1 / 51

Update: Hexavalent Chromium Cr(VI)

Update: Hexavalent Chromium Cr(VI). Drawn from the Preambles and Training Materials from the National Office and Regions 5 and 6. Purpose. Present an overview of the major provisions of OSHA’s Cr(VI) standard (71 FR 10100, February 28, 2006).

heloise
Download Presentation

Update: Hexavalent Chromium Cr(VI)

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Update: Hexavalent Chromium Cr(VI) Drawn from the Preambles and Training Materials from the National Office and Regions 5 and 6

  2. Purpose Present an overview of the major provisions of OSHA’s Cr(VI) standard (71 FR 10100, February 28, 2006). Note: This presentation is for training purposes only. Consult the Federal Register on OSHA’s web site for the complete requirements of this standard.

  3. What is Hexavalent Chromium? • Toxic form of chromium metal that is generally man-made • Used in many industrial applications primarily for its anti-corrosive properties • Can be created during certain “hot” work processes where the original form of chromium was not hexavalent

  4. Is Chrome a Carcinogen or Necessary Element? • Chrome III is an essential nutrient for maintaining blood glucose levels • Chrome VI is classified as a known human carcinogen

  5. Operations with Cr(VI) Exposure • Electroplating • Welding/cutting/torching/grinding painted surfaces • Welding/cutting/grinding stainless steel, chrome alloys and even carbon steel • Applying/removing coatings with chrome • Glass production • Chemical synthesis • Chromium catalyst users • Printing ink production

  6. Routes of Exposure • Inhalation of dusts, mists, or fumes created during processes involving the use of Cr(VI) compounds or hot processes that cause the formation of Cr(VI) • Eye or skin contact with powder, dusts or liquids containing Cr(VI) with skin absorption possible • Ingestion through contamination of food and drink (controversy over extent of issue)

  7. Major Health Effects • Lung cancer • Nasal septum ulcerations and perforations • Asthma • Skin ulcers • Allergic and irritant contact dermatitis

  8. History of Exposure Limits • 1943 ANSI standard was the source of OSHA’s 1971 standard of 1mg/10 m3 Cr(III) or 52 µg/m3 CR(VI) • Mounting evidence of carcinogenicity • 1974 by ACGIH • 1975 by NIOSH • 1984 by EPA • 1990 by IARC

  9. Occupational Exposure Limits • NIOSH REL • 0.001 mg Cr VI/M3 10-hr TWA • ACGIH TLV • Water-Soluble Cr VI compounds as Cr 0.05 mg/M3 TWA • Insoluble Cr VI compounds as Cr 0.01 mg/M3 TWA • ACGIH BEI • Total chromium in urine BEIs (2) for Chrome VI water soluble fume

  10. History of New Standard • In 1993 the Health Research Group petitioned for ETS of 0.5 µg/m3 • OSHA unable to demonstrate “grave danger” • In 1997 HRG sued to complete rulemaking process and lost • In 2002 HRG sued to complete rulemaking process and won • Proposed rule to be issued 10/4/04 • Final rule to be issued 1/18/06 • Final rule was issued 2/28/06

  11. Steps to Complete a Rule • Review all research on health effects ** • Peer review of OSHA review • Develop risk assessment ** • Justify significance of risk assessment • Perform Economic Analysis and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis with SBREFA Assessment – 6 issues for each potential PEL ** • Submit to OMB – 5 laws • Proposed rule with Questions • Hearings • Final Rule

  12. Case Law for Health Standards • 1980 Supreme Court decision on benzene requires examination of significance of risk (cost-benefit) • 1981 Lead and Cotton Dust cases gave concept of technological and economical feasibility in view of financial health and profitability of industry and impact on unit pricing **

  13. Greater Risk Than Asbestos At the new technologically and economically feasible PEL, the cancer risk from Cr(VI) is higher than other regulated carcinogens • Methylene Chloride: 3.6 per 1000 workers • Asbestos: 6.7 deaths per 1000 workers • Benzene: 10 deaths per 1000 workers • Cr VI: 10-45 excess lung cancer deaths per 1000 workers for 45 years of exposure at new PEL of 5 ug/M3 2/28/06FR p. 10225

  14. Three Cr(VI) Standards • 1910.1026 General Industry • 1926.1126 Construction • 1915.1026 Shipyards

  15. Scope Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL) Exposure Determination Regulated areas* Methods of Compliance Respiratory Protection Protective Work Clothing and Equipment *General industry only Hygiene Areas and Practices Housekeeping* Medical Surveillance Communication of Hazards Recordkeeping Dates Major Provisions of the Standards

