An imperial presidency
1 / 14

An Imperial Presidency? - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on

An Imperial Presidency?. The Executive vs. Congress and the Courts. I. Can Congress Check the President?. What predicts Presidential success in Congress? Presidential popularity has little effect – Only a slight effect in the Senate, none in the House

I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'An Imperial Presidency?' - liang

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
An imperial presidency

An Imperial Presidency?

The Executive vs. Congress and the Courts

I can congress check the president
I. Can Congress Check the President?

  • What predicts Presidential success in Congress?

    • Presidential popularity has little effect – Only a slight effect in the Senate, none in the House

    • Partisanship: Same-party members more supportive

      • Effect is largest for first-term Congresspeople

      • Effect is largest during non-election years

    • Issue Type: Foreign policy success more likely than domestic policy success

    • Proaction vs. Status Quo – President is more successful at stopping unfriendly bills than passing friendly ones

B what predicts executive success in the bureaucracy
B. What predicts executive success in the bureaucracy?

  • Legislative Vetoes: Congress attaches strings to delegation of power

    • Declared unconstitutional – INS vs. Chadha

    • Hundreds of new legislative vetoes passed since INS vs. Chadha! – Effective because Congress refuses to delegate authority when Presidents ignore legislative vetoes

2 executive orders
2. Executive Orders

  • Presidents issue more executive orders under united government!

  • Orders rarely overturned – because Presidents don’t issue them if they anticipate a veto-proof majority against them

C war powers does congress have a role
C. War Powers: Does Congress Have a Role?

  • Declaration of War vs. Commander-in-Chief: Which clause governs initiation of combat?

    • Early 19th Century: Congress authorizes military action short of war against France, Barbary Pirates, American Indians, etc.

    • Late 19th Century – Early 20th Century: Presidents begin deploying small detachments of Marines without advance approval from Congress

    • 1950: Truman calls the Korean War a “police action” and says no declaration of war is needed

    • 1989: Bush invades Panama without asking Congress for authority

    • 1991: Bush argues that UN Security Council approval eliminates need for Congressional approval (then asks for it anyway). Clinton repeats the argument for UN/NATO approval in 1994 (Haiti and Bosnia) and 1999 (Kosovo)

2 war powers act
2. War Powers Act

  • Enacted in 1973

  • Requires President to notify Congress and get permission to continue hostilities beyond 60 days

  • Repudiated as unconstitutional by all Presidents since

  • No military action has ever been curtailed by the War Powers Act

3 the power of the purse
3. The “Power of the Purse”

  • Congress must approve all expenditures

  • Congress can stop wars by cutting off funds

  • Process is rarely used

    • Never used during war – No one will vote to leave US troops stranded, and Presidents threaten not withdraw them before money runs out

    • Used to prevent escalation: Southeast Asia (1973), Central America (1980s – circumvented)

  • Some argue process is unconstitutional: Reagan rejected constitutionality of Boland Amendment

Ii can courts check the president
II. Can Courts Check the President?

  • The power of judicial review: limited by Court’s inability to enforce decisions

    • Jefferson threatens to ignore the Court – Marbury vs. Madison as a strategic decision

    • Jackson ignores the Court – Worcester vs. Georgia

    • Lincoln ignores the court repeatedly – Dred Scott, Ex parte Merryman

    • Nonenforcement is extremely rare: requires public opposition to Court legitimacy

B limits on the court s power
B. Limits on the Court’s Power

  • Case or Controversy – Real dispute must exist; no advisory opinions

  • Stare Decisis – Respect precedent

  • Political Question Doctrine – Avoid questions best decided through political process or by another branch

  • Comity – Treat other branches as equals (avoid interfering in internal processes)

  • Jurisdiction – Congress can strip Court of jurisdiction over some cases

  • Standing – Parties must have specific personal stake in outcome

C courts as a check on the executive bureaucracy
C. Courts as a Check on the Executive Bureaucracy

  • Courts now follow doctrine of deference on regulatory decisions

  • Actual amount of deference seems to depend on Presidential popularity

D effectiveness of the court vs presidential power
D. Effectiveness of the Court vs. Presidential Power

  • Domestic policy – Effective: Truman’s Seizure of Steel Mills, Nixon’s Tapes, etc.

  • Foreign Policy – Ineffective

    • Treaties must be Constitutional – But not one has ever been struck down

    • War powers limited – But political question doctrine normally prevents resolution

    • Extreme deference on national security – willingness to base decisions on unknown secret information

Iii conclusions
III. Conclusions

  • Domestic policy – Presidential power highly limited

    • Presidential programs easily blocked by Congress, also subject to Court review

    • President does have some ability to prevent disliked domestic policy through nonenforcement or veto power

  • Foreign policy – President is virtually unconstrained