1 / 23

Legionnaire’s Disease and the Hospitality Industry

Legionnaire’s Disease and the Hospitality Industry. Academy of Hospitality Industry Attorneys Philadelphia Penna. April 26 2008. Rules of the Road. Plaintiff lawyer’s role is to: Simplify Clarify Definitize

river
Download Presentation

Legionnaire’s Disease and the Hospitality Industry

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Legionnaire’s Disease and the Hospitality Industry Academy of Hospitality Industry Attorneys Philadelphia Penna. April 26 2008

  2. Rules of the Road • Plaintiff lawyer’s role is to: • Simplify • Clarify • Definitize • The author wishes to acknowledge Rick Friedman and Patrick Malone who wrote Rules of the Road A Plaintiff Lawyer’s Guide to Proving Liability

  3. Bad Examples Reasonable man standard - vague and abstract - “showing sound judgment” - “rational”

  4. Better Alternative Reasonable man standard - follows recognized rules or customs - simple - clear - definite

  5. Fact Finder Can Act • Confidence comes from simplicity, clearness and certainty • Now the fact finder is armed to act

  6. Establish the Standards from the Beginning • Start putting down the standards from the initial interview • Statutes and regulations • Case law • Contractual relationship between the various parties • Other court rulings • Jury instructions

  7. Additional Standards • Pleadings • Textbooks • Articles • Industry guidelines • Ethical codes • Morals

  8. Standards Definition • Easy to understand • Defense cannot easily dispute • Defendant breached the standard • Significant within framework of the case

  9. Easy to Understand • Convert statutory language to English • Examples • Bromine must be at a certain level • Hotels must keep their place safe for their patrons

  10. Defense Cannot Dispute • Violation of statute or regulation • Case law • Highest duty owed to invitee

  11. Defense Breached • Bromine levels below state standard • Guests got sick and only thing in common was stay at hotel

  12. Important in the Case • Bromine violation key to case • All guests got sick within specified time frame • Only thing in common was their stay at the hotel

  13. Legionnaire’s disease • Bellevue Stratford in 1976 • Outbreak somewhere in world every day • Bacteria • Genus is legionella • Species legionella pneumophila • 15 serogroups one of which is Lp1 • Most common in US

  14. Legionnaire’s disease cont’d • Disease (legionellosis) occurs when infectious dose enters susceptible persons lungs • Inhaling contaminated aerosolized water droplets • Form of community acquired pneumonia • Can also be nosocomial

  15. Legionnaire’s disease cont’d • Common sources • Indoor spa • Jacuzzis • Shower heads • Water faucets • Cooling towers

  16. Outbreak in Ocean City Maryland • Reportable disease in Maryland • Department of Health usually receives first reports from local hospital • Two persons staying at same location who became sick within ten days and have nothing else in common • Disease is very under reported

  17. Maryland Outbreak cont’d • State health officer puts team together • Inspection of premises occurs • Look for possible legionella in sources where usually occurs • Case control study • Not always conducted

  18. Outbreak Investigations in General • Water tests always performed • Maryland cases not yet superchlorinated • Florida cases indoor spa already superchlorinated • Retesting normally done by the State • Meaningless if superchlorinated or superheated

  19. Outbreak Investigation cont’d • State epidemiologist critical • Florida case no legionella found • All tested negative for legionellosis Various methods to test for legionellosis • Urine antigen • Serologically • Sputum

  20. Legal aspects • Extensive discovery • 1400 pages of documents in Florida and Maryland litigation • 15 depositions in Florida litigation

  21. Legal Theories of Recovery • Restatement 343 • Notice issues • Comment (b)-duty to discover • Res ipsa loquitor • Negligence • Excusive control • Plaintiff not negligent

  22. Damages • Compensatory • Punitive

  23. Contact Information • Jules Zacher, Esq. • Medical Arts Bldg., Suite 707 • 1601 Walnut Street, • Philadelphia, PA 19103 • TEL: 215-988-0160 • ZACHERLAW@AOL.Com • www.juleszacher.com • www.legionnairelawyer.com

More Related