1 / 27

Portfolios: Measuring the Art and the Science in Medical Education

Portfolios: Measuring the Art and the Science in Medical Education. Carol Carraccio, MD, MA ABP R 3 P Project February 1, 2007. Objectives:. Become familiar with the contents of a learning portfolio Integrate the components into a holistic approach to learner assessment.

herman
Download Presentation

Portfolios: Measuring the Art and the Science in Medical Education

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Portfolios: Measuring the Art and the Science in Medical Education Carol Carraccio, MD, MA ABP R3P Project February 1, 2007

  2. Objectives: • Become familiar with the contents of a learning portfolio • Integrate the components into a holistic approach to learner assessment

  3. Components of the Portfolio

  4. Global Assessments • Objectives for learning activities • Match items for assessment to the specific learning objectives for the given clinical experience/rotation • Example: Demonstrating the ability to manage a ventilator while in the PICU

  5. Global Assessments • Benchmarks for Competencies • Performance indicators and standards, based on learner’s level of experience, that define competence in each of the ACGME domains • Example: Patient care requires gathering essential and accurate information • Benchmark: Perform a detailed and accurate PE with sensitivity to developmental, psychosocial and cultural issues • Standards: PGY1s expected to do for routine patients, PGY2s for most patients and PGY3s for almost all patients regardless of acuity/complexity

  6. Components of the Portfolio

  7. Task-oriented Assessment Tools • Structured tools • Complement global evaluations • Examples: • History & Physical Checklist or mini-CEX • Journal Club evaluation that addresses specific criteria and standards

  8. Components of the Portfolio

  9. Learning Plans • Individual learning plans • Require mentor guidance • Incorporate feedback from others and self-assessment • Creation of learning objectives and strategies to achieve them • Should ultimately become a living document that serves as the learner’s roadmap

  10. Components of the Portfolio

  11. Journal • Debrief from clinical experiences • Confidential vs assigned readers • Assigned by resident • Assigned by program director

  12. Components of the Portfolio

  13. Threaded Discussion • Ongoing bidirectional feedback between mentor and mentee • Recorded within the portfolio unlike email which is deleted

  14. Components of the Portfolio

  15. Critical Incidents • Instant evaluations documenting particularly positive or negative behaviors • Learner responds with a written “reflection” on how this incident will change future practice

  16. Components of the Portfolio

  17. Multi-source Feedback • Solicits feedback from all stakeholders • Delivered to residents in aggregate form by categories of evaluators • Mentors guide residents in incorporating this feedback into self-assessments and learning plans

  18. Components of the Portfolio

  19. Projects • Engage learners in tasks of real world practice • Address benchmarks for competencies that are not well demonstrated in the context of routine clinical care • Examples • Personal/professional quality improvement project • System errors activity such as root cause analysis

  20. Components of the Portfolio

  21. Logs • Conference attendance • ACGME logs • Continuity Clinic • Procedure

  22. Building the Portfolio Integration of the Components

  23. Intended Learning (Curriculum & Assessment) • Learning objectives for clinical skills • Benchmarks for competencies • Global &Task oriented assessments

  24. Reflective Learning • Journal Writing • Threaded Discussions • Self-Assessment • Learning Plans

  25. Putting It All Together …. My Reflective Learning My Intended Learning • Multi-source feedback • Critical • Incidents • Logs

  26. My Professional Development • Maintenance of Certification • Continuous Personal & Professional • Development

  27. Supporting the Formation of Professionals My Reflective Learning My Intended Learning My Professional Development

More Related