1 / 11

The principles for the oversight of synthetic biology

April 18, 2012 Is the Precautionary Principle Needed? Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars Eric Hoffman Food & Technology Policy Campaigner Friends of the Earth U.S. The principles for the oversight of synthetic biology. Background.

yeva
Download Presentation

The principles for the oversight of synthetic biology

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. April 18, 2012 Is the Precautionary Principle Needed? Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars Eric Hoffman Food & Technology Policy Campaigner Friends of the Earth U.S. The principles for the oversight of synthetic biology

  2. Background • To date, endorsed by 113 organizations from around the world • Civil society groups, social movements, local and indigenous communities, public interest, environmental, scientific, human rights, religious and labor organizations • Written in response to: • Lack of regulation around the rapidly-developing field of synthetic biology • Industry and government calls for “self-regulation”

  3. The Principles for the Oversight of Synthetic Biology • Employ the Precautionary Principle • Require mandatory synthetic biology-specific regulations • Protect public health and worker safety • Protect the environment • Guarantee the right to know and democratic participation • Require corporate accountability and manufacturer liability • Protect economic and environmental justice

  4. I. Employ the Precautionary Principle • Moratorium on the release and commercial use of synthetic organisms, cells, or genomes until government bodies, with full participation of the public, have: • Developed a public interest research agenda • Considered alternatives • Conducted full and inclusive assessments of the implications of this technology, (human health, environmental, and socio-economic impacts of synthetic biology) and preventing harms. • Developed national and international oversight and security mechanisms equipped to keep pace with developments

  5. II. Require mandatory synthetic biology-specific regulations • “Coordinated Framework” for biotechnology outdated, inadequate to deal with novel risks of synthetic biology • Only one synthetic biology-specific regulation in the U.S. today • “Self-regulation” does not allow for public oversight or participation, limits transparency, no legal recourse in the event of harm

  6. III. Protect public health and worker safety • Must prevent known and potential human exposures to synthetic organisms that have not been proven safe • Biotech workers on front line of risks • Efforts to change the human genetic makeup (including the human genome, epigenome and human microbiome) must be prohibited

  7. IV. Protect the environment • Synthetic biology requires the strictest levels of containment: • Physical • Biological • Geographic • Independent environmental risk assessment for each proposed activity or product. • The capacity of each synthetic organism to survive, reproduce, and the fate of its DNA in wild must be studied

  8. V. Guarantee the right-to-know and democratic participation • Public has a right-to-know, right-to-participate in decisions about their environment and livelihoods • Public consultation pre-research to post-release • Legally enforceable right to halt dangerous applications • Labeling of synthetic biology organisms & products necessary for tracking and post-market review

  9. VI. Require corporate accountability and manufacturer liability • Those using synthetic biology must be financially and legally liable for any harm caused to the public, worker health or the environment • If the risk is too great for private investors, it is too great for the public (i.e. loan guarantees)

  10. VII. Protect economic and environmental justice • It is necessary to ensure that the development of synthetic biology does not deepen economic and social injustices • New “bio-economy” – 86% of world’s biomass found in global South • Natural product replacement (i.e. artemisinin, vanilla, rubber, etc.) • Patents & digital bio-piracy

  11. Thank You Eric Hoffman Food & Technology Policy Campaigner Friends of the Earth U.S. ehoffman@foe.org 202.222.0747 www.foe.org

More Related