210 likes | 370 Views
Willis Environmental Risk Practice Decisions Involve Risk Understand the System Current Status of the Market P
E N D
1.
Insurance Program & Contracts Management
Insurance, Indemnity and Surety
Jim Gilley, Senior VP
Environmental Risk Practice
(865) 583-3754 – dl, 607-5663 - cell
James.gilley@willis.com
www.willis.com/homepage.aspx
www.willis.com/services/environmental/north%20america.aspx
W
National Contracts Management Association
NCMA - ET
3. Willis – Environmental Risk Practice
Specialty Unit within Willis – divided into two separate structures
Direct Client Service Unit
Internal Resource Group
Our Group - direct placement of all P&C lines of insurance and contract surety for environmental/construction contractors & WM service companies
We work as a consultant to our client’s Risk / Contracts Management and Business Development Teams
Contract review and consulting
Design and negotiate insurance programs – Professional/CPL, work comp, general/excess liability, equipment, international
Project specific placements – Guaranteed Fixed Price Remediation (GFPR), WRAP, Cost Cap, Site Pollution Liability, Liability Buy-Outs
Surety – Bid, Performance, Payment & Closure/Post Closure Bonds
4. TIMELINE: What I have been doing
5. II. Decisions Involve Risk!
6. Understand the System Broker
Represents the client (fee based or commission)
Results are dependent upon skill sets and company capabilities
Agent
Represents the insurance carrier (commission based)
Limited resources; dependant upon carrier services
Carriers
Risk Appetite (Limited in the Env./WM sector)
No uniformity of professional/CPL, project specific forms
Underwriters
Attitude (insurance - pressure to produce; surety - apathy, no pressure to produce)
Motivators - tied to understanding risks, leverage (negotiation skills are critical)
7. Current Status of the Market Insurance
Return to soft pricing market
Underwriting discipline & engineering reviews (not like the late 90’s)
Limited carrier market for Env./WM companies
Willingness to modify form provisions (Reasonable)
Underwriters desire to write more lines of insurance (leverage)
Little impact from Katrina (for env./WM companies)
Good time to transfer risk (low cost)
Bonding - (Surety Association of America – 2/7/06 stats)
$4.3bil market that is not growing
Market consolidations – St. Paul Travelers has 33% of market
Combined Loss Ratio – 117% (2000 – 2004), strict underwriting, co-ins. provisions, capacity restrictions
Env. Surety –
Strong balance sheet required
Expect a collateral requirement (30 - 70% LOC)
Higher rates than construction work
Corporate and personal indemnity
8. III. P&C and Environmental Insurance 101 Professional Liability
Pays sums that the insured is legally obligated to pay as damages because of an act, error or omission resulting from the rendering of professional services. (Errors and Omissions Insurance - E&O) many endorsements are required
Contractors Pollution Liability (CPL) “not PL”
Pays for 3rd party bodily injury, property damage and clean-up costs which the insured is legally obligated to pay due to sudden and accidental environmental impairment resulting from work performed by or on behalf of the insured. endorsements required
General Liability exclusions negate coverage for most env. ops and projects
Contractual liability*
Products & Completed Operations*
Premises & Operations
Personal & Advertising
Damage to rented facilities
Medical Expenses
9. P&C and Environmental Insurance 101 Workers Compensation
Provides statutory limits of insurance for worker injury/disease claims
State programs – excluded from the insurance program (OH, WA, WVa, ND, WY)
Experience mod (<1.00)
Rates vary significantly by state and class code
Automobile
Liability and Physical Damage
Hired & Non-Owned (Liability & PD)
Mixed and Haz waste transit
Contractors Equipment/Property
Insurance for leased and rented equipment, tools
Equipment coverage is limited to a per program and item maximum
Coverage for business property/EDP
10. P&C and Environmental Insurance 101
Excess Liability - Provides excess liability limits over the following coverages (if properly designed)
Professional & Contractors Pollution Liability
