1 / 69

Scenario Building for Successful Organizational Change

Scenario Building for Successful Organizational Change. MPA 8002 The Structure and Theory of Human Organization Richard M. Jacobs, OSA, Ph.D. For Bolman & Deal (1997). managing and leading organizations is a matter of utilizing four frames to diagnose organizational functioning.

adamdaniel
Download Presentation

Scenario Building for Successful Organizational Change

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Scenario Building for Successful Organizational Change MPA 8002 The Structure and Theory of Human Organization Richard M. Jacobs, OSA, Ph.D.

  2. For Bolman & Deal (1997)... • managing and leading organizations is a matter of utilizing four frames to diagnose organizational functioning

  3. Structurally, managers and leaders... 1. set goals and policies under conditions of uncertainty 2. achieve a “delicate balance” in allocating scarce resources across organizational entities 3. motivate, coordinate, and control large, diverse group of subordinates

  4. From a human resources view, managers and leaders... 1. help individuals and groups develop a shared sense of direction and purpose 2. balance task and process goals 3. endeavor to make group work both satisfying and efficient

  5. Politically, managers and leaders... 1. confront workplace politics 2. apply ethics in the decision-making process 3. wield power effectively 4. act with authority

  6. Using symbols, managers and leaders... 1. attend carefully to socializing new members into the organization 2. emphasize diversity in ideas and approaches to problem solving 3. manage and lead by example 4. develop and use code language to communicate organizational purpose

  7. For Bolman & Deal, the goal is... • for managers and leaders to give appropriate emphasis to the positives associated with each frame…

  8. Strengths of the structural frame... …is rational and objective, data driven …uses logic to shape policies, procedures, division of labor, and span of control …is action oriented …provides for accountability

  9. Strengths of the human resources frame... …personal …practical …addresses fundamental human needs and interests

  10. Strengths of the political frame... …realistic …practical …addresses the reality of mixed motives, conflict, and power struggles present in the workplace …highlights the need for principled reflection and ethical action

  11. Strengths of the symbolic frame... …personal …illuminates the importance of creating and sustaining belief and meaning …inspiring, meaningful, motivational …focuses on the bonds uniting individuals into cohesive groups that pursue a shared purpose

  12. While simultaneously... • managers and leaders to avoid each frame’s limitations…

  13. Structural frame limitations... …impersonal and bureaucratic: views workers as functionaries …overly simplistic …pessimistic about human nature …inflexible and rigid for decision making …overestimates the power of authority …neglects fundamental human, political, and cultural variables

  14. Human resources frame limitations... …naïve in its assessment of human nature …overly optimistic about integrating people, process, and technology …not realistic for a fast-changing environment …neglects the power of structure …neglects the realities of conflict and scarce resources

  15. Political frame limitations ... …impersonal in dealing with people …cynical view of human nature …assumes conflict and power struggles …reinforces conflict and mistrust …sacrifices opportunities for rational discourse, collaboration toward shared goals, and hope in a positive future

  16. Symbolic frame limitations... …an overly abstract, vague, and elusive concept …impractical for use in the workplace …can easily be manipulated

  17. Using frame analysis positively... • effective managers and leaders engage in activities… …focused by their primary concerns

  18. Using the structural frame... …scientists effective managers and leaders are …planners …social architects …good data …honest analysis whose primary concerns are …creative designs …the best process

  19. Using human resources theory... …personable and warm …thoughtful and kind effective managers and leaders are …servants …catalysts for growth …challenging growth …providing support whose primary concerns are …expanding roles …engendering and sustaining good will

  20. Using political theory... …savvy and smart …polished effective managers and leaders are …clear-headed …advocates …coalition-building …negotiating gray areas whose primary concerns are …upholding the common good

  21. Using symbolic theory... …prophets effective managers and leaders are …poets …priests …substance …framing experience whose primary concerns are …inspiring …pointing a way

  22. Using frame analysis negatively... • ineffective managers and leaders engage in activities… …focused by their primary concerns

  23. Abusing the structural frame... …petty tyrants ineffective managers and leaders are …self-absorbed …self-interested …micro-managing whose primary concerns are …“snoopervising” …fault finding …ruling by fiat …issuing memos

  24. Abusing human resources frame... …linguini-spined ineffective managers and leaders are …wimps …pushovers …how people feel …avoiding conflict whose primary concerns are …letting others decide …allowing events to take their course

  25. Abusing the political frame... …poker-faced ineffective managers and leaders are …con-artists …hustlers …self-interest …plausible alibis whose primary concerns are …masking fraud …deception

  26. Abusing the symbolic frame... …fanatics ineffective managers and leaders are …fools …full of “b.s.” …self-preservation …style whose primary concerns are …images …propagandizing

  27. The strength of “reframing”... …is its focus upon the multiple uses of organizational processes  strategic planning  goal setting  decision making  communicating  reorganizing  meetings  motivating  evaluating

  28. However... • these frames, as well as the interpretations they offer, imply that... …control is a fact... when it is an illusion …sensemaking is prospective… when it is retrospective …understanding is predictable… not confusion (Weick, 1995)

  29. The managerial/leadership reality... • the facts associated with life in human organizations... …run contrary to common perceptions and opinion...

  30. • First: turbulence, not stability, characterizes organizational life.

  31. • Second: people in organizations possess pluralistic, not unitary, views about organizations.

  32. • Third: intuition, not rationality, proves to be of greater value in the decision-making process.

  33. • Fourth: managers/leaders make few, not many, decisions.

  34. the consequence of this organizational reality is that managing and leading human organizations is more like... …“white-water rafting” (Sergiovanni, 1992) …“muddling through” mazes of messes (Lindblom, 1979) …“garbage can decision making” (Cohen, March, & Olsen, 1992)

  35. MANAGING/LEADING ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE “...it should be considered that nothing is more difficult to handle, more doubtful of success, or more dangerous to manage, than to put oneself at the head of introducing new orders. For the introducer has all those who benefit from the old orders as enemies, and he has lukewarm defenders in all those who might benefit from the new orders.” Machiavelli, The Prince, 1985, p. 23

  36. The question, then, is... What does successful leadership management and involve and require?

  37. A lesson to remember... • successful managers and leaders... don't seek to make people happy by doing things right

  38. successful managers and leaders... earn respect by doing right things

  39. For managers and leaders... • the challenge is not so much “reframing” the problems impacting organizational functioning (Bolman & Deal, 1997)... …and actingbased on calculations and contingencieswhether to manage/lead through participation, delegation, selling, or telling (Hersey & Blanchard, 1977)

  40. instead, managing/leading human organizations is a matter of the human intellect and creative spirit… …a process of “scenario building” …in an overall effort directed at improving organizational functioning

  41. Scenario building... • a methodology to assess organizational functioning... ...by developing unitary solutions (i.e., “scenarios”) designed from an accurate diagnosis of the situation (i.e., “framing”)

More Related