionsN.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.5 • BOE may expel after providing the following: • All due process rights (7.5(a)1)subsequent to a long-term suspension, per 7.3 (and prior fulfillment of 7.1(c)3), which include:

  33. Expulsions, cont. • Notification to parents that further engagement in conduct warranting expulsion may amount to a knowing & voluntary waiver of the right to a free public education – 7.3(a)5iv; and • Provision of appropriate educational programs or services, per 7.3(a)9, 7.3(f) & 7.4(a)2 • Appeals [7.5(b)]

  34. Conduct Away From School GroundsN.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.5 • May impose consequences for conduct away from school grounds that are consistent with the BOE’s CSC (7.1) – 7.5(a) & (a)3 • Exercised only: • When it is reasonably necessary for the student’s physical or emotional safety, security & well-being or for reasons relating to the safety, security & well-being of other students, staff or school grounds – 7.5(a)1; and • When the conduct that is the subject of the proposed consequence materially & substantially interferes with the requirements of appropriate discipline in the operation of the school – 7.5(a)2

  35. Conduct Away From School Grounds, cont. • However, school authorities must respond to harassment, intimidation or bullying that occurs off school grounds – 7.5(b)

  36. AttendanceN.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.6 • Requires adoption of policies & procedures to include: • Expectations & consequences regarding students’ timely arrival to & attendance at school & classes – 7.6(a)1 & 2 • A definition of unexcused absence that counts toward truancy – 7.6(a)3

  37. Attendance, cont. • Required school staff responses for unexcused absences: • For up to 4 cumulative absences – 7.6(a)4i • For between 5 & 9 cumulative absences – 7.6(a)4ii • Cumulative absences of 10 or more, at which time the student (ages 6-16) is truant –7.6 (a)4iii

  38. Attendance, cont. For up to 4 cumulative absences, the school district must (7.6(a)4i): • Attempt to notify parents of each absence before the start of the following school day; • Attempt to determine the cause of each absence, including through contact with parents; • Identify, in consultation with parents, needed action; • Act on potential missing or abused child situations; and • Cooperate with law enforcement & other authorities, as appropriate.

  39. Attendance, cont. For between 5 & 9 cumulative absences, the school district must (7.6(a)4ii): • Attempt to notify parents of each absence before the start of the following school day; • Attempt to determine the cause of each absence, including through contact with parents; • Evaluate the appropriateness of action taken; • Develop an action plan; and • Cooperate with law enforcement & other authorities, as appropriate.

  40. Attendance, cont. For cumulative absences of 10 or more, at which time the student (ages 6-16) is truant, the school district must (7.6 (a)4iii): • Make a determination of the need for a court referral; • Continue to consult with the parent & involved agencies; • Proceed in accordance with N.J.S.A. 18A:38-28 through 31, Article 3B, Compelling Attendance at School, and other applicable statutes; and (continued)

  41. Attendance, cont. • A court referral may be made as follows (7.6(a)4iv): 1) When unexcused absences are determined to be violations of the compulsory education law & BOE’s attendance policies, the parent may be referred to municipal court. • A written report of the school’s actions regarding the student’s attendance must be forwarded to the municipal court.

  42. Attendance, cont. 2) When there is evidence of a juvenile-family crisis, pursuant to N.J.S.A. 2A:4A-22.g, the student may be referred to Superior Court, Chancery Division, Family Part. • A written report of the school’s regarding the student’s attendance must be forwarded to the juvenile-family crisis intervention unit.

  43. Attendance, cont. • Procedures for receiving & sending schools – 7.8(c) • Receiving school acts on up to 4 cumulative absences • Receiving school reports 5 or more cumulative absences to sending school, which acts in accordance with its BOE’s policies & procedures

  44. Harassment, Intimidation & Bullying (HIB)N.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.7 • Develop, adopt & implement a policy prohibiting HIB on school grounds – 7.7(a) • Develop policy in consultation with parents & other community members, students & school staff – 7.7(a)1 • BOE has local control over content of policy, which must address the components in N.J.S.A. 18A:37-15 & N.J.A.C. 6A:16-7.7(a)2 • Emphasis on expected behaviors, remedial actions for actors & support for victims. • Model Policy & Guidance: http://www.state.nj.us/njded/parents/bully.htm

  45. HIB, cont. • Minimum components of policy – 7.7(a)2: • Statement prohibiting HIB • Definition of HIB • Description of expected behavior • Remedialactions for student or staff offenders • Consequencesfor student or staff offenders

  46. HIB, cont. • Minimum components of policy, cont.: • Reporting procedure, including anonymous reports • Procedure for prompt investigation of violation & complaint reports • Range of responses to incidents, which must include support for victims & corrective actions for related systemic problems

  47. HIB, cont. • Minimum components of policy, cont.: • Statement prohibiting reprisal, retaliationor false accusation against a victim, witness, HIB reporter or one with information about an HIB act • Consequences & remedial action for reprisal or retaliation • Consequences & remedial action for false accusation as a means of retaliation or HIB

  48. HIB, cont. • Minimum components of policy, cont.: • How the policy is to be publicized • A link to HIB policy posted on the homepage of district’s and each school’s website • Annual distribution of HIB policy to staff, students & parents • Web posting of information on district anti-bullying coordinator and school anti-bullying specialist • Prohibition against reprisal, retaliation or false accusations – 7.8(b) • Mandated reports & immunity – 7.8(c)

  49. HIB, cont. • Appropriate responses to HIB that occurs off school grounds when school made aware of the actions or a school administrator should have known • BOE’s may adopt HIB policies with more stringent components • Immunity granted for school personnel who comply with HIB reporting requirements • Possible disciplinary action for an administrator who fails to initiate or conduct an investigation or take sufficient action

  50. HIB, cont. • Annually review the training needs of district staff & volunteers & implement training programs to full- & part-time staff & volunteers consistent with the review – 7.7(d)1 • Information on the HIB policy incorporated into the district’s employee training program –7.7(d)1i • Annually discuss the IHB policy with students – 7.7(d)2 • Annually review the HIB policy& make necessary revisions – 7.7(d)3

More Related