1 / 18

Assessing the Potential of an OHL / AHL Franchise in Thunder Bay Study Presentation to Thunder Bay City Council

December 14, 2009. Assessing the Potential of an OHL / AHL Franchise in Thunder Bay Study Presentation to Thunder Bay City Council. Background. Project Overview

gazit
Download Presentation

Assessing the Potential of an OHL / AHL Franchise in Thunder Bay Study Presentation to Thunder Bay City Council

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. December 14, 2009 Assessing the Potential of an OHL / AHL Franchise in Thunder BayStudy Presentation to Thunder Bay City Council

  2. Background Project Overview • Deloitte retained by the City of Thunder Bay to assess the ability of the city to support an OHL / AHL franchise and a new multi-use spectator event centre • Report addresses the following elements: • The long-term viability of an OHL / AHL Team operating successfully in Thunder Bay • The impact on an OHL / AHL Team on other existing hockey teams in Thunder Bay • A review of leases which other municipalities have with OHL teams Scope of Review • History of hockey in Thunder Bay • History of the Ontario and American Hockey Leagues • Assessment of the operating potential of new multi-use spectator event centres • Assessment of the economic benefits of OHL / AHL teams and spectator event centre • Overall conclusions and recommendations

  3. Hockey in Thunder Bay • City has had a long and successful history of hosting junior, senior and semi-professional hockey. City has hosted teams playing in a broad number of leagues: • Thunder Bay Junior Hockey League • Thunder Bay Hockey League • United States Hockey League • Colonial / United Hockey League • Superior International Junior Hockey League • Thunder Bay Junior B Hockey League • OHA Senior A Hockey League • Most popular and perhaps most successful team is the Lakehead University Thunderwolves. Success appears to be driven by: • Quality of the on-ice product • Quality of the league vis-à-vis other levels of hockey currently being played in Thunder Bay • Despite the City’s long hockey history, Thunder Bay has never been home to a Major Junior A (Tier I) franchise. • Location has also been an issue in keeping teams in the City

  4. Ontario Hockey League Overview • In operation since 1974, the OHL is one of three Tier 1 Major Junior hockey leagues operating in Canada • Comprised of 20 teams – 17 located in Ontario, 2 in Michigan and 1 in Pennsylvania • Produce the highest percentage of players drafted into the National Hockey League • Teams generally attract some 4,000 fans per game • League has realized significant jumps in attendance coinciding with the construction of new multi-purpose spectator event facilities

  5. Ontario Hockey League Building Boom • Since 1996, 10 new 5,000+-seat multi-use spectator facilities have been constructed: • Barrie Molson Centre (1996) – 4,200 seats • Sarnia Sports and Entertainment Centre (1998) – 5,000 seats • Brampton Powerade Centre (1998) – 5,000 seats • Mississauga Hershey Centre (1998) – 5,400 seats • Guelph Sleeman Centre (2000) – 5,100 seats • London John Labatt Centre (2002) – 9,100 seats • Sault Ste. Marie Essar Centre (2005) – 5,000 seats • Oshawa General Motors Centre (2006) – 5,400 seats • Kingston K-Rock Centre (2008) – 5,200 seats • Windsor WFCU Centre (2008) – 7,000 seats • Buildings designed to mimic NHL venues and contain many of the same amenities found within these buildings: • luxury suites • club seats • in-house restaurants • retail outlets • enhanced food & beverage • larger concourses • wider seating • better advertising opportunities

  6. Confidential Phase 1 Report – Proposed Multi-Plex Facility Ontario Hockey League Fort William Gardens

  7. Ontario Hockey League Essar Centre – Sault Ste. Marie

  8. Ontario Hockey League K-Rock Centre - Kingston

  9. Ontario Hockey League General Motors Centre - Oshawa

  10. Ontario Hockey League WFCU Centre - Windsor

  11. Ontario Hockey League John Labatt Centre - London

  12. Ontario Hockey League Sleeman Centre - Guelph

  13. American Hockey League Overview • In operation since 1936 • 29 teams have direct affiliations with NHL parent teams • Teams stocked with younger, recently drafted players who have yet to make an NHL roster (plus aging veterans) • Teams generally attract 5,000 to 6,000 fans per game • League has witnessed significant franchise relocations • at one time there have been 15 different Canadian teams • currently one team is “dormant” • 40 different teams / centres have existed in the 2000s • Less than 50% of the league’s 29 teams predate the 2000-01 season • Player and coach salaries covered by NHL parent club • Team travel costs generally higher compared to OHL teams

  14. Multi-Use Spectator Event Facilities Uses Operations • Depending on the market, new multi-purpose spectator event centres can make or lose money from operations (Fort Williams Gardens loses $400,000 to $500,000 annually) Lease Agreements • Leases in new buildings generally run for a 10 / 15 / 20 period and provide the OHL team tenant with priority booking access. In addition: • rent generally based on a portion of gross ticket revenue • teams / building “split” food & beverage and advertising • building retains revenue from club seats and suites

  15. Economic Benefits Team • As an economic entity, the operations of an OHL / AHL team will create employment and spending within the community • Fosters visitor attraction, increased room night demand and spending (scouts, agents, player families, etc.) • Provides “brand name” marketing for the community • Supports local philanthropic endeavours Building • As an economic entity the operations of a multi-use spectator event facility will create employment and spending within the community • The construction of the building could generate $90 million in total spending impacts and support more than 550 person years of employment • Used by local economic development / marketing officials as part of the “quality of life” package to help attract business and investment, and to assist in luring professionals to Thunder Bay • Allows the city to attract a broader range of other sporting, entertainment and corporate events to the community • Buildings have been used as catalysts for additional entertainment-related economic development

  16. Conclusions Can an OHL / AHL Team Operate Successfully in Thunder Bay • Attendance projected to average 4,200 per game over the course of a season • Experience is that teams playing in new buildings will experience a “honeymoon” period of significantly higher average attendance and some games will attract significantly more fans • Recommended building size is roughly 5,200 to 5,600 seats – cost would be $50 million - $60 million • An OHL / AHL team will require a new, larger building in order to be successful • As most buildings will strive to achieve break-even operating results, 100% of the cost of the building would be borne by the City of Thunder Bay, offset somewhat by the sale of naming rights and other building sponsorships Impact on Existing Teams • OHL / AHL will have little impact on most existing Thunder Bay teams • OHL / AHL will likely have significant impact on the Lakehead University Thunderwolves, particularly from an attendance and corporate sponsorship perspective • City should attempt to secure some form of covenant / guarantee from the OHL / AHL team that it will be resident in the City for the long term Terms and Conditions in a New Facility • OHL / AHL provided with priority booking rights as “featured tenant” • OHL / AHL to pay rent based on gross ticket sales – team and building to share other revenue streams (including concessions, advertising, etc.)

  17. Questions

More Related