1 / 11

Causal Mechanisms for Strategic Subcultures: The Case of Aum Shinrikyo

Causal Mechanisms for Strategic Subcultures: The Case of Aum Shinrikyo. Alex Burns (Alexander.Burns@monash.edu) SPS Symposium, 30 th October 2018 PhD Candidate, School of Politics & Social Inquiry, Monash University. Progress Report 2019.

glove
Download Presentation

Causal Mechanisms for Strategic Subcultures: The Case of Aum Shinrikyo

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Causal Mechanisms for Strategic Subcultures: The Case of Aum Shinrikyo Alex Burns (Alexander.Burns@monash.edu) SPS Symposium, 30th October 2018 PhD Candidate, School of Politics & Social Inquiry, Monash University

  2. Progress Report 2019 • Pre-Submission Seminar / Final Review milestone completed on 14th November 2018 with thanks to committee Associate Professor Benjamin MacQueen, Associate Professor Steve Roberts, and Dr Bill Flanik • Associate Professor Pete Lentini joins as new main PhD Supervisor to augment Dr Luke Howie and Dr ZarehGhazarian (main and associate PhD Supervisors) • Two new data chapters written using process tracing methodology, and two unused new chapters which will inform future journal articles (on Theory-Building Insights and on the Accelerationist political philosophy and recent terrorist attacks) • Dr Brett Hough to copy-edit thesis on 11th November 2019 • Thesis submission to MGRO on 22nd November 2019

  3. Subcultures and Terrorist Subcultures • Subculture analysis emerged in 1940s and 1950s: • Meso-level structures for beliefs and values in society • How new norms arise in society at the sub-group level • Social-psychological tension between deviant sub-group and the mainstream society (e.g. youth, aesthetic) • Chicago and Birmingham (Stuart Hall) schools • Terrorist Subcultures • Mark Hamm (cultural criminology) and Jeffrey Kaplan (Interpretivist analysis of new religious and terrorist groups) • Subcultural artefacts (art, music, books, symbolism, memes) • Examples: militias, post-Vietnam paramilitary, neo-Nazi, far right, and Alt-Right proponents who support extremist violence • Different to (terrorist) strategic subcultures I use in the thesis

  4. Strategic Culture Defined: Jack Snyder • Formulated in 1977 by Jack Snyder for a RAND monograph on Ford and Carter administration détente and the Soviet Union • “Individuals are socialized into a distinctly Soviet mode of thinking . . . a set of general beliefs, attitudes and behavioral patterns . . . that places them on the level of “culture” rather than mere “policy” . . .” [emphasis added] (Snyder 1977: v) • “Culture is perpetuated not only by individuals but also by organizations.” (Snyder 1977: 9). • “Strategic subculture: . . . a subsection of the broader strategic community . . . Reasonably distinct beliefs and attitudes.” (Snyder 1977: 10).

  5. Aum Shinrikyo • Founded in 1984 as a small yoga group • Founder: Shoko Asahara (Chizuo Matsumoto) • Developed a synthesis of religious beliefs • Hindu deity worship (Shiva experience in 1985) • Tibetan Buddhist Vajrayana (esoteric practices) • Evangelical Christianity (End Times apocalypse) • Cultic milieu (Nostradamus) • Innovation (Perfect Salvation Initiation) • 20th March 1995: sarin gas attack on Tokyo subway • 13 people killed • 5500 people injured • Long-term psycho-social effects in Japanese society (the ‘Aum affair’) • Transformed from new religious movement to religiously motivated terrorist organisation

  6. Aum Shinrikyo’s Pathway to Terrorist Violence • Asahara’s goal of recruiting 30,000 renunciates (very ambitious, led to Korea and Russia members) • Early, optimistic period (1984-90) became more pessimistic (Ian Reader, 2000): parallels to Bhagwan Rajneesh (Netflix 2018 documentary Wild, Wild Country) • Failed ‘populism’ of Asahara’s micro-party political campaign for the Japanese Diet (1990) • Asahara’s interest in conspiracy theories (priming) • Chemical and Biological Weapons experimentation • Pathway to violence: Matsumoto (June 1994) and Tokyo (March 1995) when Aum Shinrikyo was under investigation by Japanese authorities

  7. CM1: Cultural Transmission • Shiva experience in 1985: Asahara’s religious mission as an avatar to liberate humanity • Anthropologist Frederick M. Smith (The Self Possessed): ‘deity yoga’ experiences in South Asian tantra as transcultural model • Indo-Tibetan worldview influenced by Hindu (Shaktipat Initiation) and shift in 1989-90 to Tibetan Buddhist Vajrayana • Syncretic beliefs: also interested in Evangelical Christian religious narratives about Armageddon (Asahara, Declaring Myself The Christ) • Forecast the apocalyptic counterfactual of a ‘limited’ nuclear war between United States and Japan in 2003, after a period of global economic collapse (US, Europe, Japan)

  8. CM2: Social Learning • Aum Shinrikyo counter-elite functioned as an attachment-rank hierarchy (Anthony Stevens & John Price, evolutionary psychiatrists, Prophets, Cults and Madness) • Initiatory, religious sub-system: a way for Asahara to reach his goal of 30,000 renunciates in order to liberate humanity • Indoctrinability: provided the belief system for ‘wandering’ seekers to quickly become renunciates and donate assets • Social bonds, initiatory practices, and ritual ordeals were important for renunciates • Compartmentalised: renunciates unaware of Chemical and Biological Weapons experimentation

  9. CM3: Folklore • Aum Shinrikyo interacted with Japan’s cultic milieu and with anime/manga media imagery (Space Battleship Yamato) • Renunciates had background interest in the occult that pre-screened them (Haruki Murakami, Underground interviews) • Narratives around experimentation at Bhajaran cattle station, Western Australia (Jake Hanrahan, Vice Motherboard and Sarah Hightower, @nezumi_ningen) • Psychiatric diagnosis of “functional megalomania” (Robert Jay Lifton) and “florid schizophrenia” (Daniel Shaw): earlier susceptibility to schizotypal thinking (ideas of reference) in the cultic milieu (1978-84)

  10. Thesis Lessons • Aum Shinrikyo transformed from a guru-led new religious movement to a religiously motivated terrorist organisation • Japanese Government execution of Asahara and other Aum members (6th and 26th July 2018) before Heisei era’s end and Reiwa era began • The three posited causal mechanisms converge on the indoctrinability of renunciates • Academic contribution: new analytical theory of strategic subcultures and new process tracing causal tests for terrorist organisations • Policy relevance: cross-domain counter-coercion capabilities and terrorist organisation deterrence

  11. Discussion

More Related