  16. Scope: Who is Coveredby the Standard? All occupational exposures to Cr(VI) compounds except: • Exposures that occur in the application of pesticides • Application is already covered by EPA Standards • The manufacture of pesticides and handling of pesticide treated materials are covered under new OSHA standard

  17. Scope: Who is Coveredby the Standard? All occupational exposures to Cr(VI) compounds except: • Exposures that occur in the application of pesticides • Exposures to portland cement • American portland cement usually contains only trace amounts • Would typically be over PEL for PNOR before over on Cr(VI) • Use PNOR, Personal Protective Equipment and Hazard Communication Standards for protection

  18. Scope: Who is Coveredby the Standard? All occupational exposures to Cr(VI) compounds except: • Exposures that occur in the application of pesticides • Exposures to portland cement • Where employers have objective data demonstrating that a material containing chromium or a process involving chromium cannot release Cr(VI) in concentrations at or above 0.5 µg/m3 as an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) under any condition of use

  19. Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL) and Action Level (AL) • PEL: 5 µg/m3 - TWA • AL: 2.5 µg/m3 - TWA

  20. Exposure Determination Two options allowed for determining employee exposures: • Scheduled monitoring option • Performance-oriented option

  21. Scheduled Monitoring Option • Prescribes a schedule for performing initial and periodic personal monitoring • If initial monitoring indicates exposures are: • Below theAL: monitoring can be discontinued • At or above theAL: monitor every 6 months • Above thePEL: monitor every 3 months

  22. Performance-Oriented Option • Exposures characterized using any combination of air monitoring data, historical monitoring data or objective data • No fixed schedule for performing periodic monitoring

  23. General Requirementsfor Exposure Determination • Affected employees must be notified where exposures exceed the PEL

  24. General Requirementsfor Exposure Determination • Affected employees must be notified where exposures exceed the PEL • Methods used for air monitoring and analysis must be sufficiently accurate [+/- 25% and within a statistical confidence level of 95% at AL]

  25. General Requirementsfor Exposure Determination • Affected employees must be notified where exposures exceed the PEL • Methods used for air monitoring and analysis must be sufficiently accurate • Employees or their representatives must be allowed to observe Cr(VI) monitoring

  26. Regulated Areas • For general industry employers only

  27. Regulated Areas • For general industry employers only • Areas where exposures exceed or can be reasonably expected to exceed the PEL • Must be demarcated from other areas • Must limit access to employees who have a need to be there

  28. Methods of Compliance • Establishes engineering and work practice controls as the primary means of achieving the PEL

  29. Methods of Compliance • Establishes engineering and work practice controls as the primary means of achieving the PEL • Exceptions: • Painting aircraft or large aircraft parts: • Use engineering and work practice controls to achieve 25 µg/m3 and supplement with respirators to achieve the PEL • Tasks or operations that do not result in exposures above the PEL for 30 or more days per year: • Use of respirators alone allowed to achieve the PEL

  30. Methods of Compliance • Establishes engineering and work practice controls as the primary means of achieving the PEL • Exceptions: • Painting aircraft or large aircraft parts: • Tasks or operations that do not result in exposures above the PEL for 30 or more days per year • Prohibits job rotation to achieve compliance with the PEL

  31. Respiratory Protection Required • Periods necessary to install or implement feasible engineering and work practice controls • Maintenance or repair operations where engineering and work practice controls are infeasible • Operations where all feasible controls have been used and exposures are still above the PEL • Operations where exposures do not exceed the PEL for 30 or more days per year • Emergencies

  32. Assigned Protection FactorsFinal Rule August 24, 2006

  33. Protective Work Clothingand Equipment • Use where a hazard is present or is likely to be present from skin or eye contact with Cr(VI) • Provided and paid for by the employer • Remove Cr(VI)-contaminated clothing and equipment when work shift or task is completed • Clean, store and label Cr(VI)-contaminated clothing and equipment

  34. Hygiene Areas and Practices • Must provide change rooms and washing facilities per 29 CFR 1910.141 • Employees must wash their hands and face at the end of a work shift and prior to eating, drinking, smoking, etc. • Employer-provided eating areas must be kept as free as practicable of Cr(VI) • No eating, drinking, smoking etc. in regulated areas

  35. Housekeeping • For general industry employers only • Keep all surfaces as free as practicable of accumulations of Cr(VI) • Use HEPA vacuums or other methods that minimize exposure to Cr(VI) • Use of compressed air prohibited unless: • Used in conjunction with a ventilation system to capture the dust cloud created by the compressed air, or • No alternative method is feasible • Dispose of Cr(VI)-contaminated waste in labeled, impermeable bags/containers

