1 / 30

The grammar gap

The grammar gap. Dick Hudson Liverpool February 2010. Plan. Grammar in a normal world How we got our grammar gap Curriculum reform The problem The symptoms The diagnosis The remedy. 1. A normal world. Everyone needs some “knowledge about language” ( KAL ) explicit knowledge

ward
Download Presentation

The grammar gap

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The grammar gap Dick Hudson Liverpool February 2010

  2. Plan • Grammar in a normal world • How we got our grammar gap • Curriculum reform • The problem • The symptoms • The diagnosis • The remedy

  3. 1. A normal world • Everyone needs some “knowledge about language” (KAL) • explicit knowledge • with established terminology • Why? • like biology: for interest and self-understanding • like literacy: for learning more • in L1 • in foreign languages

  4. What is KAL? • External KAL: own language and others: • history • geography • Internal KAL: • varieties, e.g. standard/non-standard • pronunciation, e.g. IPA • vocabulary, e.g. synonymy, hyponymy, cognate • grammar.

  5. Grammar in a normal world • ideas • e.g. compositionality and irregularity • categories • e.g. word classes • skill in analysing examples • skill in using analyses • in learning new language • in using old language

  6. Grammar in a normal world • Accepted as part of the curriculum • like literacy, numeracy, IT. • Informed by research on grammar. • Taught by best methods • systematically • interestingly • relevantly

  7. Where is this normal world? • Ancient India, Greece and Rome • Mediaeval Arabic civilization • 18th and 19th century Britain • France, Spain, Italy, … • Russia, Bulgaria, …

  8. 2. How we got our grammar gap • At one time, English education was normal. • ‘Grammar schools’ taught Latin and other languages, including their grammar • the ‘trivium’ in mediaeval universities was: • logic • rhetoric • grammar • Grammar survived till the 1960s

  9. GCE O-level English 1950

  10. But between 1900 and 1950 … • HE: No research on language • except phonetics • No teaching of ‘language’ • except OE and philology • Schools: Traditional grammar taught and tested • but grammar for English was ‘Latinate’. • ‘ [it is] impossible at the present juncture to teach English grammar in the schools for the simple reason that no-one knows exactly what it is ’ (Board of Education 1921) • so grammar was marginal – one optional question

  11. The turning point: the 1960s • The end of grammar teaching in schools • first in English • then in Foreign languages • The start of grammar research in universities • Quirk • Halliday • Chomsky

  12. 3. Curriculum reform • Since 1990, grammar is back in the curriculum: • but not old-fashioned Latinate grammar • linguists have had a lot of influence • The National Curriculum • for English (1990, 1995, 1999) • for foreign languages (1990, 1999)

  13. and of course, … • A-level English language appeared in 1985

  14. What Ofqual expects in ALEL: • 3.5 AS specifications should require candidates to show broad knowledge and understanding of … • the characteristic speech sounds and intonation patterns (phonetics and phonology) • the vocabulary of English, including the origins, meanings and usage of words (lexis) • the forms and structures of words, phrases, clauses, sentences and texts in speech and writing (morphology, grammar and discourse) … • 3.6 In addition, A level specifications should require students to show deeper knowledge and understanding of … the following frameworks …: • phonology and phonetics, lexis, morphology, grammar, discourse …

  15. 4. The problem • Young teachers don’t know grammar • Schools didn’t need to teach grammar 1960-1990. • Most university English and FL depts still don’t teach about grammar. • So since 1980 teachers have had to teach content that they probably didn’t learn either at school or at university.

  16. 5. The symptoms • In 1986, educational linguists were worried. • So Tom Bloor constructed a simple test • for Aston University French Dept • and UCL Linguistics Dept • to be taken by new undergraduates: • 63 in language subjects (Aston, UCL) • 175 in other subjects (Aston) • one part involved grammar KAL:

  17. The grammar test • From the sentence below give ONE example of each of the grammatical items requested and write it in the space provided. NB You may select the same word(s} more than once if appropriate. • Materials are delivered to the factory by a supplier, who usually has no technical knowledge, but who happens to have the right contacts.

  18. The items requested • verb, noun, … • countable noun, relative pronoun, auxiliary verb, … • passive verb, past participle, …

  19. % of students who ‘gapped’ 44% of linguists couldn’t find an auxiliary verb 85% of non-linguists couldn’t find a passive verb

  20. A simple index of grammatical KAL • Averagegaps per student (max: 15): • linguists (inc French): 3.02 • non-linguists: 7.45 • Conclusions: • linguists had serious gaps • but they were much better than non-linguists • they must have learned it from A-level FL

  21. What happened next? • NB from 1990 official policy requires grammar to be taught • but NOT tested • Did this reverse the trend? • 1992, 1994: Charles Alderson at Lancaster • tested students of French and of Linguistics

  22. 1986, 1992, 1994

  23. 2009 • Charles Alderson and I invited colleagues in LAGB and BAAL to repeat the test. • It was taken by 659 students at 11 HEIs • Including Aston and UCL

  24. A typical FL undergraduate in 2009 French and Spanish at A-level ‘a describing word’?

  25. How do students feel about it?

  26. 1986 - 2009 Aston French: 11 UCL Lingx: 18

  27. Moreover, other HEIs are worse UCL BSc

  28. Effects of A-level • Foreign language A-level does teach grammar • 1986: it added 5 points to score • 2009: it only adds 1 or 2 points • English language makes no difference

  29. 6. The diagnosis • Students aren’t learning grammar at school • in spite of the curriculum • But some grammar is being taught • So official policy is not working • Why not? Maybe because teachers • are anxious • don’t really understand • can easily avoid it

  30. 7. The remedy • Official policy should test grammar. • Ofsted should ensure it’s taught well. • Linguistics and Eng Lang graduates should become school teachers. • Linguistics depts should teach English grammar for text analysis.

More Related