1 / 11

Propositions and Arguments

Propositions and Arguments. What is a proposition ?. A proposition is a predicative sentence that only contains a subject and a predicate S is P. Which of these sentences express propositions?. Sydney is north of Melbourne. Is Edinburgh in Scotland?

jgain
Download Presentation

Propositions and Arguments

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Propositions and Arguments

  2. What is a proposition? • A proposition is a predicativesentencethatonlycontainsasubject and a predicate S is P.

  3. Which of these sentences express propositions? • Sydney is north of Melbourne. • Is Edinburgh in Scotland? • The moon is made of swiss cheese. • Did you see the eclipse? • Whatan eclipse! • Would that I were good at logic. • Look at the eclipse. • I wish that I were good at logic. • 7+12=23

  4. Arguments • Argumentsineverydaysituationstakeplacebetweenpeople. • Argumentsgivereasonsforbelievingthetruth of a proposition. • Logicstudiestheinformationcontent of thesearguments.

  5. An argument is a list of propositions, called the • premises, • followed by a word such as ‘therefore’, or ‘so’, and then another proposition,calledtheconclusion. • The reasonforacceptingtheinformationintheconclusion is basedonthepremises. • If everything is determined, people are not free. Premise • Peopleare free. Premise • So not everything is determined. Conclusion

  6. Rule Rule Individualinstances Individualinstances INDUCTIVE Arguments DEDUCTIVE Arguments

  7. Rule Most Hungarianscommittaxfraud. Gábor is Hungarian. So, Gábor is likelytocommittaxfraud. • The link betweenthepremisesweaker. • The truth of thepremisesonlymakesthetruthoftheconclusion , butdoesnotguaranteeit • The conclusion is onlypossiblytrue. • TheseargumentsareInductivearguments. Individualinstances P(A|B) = P(A|B) = INDUCTIVE Arguments

  8. AllHungarianscommittaxfraud. Gábor is Hungarian. So, Gábor commitstaxfraud. The premisessupportthetruth of theconclusion: it is impossibleforthepremisesto be true and theconclusionto be false. Thesearecalleddeductivearguments. Rule Individualinstances Peoplecommitingtaxfraud Hungarians DEDUCTIVE Arguments

  9. Valid arguments • An argument is valid if and only if whenever the premises are true, so is the conclusion. • In other words, it is impossible for the premises to be true while at the same time theconclusionis false.

  10. Soundarguments • An argument is sound, just in the case where it is valid, and, in addition, the premises are • all true. So, the conclusion of a sound argument must also be true. • soundnessappealsto the truth of the matter.

  11. Valid ArgumentScheme Allbatsarebirds. H Allbirdsfly. HNotsound ----------------------------------- Thereforeallbatsfly. I Allwhalesaremammals. I Allmammalshavehearts.ISound ---------------------------------- Allwhaleshavehearts. I c A B C All A’s areB’s AllB’sareC’s ----------------- SoallA’s are C’s

More Related