the criminological use of culture and subculture n.
Download
Skip this Video
Loading SlideShow in 5 Seconds..
The Criminological Use of Culture and Subculture PowerPoint Presentation
Download Presentation
The Criminological Use of Culture and Subculture

Loading in 2 Seconds...

play fullscreen
1 / 17

The Criminological Use of Culture and Subculture - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 743 Views
  • Uploaded on

The Criminological Use of Culture and Subculture. Understanding Criminology 2 nd November 2006. Lecture Outline. Subculture: Definitions and Typology Gangs and the variety of adaptations to strain Social Class and Subculture Drift Theory. Culture and Subculture.

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'The Criminological Use of Culture and Subculture' - bernad


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
the criminological use of culture and subculture

The Criminological Use of Culture and Subculture

Understanding Criminology

2nd November 2006

lecture outline
Lecture Outline
  • Subculture: Definitions and Typology
  • Gangs and the variety of adaptations to strain
  • Social Class and Subculture
  • Drift Theory
culture and subculture
Culture and Subculture
  • Adaptations of Strain theory, with an awareness of the diversity of deviant forms
  • Initial focus on gangs and youth delinquency
subculture definitions
Subculture: Definitions
  • A relatively small grouping that develops distinctive norms, values and beliefs. Subcultures provide members with a range of personal resources (e.g. status, capital, excitement) that have often been denied by mainstream society / culture
  • Subcultural Theory: aim to identify the cause and expressive nature of subcultures
typology
Typology
  • Reactive / Oppositional Subcultures
    • The subcultural form is a direct reaction against mainstream culture
    • Most directly influenced by strain theory
  • Independent Subcultures
    • Subcultures develop their own values and norms of behaviour independently of mainstream culture
william whyte street corner society
William Whyte: Street Corner Society
  • Easier for a “slum” resident to achieve monetary success in a racket, than by conventional means
  • Role models: college boys v. corner boys
  • Gang activities highly organised
  • Pioneering participant observation based study
  • KEY: expressive nature of subcultures
sutherland s differential association theory
Sutherland’s Differential Association Theory
  • Delinquent practices are ‘culturally transmitted’ from one individual to another
  • Cultural conflict: if “definitions” favourable to law violation outweigh those unfavourable, crime will occur
  • Applied largely to white-collar crime, but has subsequently been applied to other crime
  • KEY: Cultural Transmission
slide8

National = Strain / Inequality / Limited Opportunities

Community = Legitimate and Illegitimate Opportunities

albert cohen delinquent boys the culture of the gang
Albert Cohen: “Delinquent Boys:The culture of the gang”
  • Subculture evolved in response to strain, and a rejection of ‘middle-class values’
  • Education paramount:
    • Make children aware of social status
    • Key to the constraint of opportunities
  • Goal: status, not necessarily monetary success
  • An attempt to understand non-economic deviance
  • Gangs were a particular form of subcultural adaptation, characterised by:-
richard cloward and lloyd ohlin
Richard Cloward and Lloyd Ohlin
  • Focussed on the range that adaptations to strain could take, incorporating differential association
  • Criminal Gangs
  • Conflict Gangs
  • Retreatist Gangs
  • Returned to Merton’s focus on monetary success
evaluation of strain influenced subcultural theories
Evaluation of Strain Influenced Subcultural Theories
  • Fits with
    • Over-representation of working class, urban offenders in gang activity
    • A dominant / superior middle class culture
  • Possibly fits with
    • Gang activity being predominantly male: girls and young women have alternative sources of status?
  • Doesn’t fit with
    • Widespread, but petty offending
    • British experience
david downes a british perspective
David Downes: a British Perspective
  • In Britain, social class is central to understanding subcultural adaptation
  • Working class youth had a “realistically low” level of aspiration / fatalism
  • Delinquency as a ‘fact’ of life, but not a ‘way’ of life
downes and subculture in britain
Downes and Subculture in Britain
  • Key cause of delinquency: boredom and the importance of leisure
  • little opportunity for excitement (akin to strain)
  • leisure became the location for excitement and expression of

- toughness, daring, panache

  • Links between leisure and delinquency
    • proceeds of crime funding leisure
    • delinquency is itself exciting
    • delinquency is a by-product of certain forms of excitement
marxist analysis of sub culture counter culture
Marxist analysis of sub-culture / counter-culture
  • Phil Cohen
  • Economic Decline ->
    • family tensions
    • fragmented community
    • economic insecurity
  • Mods: socially mobile white-collar worker
  • Skinheads: emphasising masculinity of hard manual labour
david matza drift and neutralization
David Matza: Drift and Neutralization
  • Sees subcultural theories are over-predictive
  • Drift: a ‘limbo between convention and crime’ preceding delinquency
  • Techniques of neutralization demonstrate continued commitment to mainstream cultural values
  • Delinquency represents the exaggeration of “subterranean”, but not deviant values:
    • the pursuit of excitement
    • the disdain for routine work
    • toughness and masculinity
what is a cultural of deviance
What is a Cultural of Deviance?
  • Pockets of specific activities providing meaning and resources to the member
    • E.g. The Gang
  • A widespread loose affinity between relatively informal groupings
    • E.g. Anti-globalisation environmental groups
  • A reflection of temporary adolescent rejection of parental / mainstream values – functional?
  • A vital mechanism that acts to support and

reproduce mainstream culture

summary
Summary
  • Most cultural theories would expect more criminality than actually seen
  • Matza and Drift theory would not predict much ‘career criminality’
  • Cultural Relativism: a danger that criminality is romanticized: the expressive qualitative nature of deviance is addressed: rarely the same focus on mainstream culture or victimisation