130 likes | 371 Views
ETHICAL THEORIES: OVERVIEW. Universal Moral Theories. Utilitarianism Egoism Deontology Rules-based Rights-based Virtue ethics. Utilitarianism. If the end doesn’t justify the means, what does? Consequence-based
E N D
Universal Moral Theories • Utilitarianism • Egoism • Deontology • Rules-based • Rights-based • Virtue ethics
Utilitarianism • If the end doesn’t justify the means, what does? • Consequence-based • Weights suffering against happiness (produces greatest balance of good over harm) • Can we actually measure something called “the greatest good”?
Utilitarian Method • Identify all courses of action • Identify parties affected • Identify contribution of each course of action to that person’s net happiness • Ignoring all other considerations, compare courses of action, taking account of the NUMBER of people affected • Choose the course of action that maximizes overall happiness
Utilitarian Method • When might this be a good approach? • When might this be a poor approach?
EGOISM • Opposite to utilitarianism • Do the most good for yourself • Is this selfish? And if so, how can it be morally justifiable?
Deontology: Rights-based • What is my moral duty? • We should do our duty because of a sense of good will, not because of reward or punishment • Everyone has rights • Everyone needs to respect each other’s rights • Does this address the utilitarian weakness (can we ever be sure of the consequences?)?
Deontology: Rules-based • Legalistic or rule-bound theory • Can following the rules result in greater harm than breaking them?
Deontology Method • What rule are you following? • Would it be a universal rule?
Deontology • What are its strengths? • What are its weaknesses?
Virtue Ethics • Being a virtuous person is most important • What behaviors are equal to being virtuous?
Review • Utilitarianism: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tWABlhuvRDA • Deontology: Three Minute Philosophy – Immanuel Kant http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xwOCmJevigw • Virtue Theory: Three Minute Philosophy – Aristotle http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tm0Uq08xXhY&feature=channel