General Liability
Automobile Liability
Employers Liability - Workers Compensation
Project specific placements
Remediation Cost Cap (Not liability Insurance)
Guaranteed Fixed Price Remediation (GFPR)
Addresses known contamination
Pays cost above agreed remediation cost (approved plan or SOW)
Applies to individual sites or portfolios
Underwritten on a multiple years basis
SIR and co-payment provisions
11. P&C and Environmental Insurance 101 Pollution Legal Liability
Provides coverage for pollution emanating at or from a facility or site
Covers pre-existing unknown pollution
Covers new releases of pollution (on and off-site)
Covers known contamination in excess of SIR (trigger levels)
3rd party on and off site pollution liabilities (BI, PD, clean-up costs)
Legal expenses, business interruption, NODS, NRDA, transit
Other Types of Environmental Insurance
Liability Buy-Out (Finite Risk)
WRAP (Owner/Contractor Controlled Program)
RCRA financial assurance
Closure/Post-Closure
UST, Asbestos, Mold, Marine, Products
12. TIMELINE: Environmental Insurance & Legislation
13. TIMELINE: Environmental Insurance & Legislation
14. TIMELINE: Environmental Insurance & Legislation
15. IV. Contract Bonds Contract Bid, Performance and Payment Bonds
Decontamination & Decommissioning Projects
Environmental Remediation Projects
Construction Projects
Closure/Post Closure Financial Assurance
(you should never see contract bonds being required for professional services)
16. Quick Course – Bid, Performance & Payments Bonds Proposal or Pre-Qualification
Surety reference letter – bonding capability
Not an actual guarantee (subject to’s)
Bid & Award
__% bid security (20%)
Form – surety bond, cashiers check, ILOC
Failure to enter into contract – bond default
Performance/Payment Bond
Performance – to SOW as contracted at the awarded dollar amount
Payment - obligation to pay subcontractors
17. Surety – Information required for consideration
Contractor Questionnaire
Corporate financials (2 yr. + interim)
Personal financials of major stockholders (over 10% interest)
Bank reference on credit line
Current work-in-progress report
Copies of SOW, bond requirement, bond forms and contract specifications
Corporate presentation (narrative – historical, operations, management, future, brochures “support the cause”)
18. V. Contract Key Components Insurance Requirements (Liability lines, WC, Eq/Prop)
Indemnity Requirements
Bonding Requirements (Bid, Performance, Payment)
Penalties
Warranties
Goal - “Eliminate, Minimize and Transfer Risk” –
********IN AND OUT OF YOUR CONTRACT******
19. Contracts - General Rules of Engagement for Project Insurance Requirements Everything is Negotiable (basic assumption)
Always:
Modify T&C (insurance & indemnity)
Lowest limits of insurance possible (don’t tell!)
Penalties - negotiate them out of the contract
Warranty period – modify what is covered and for how long
Engage broker in contract reviews and negotiations
20. Contracts - General Rules of Engagement for Project Surety Requirements
#1 Rule – Negotiate it out of the contract
#2 Rule – Reduce the requirement
#3 Rule – Timing (...the moment the GO bid decision is made)
Options – LOC (= to quarterly revenue), Hold-back (__% of monthly billings), flow down to subcontractor or up to jv partner
Remove warranty period (or reduce to 12 month max.)
Require subs to bond back
Anticipate both corporate and personal indemnity agreements… and collateral requirements (% of project value)
21. Existing Contracts Review for Compliance (liability - maintenance requirements)
At mod., rebid or anytime during the contract term… re-negotiate T&C’s
Make sure that subcontractor certificates of insurance are correct and current (Tracking system)
Any contract expansions (SOW, length of project) use rates to calculate insurance costs to add to project modification pricing
22. Subcontractors Flow-down contract requirements to subs
Modify your subcontracts to transfer more risk to the subcontractors
Check certificates to ensure that subcontractors are meeting requirements
Request sub EMR - past 3 years (safety)
Named as an additional insured (on their policies)
Minimum Carrier Rating – Best A