E N D
1. and Challenges Faced By Women Artists in Early Modern Era Artemisia Gentileschi
2. “Why Have There Been No Great Artists?” Linda Nochlin (1973)
Why?
Women artists are not worthy of scholarly attention because there have been no “great” artists with works of “quality”
Women have obligations to family before being a painter
There were great artists, but their works were “marginal”- more decorative and pleasing than serious, high art
They are women
3. Artemisia Gentileschi
4. Artemisia Gentileschi July 8, 1593 in Rome, Italy
Orazio Gentileschi & Prudentia Ottaviano Monotone
Baroque artist
“Caravaggisti”- follower of Michelangelo Merisida Caravaggio
“First significant woman painter in western art”
Began painting at 12
In domestic seclusion
5. Agostino Tassi
6. Agostino Tassi Landscape and marine painter
Was receiving major commissions for fresco decoration in Roman palaces
Worked with Orazio at Palazzo Quirinale (1611)
Sued by his sister for adultery and incest with his sister-in-law (had children with her)
Rumored that he paid to have his wife in Florence killed the year before
7. Trial of 1612 Orazio took Tassi to court for rape of Artemisia
Tassi denied rape and sexual relationship with Artemisia
Artemisia subjected herself to torture (sibyl) to prove her point
Tassi convicted of “presumed defloration”
Jailed for only 8 months and case eventually dismissed
Artemisia was “doubly raped”
8. Artemisia
9. Artemisia Directed by Agnčs Merlet
Rated NC-17 in US, later appealed to R
Portrayed Artemisia as a beautiful seducer, a whore, and a creepily perverted peeping tom
“Sexy. Defiant. Provocative. Her passion for art changed the face of history.”
Over 20 out of 49 keywords had to do with sex, nudity, rape, pornography, or something otherwise sexual
10. What’s Wrong? Story of Artemisia and Agostino was not romance material
She was raped
There was no romantic relationship afterwards- she allowed for sexual relationship to happen because she believed she was engaged
They did not repeatedly confess love for each other
She did not seduce him, did not “return for more” after her rape
11. She did not use sketches of nude men to lure Tassi into teaching her, and was not obsessed with sex
Does not have as much mastery over male anatomy as female anatomy- can be seen from the drapery that covers Holofernes’s torso in Judith Slaying Holofernes
12. In court, Artemisia did not lie to defend Agostino’s innocence and bear torture to keep him from becoming incriminated
Asserted his guilt harshly, putting herself out voluntarily for torture
Agostino did not confess to his crimes to make the torture to Artemisia stop
Argued that she was a whore and defended his innocence
13. One of the evidences the defendant gave was her painting, Judith Slaying Holofernes, to show her “evilness” in trying to falsely accuse his client
It was completed after her trial, and in Florence
They also gave the nude drawings of men as evidence, but even if she did sketch nude men, they were not used in the trial
14. Renaissance rendition of Romeo and Juliet
The movie merely portrayed Artemisia as a lustful, sheltered teenager who found wild romance with an older man, their relationship cruelly torn apart by her unhappy father
Movie focused more on the nonexistent love affair than on her paintings
Viewers take away misinterpretations of her history and character
15. In Conclusion… Artemisia Gentileschi, raped once in the 17th century by Agostino Tassi, was raped again in the 20th century by the unjust representation of her character and life
16. Challenges Women Artists Faced in Early Modern Era There were many social “norms” women were expected to follow
Women must first meet obligations with the family
ie: get married, raise kids, keep the house
It is improper for young girls to go out without a chaperone
Cannot observe as many outside art as males
Females may not look at male nudes
Blocks a major section of popular art
Women must retain their virginity as a show of their chastity and honor
Females are inferior to men in general
Not given the same respect when being assessed
17. Works Cited Adams, Laurie Schneider. Art and Psychoanalysis. New York: HarperCollins, 1994.
Johnson, Tony W., and Ronald F. Reed. Philosophical Documents in Education. Boston: Pearson, 2008.
Nochlin, Linda. Women, Art, and Power and Other Essays. New York: Harper & Row Publishers, 1988.
Opfell, Olga S. Special Visions. North Carolina: McFarland & Company, Inc., 1991.
Slatkin, Wendy. Women Artists in History. Upper Saddler River: Prentice Hall, 2001.
The Internet Movie Database. “Artemisia.” IMDb.com, Inc. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0123385 (accessed May 12, 2010).
Van Cleave, Rachel A. “Sex, Lies, and Honor in Italian Rape Law.” Suffolk University Law School. http://www.law.suffolk.edu/highlights/stuorgs/lawreview/docs/VanCleave.pdf (accessed May 12, 2010).