1 / 29

Conducting Research via Interviews

Conducting Research via Interviews. Collecting & analyzing interview data Sekaran & Saks Texts Example of structured interview Rudermann et al article. Why conduct interviews. To form OR test hypotheses To identify samples needed for hypothesis-testing research

glyn
Download Presentation

Conducting Research via Interviews

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Conducting Researchvia Interviews • Collecting & analyzing interview data • Sekaran & Saks Texts • Example of structured interview • Rudermann et al article

  2. Why conduct interviews • To form OR test hypotheses • To identify samples needed for hypothesis-testing research • To gather more detailed info • Before vs. after data collection

  3. Issues to consider • Interview Participants • Methods of interviewing • How to increase interviewee motivation • Structure of interviews • Avoiding Bias • Questioning Techniques

  4. Interview Participants • Opportunity vs. Representative samples • Benefits to generalization • Benefits to having formal/informal group Leaders in org/market research • Source of ‘rich’ data • Adding credibility to study

  5. Interview Methods • Face-Face • Telephone

  6. Interview Methods • Face to face • Direct observation • Non-verbal body cues, work context, response to physical/visual stimuli • Cost • Time, geographic constraints, more personnel, safety

  7. Interview Methods • Telephone • Response rate issues • Relatively higher than face-face interview • Completion rate issues • Restricts complexity & length of interview

  8. Interviewee motivation • Interviewees perceptions of the value of research • Providing information about Sponsor • Rapport • Interviewer’s Listening skills & empathy • Topic & format • Setting • Work vs. non-work

  9. Interview Structure • Unstructured • Structured

  10. Interview Structure • Unstructured • Uncover preliminary issues to identify variables needing further study • Broad, open questions • Job-level and work type • Monosyllabic answers • Positive vs. negative responses • Non-cooperative interviewees • Supervisory vs. non-supervisory employees Sekaran

  11. Interview Structure • Structured Interviews • Qs focus on relevant factors • Each P asked same qs • Sometimes deviate from interview protocol to uncover new factors • Use of Visual aids & physical stimuli • Marketing, children, issues that are hard to articulate • Advantages over questionnaire • Terminating data collection Sekaran, Saks

  12. Avoiding Bias • Sources of Interviewer bias • Lack of trust & rapport • Mis-interpretation/distortion responses • Encouraging or discouraging certain types of responses via gestures/facial expressions • Not Listening attentively • Not Paraphrasing answers • Not Repeating/clarifying questions • Not Being tactful Sekaran

  13. Avoiding Bias • Sources of Interviewee Bias • Not revealing true opinions/experiences • Interviewee says what s/he thinks interviewer wants to hear • Not understanding questions • Not liking interviewer • Giving ‘socially desirable’ responses Sekaran

  14. Avoiding Bias • Situational bias • Reasons for non-participation • Unwillingness, inability • Different levels of rapport/trust across different participants/interviewers • Physical setting • Degree to which it inhibits honesty Sekaran

  15. Questioning Techniques • Funnel technique • Sequence & Level of specificity of questions • Familiarity w/interviewee’s understanding • Contamination of responses • Perceived spontaneity, decreased self-consciousness, rapport • Probes & follow-up qs Sekaran, Saks

  16. Questioning Techniques • Unbiased questioning • Loaded/leading questions • Clarifying Issues • Re-stating/rephrasing • Helping respondent think through issues • Rephrase depending on verbalization ability Sekaran

  17. Questioning TechniquesNote Taking • Intrusiveness • Focus on summarizing • Focus on behavior • Effect on self-consciousness • Effect on rapport • Permission for taping • Effects on interviewee inhibition • Take notes (or tape) after interview Saks

  18. Conducting Researchvia Interviews • Collecting & analyzing interview data • Sekaran & Saks Texts • Example of structured interview • Rudermann et al article

  19. Rudermann et al Study • Benefits of non-job roles for managerial women • Hypothesis: Experiences in personal roles enrich managerial skills • What percentage of women mention this hypothesis in their interviews? • What percentage of all responses to interviews support this hypothesis?

  20. Participants • 74% of women participating in a women-only leadership devel’t prg • Avg. Age=40 (range=26-57) • 92% White • Avg. Salary =~78K (SD= ~32k)

  21. Participants • Rank • Middle =49%, • Upper middle =34% Figure? • Exec=17% • 51% had post-graduate education • 50% had children under 18 yrs • 71% in committed relationships • 84% in Fortune 500 corporations

  22. Procedure • Faxed qs to participants a few days before interview • Pilot tested interview qs on 28 women managers • Tape-recorded and transcribed each interview

  23. Measures • Open-ended questions on • Different types of roles managers held • Challenges faced in roles • Are there any dimensions/aspects of personal life that enhance your professional life? • Use of follow up qs and probes to obtain details on roles

  24. Data Analysis • Applied grounded theory (Glaser & Strauss, 1967) • Coding techniques Boyatzis (1998) • Developed initial hypotheses during interviews with pilot and study 1 participants

  25. Interview Coding • 2 raters read 30 interviews many times • Developed excerpts of each P’s answer • Summarized excerpts • Organized summaries & sample quotes • Compared & contrasted quotes and summaries for each case to id 13 patterns & themes • Examined remaining interviews for add’l themes

  26. Interview Coding • 13 themes reduced to 6 categories • Reviewed all excerpts to confirm categorization • Developed codebook explaining 6 themes • 66.7% to 90.9% inter-rater agreement on coding of themes • Not good according to Boyatzis, 1998

  27. Non-work roles provide… % of Sample Stating % Rater Agree-ment Opportunities to enhance inter-personal skills 42 90.2 Psychological benefits 23 75.9 Emotional support & advice 19 90.9 Results

  28. Discussion • Tentative support for hypothesis • Alternative ways of presenting data to support hypothesis

More Related