  36. Medical Surveillance • Provisions for conducting baseline and periodic health assessments of exposed employees • Provided by or under the supervision of a physician or other licensed health care professional (PLHCP) • Provided at no cost to employee and at a reasonable place and time

  37. Purpose of Medical Surveillance • Determine if an individual can be exposed to the Cr(VI) present in their workplace without experiencing adverse health effects • Indentify Cr(VI)-related adverse health effects so that appropriate intervention measures can be taken • Determine the employee’s fitness to use PPE, such as respirators

  38. Which Employees Must Be Provided Medical Surveillance? • Exposed at or above the action level(2.5 µg/m3) for 30 or more days per year • Experiencing signs or symptoms of Cr(VI) exposure • Exposed in an emergency

  39. Medical Examination Requirements • Medical and work history, with emphasis on: • Cr(VI) exposure (past, present, future) • History of respiratory system dysfunction • History of asthma, dermatitis, skin ulceration or nasal system perforation • Smoking status and history • Physical examination, with emphasis on the respiratory tract and skin • Any additional tests deemed appropriate by the PLHCP

  40. When Must MedicalExaminations Be Offered? • Within 30 days after initial assignment and annually thereafter • Within 30 days after a PLCHP recommends additional examinations • When employees shows signs or symptoms of Cr(VI) exposure • Within 30 days after exposure during an emergency • At the termination of employment

  41. Communication of Hazards • Provide employee training in accordance with OSHA’s Hazard Communication standard (29 CFR 1910.1200) • Additional training on the contents of the Cr(VI) standard and the purpose and description of the medical surveillance program required by the standard

  42. Recordkeeping • No requirement to maintain training records • Must maintain records per 29 CFR 1910.1020 for: • Air monitoring data • Historical monitoring data • Objective data • Medical surveillance information, including: • PLHCP’s written opinions • Information provided to the PLHCP

  43. Compliance Start-Up Dates • Effective date: May 30, 2006 • Start-up dates: • All provisions except engineering controls • For employers with 19 or fewer employees: May 30, 2007 • For all others: November 27, 2006 • Engineering Controls • For all employers: May 31, 2010

  44. Hexavalent Chromium Some practical issues

  45. FR Preamble: Exposure Ranges

  46. OSHA Internal Training on Hexavalent Chromium Sampling • Most pre-existing sampling was for total chrome, probably due to low cost • $50 for total metals analysis via ICP • $150 for Cr(VI) analysis • No way to separate or back calculate Cr(VI) exposures from total chrome (ICP) • Comments at 5/2006 AIHCE “Ask the Experts” Cr(VI) session indicate little new Cr(VI) sampling has been done • Conclusion: Exposure levels are not known WE NEED TO SAMPLE

  47. Cr VI SLTC Analysis OSHA ID215as of 6/2006 • Closed face 37mm PVC filter @ 2 lpm • Lab extraction of Cr VI from filter using an aqueous solution of sodium carbonate/sodium bicarbonate • Ion chromatography for Cr VI with postcolumn UV/visible detector set at 540nm wavelength • Limit of detection: 0.003 ug/M3 • SAE: varies, approx 0.112

  48. Interferences – Welding Fume Sampling • While in the cassette, Cr+6 reacts with iron Fe+2 to form Cr+3 • Cr+3 is not analyzed by method ID215 • In 6 days you lose 10% of Cr+6 through the Fe+2 reduction reaction • SHIP SAMPLE TO LAB IMMEDIATELY • If mailing will be delayed, get buffer solution from the lab ahead of time. While in the field you put the filters in the buffer solution to stabilize Cr+6

  49. Interferences – Plating Sampling • While in the cassette, Cr+6 reacts with acids from the plating baths to form Cr+3 • Cr+3 is not analyzed by method ID215 • In 6 days you lose 10% of Cr+6 through this acid reduction reaction • Order sodium hydroxide coated filters from the lab on an as needed basis for plating sampling • NaOH neutralizes the acid to cut down on Cr+6 loss • Helps maintain Cr+6 on the filter for 30 days • 1-3 month expiration date on these coated filters SHIP SAMPLE TO LAB IMMEDIATELY

  50. Filter Blanks • PVC filters are normally cut from sheet filter stock using a stainless steel cutter • Stainless steel contains chromium, and stainless steel cutters leave chrome VI contamination on filters • OSHA uses PVC filters cut with a teflon coated stainless cutter to reduce/avoid background chrome contamination • Some employers may be taking samples with filters contaminated by stainless cutters. • SEND FILTER BLANKS! 5 ug/M3 is a minute amount of material, and filter blanks will help avoid employer objections to your sample results

More Related