1 / 33

HI5027: Corporations Law

HI5027: Corporations Law. Holmes Institute: MBA Program. SESSION 4. Summarising this session. By the end of this Session, you will be able to understand the following topics: Members’ decision making; and Members’ meetings. Member decision-making. Who controls companies?

angus
Download Presentation

HI5027: Corporations Law

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. HI5027: Corporations Law Holmes Institute: MBA Program SESSION 4

  2. Summarising this session By the end of this Session, you will be able to understand the following topics: Members’ decision making; and Members’ meetings.

  3. Member decision-making • Who controls companies? • On what issues do members have a vote? • Structural or constitutional matters • Director appointment and remuneration; appointment of auditors • Some significant or related party transactions • Winding up, residual powers

  4. Member voting • Right to make certain decisions about the company is reserved to the members in general meeting by the internal management rules or the Corporations Act • Often, the internal management rules operate on a principle of majority rule – that is, members vote and the view of the majority prevails

  5. Control and the exercise of voting rights • Voting rights are a means by which members control what happens to their company • Control depends not only on the presence of voting rights, but also the capacity and information to exercise them

  6. Members’ specific powers • Precise scope depends on the internal management rules • Different for public and proprietary companies • Listing Rules confer additional powers on members

  7. Changes to structure • Member approval is required to: • adopt, modify or repeal the Constitution (s136) • change the company’s name (s157) • change type (eg from proprietary to public) (s162) • Special resolution is required in each case

  8. Variation of class rights • Section 246B – variation or cancellation permitted only: • in accordance with the Constitution, or • where the Constitution is silent, by special resolution of the company and a separate special resolution of the class

  9. Variation of class rights (cont) • What is a variation of class rights? See Greenhalgh v Arderne Cinemas • General law test is narrow – effect on enjoyment is not enough • Section 246C: certain actions will amount to variation of class rights

  10. Variation of class rights (cont) • Section 246D: rights of dissenting members where the variation, cancellation or modification does not have unanimous consent • Members holding at least 10% of the class can apply to the Court for change to be set aside for unfair prejudice

  11. Transactions affecting capital • Certain actions affecting share capital – such as share buy-backs, financial assistance and reductions of capital – may require member approval • See Lecture 20 on changes to share capital

  12. Composition of the board • Appointment – member election or approval may be required under the internal management rules, eg: • Members elect the directors by ordinary resolution (RR s201G) • Members must approve appointments made under casual vacancy power (RR s201H)

  13. Composition of the board (cont) • Listed companies always have director election • Members’ right to remove a director • Public company: s203D (ordinary resolution) • Proprietary company: only if provided for in the internal management rules, eg RR s203C

  14. Directors’ remuneration and benefits • The CLERP 9 remuneration report and non-binding shareholder vote • “Two strikes then spill” process • Retirement benefits • Note Chapter 2E of Corporations Act requirements may apply if it is not “reasonable remuneration”

  15. Veto • Members have the right to veto certain transactions – that means the transaction cannot go ahead without their consent • Related party transactions (discussed in Lecture 14) • Listed company – significant transactions • Takeovers and reconstructions

  16. Other decisions • Members’ voluntary winding up • Residual decision-making power where the board is unable to act, it relates to a decision to sue controllers, or involves ratification

  17. Members’ meetings • Meetings • Types of meetings • Convening meetings • Conducting meetings • Member voting • Decision-making without a meeting • Fixing procedural irregularities

  18. Types of meetings • All public companies must hold an annual general meeting (s250N) • Other meetings are called “extraordinary general meetings” • Rules governing meetings are set out in Pt 2G.2 of the Corporations Act and the internal management rules

  19. Convening a meeting • Usually, meetings are called by the board. Can also be called: • RR s249C by single director • Listed company by single director (s249CA) • Court, on application by a director or member if it is otherwise impracticable (s249G)

  20. Convening a meeting (cont) • Requisition by 5%+ or 100+ members (s249D) • Directors need not convene if the purpose is improper – NRMA v Parker • Direct convening by 5%+ members (s249F)

  21. Agenda • Who decides what the meeting can consider? • Only matters that have been included in the notice of meeting can be considered at the meeting – other than matters stated in s250R in case of AGMs

  22. Agenda (cont) • Usually, where the directors are calling a meeting, they will determine the agenda • Members can request the inclusion of resolutions for consideration by the meeting (s249N)

  23. Notice of meeting • General rule – 21 days. Consent to short notice is possible (s249H) • Listed companies – 28 days (s249HA) • Notice must be given to members, directors and auditor • Contents of notice (s249L)

  24. Notice of meeting (cont) • Notice must contain sufficient information to enable the member to decide whether or not to attend the meeting and how to vote • Must not be misleading or deceptive (even if this is unintentional)

  25. Notice (cont) • Must “fully and fairly inform and instruct the shareholder about the matter on which he or she will have to vote” – Devereaux Holdings • Need to balance the information presented, to make it accessible – Fraser v NRMA

  26. Conduct of meetings • Quorum • Use of technology • Proxies and corporate representatives • Conduct (role of the chair)

  27. Voting • Members’ entitlement to vote • Replaceable rule in s250E • Preference shareholders • Voting by proxies • Voting (show of hands and poll) • Ordinary and special resolutions

  28. Disqualification from voting • Corporations Act and Listing Rules prevent interested parties from voting their shares in certain circumstances, including: • related party transactions • selective buy-backs • selective reductions of capital • ASX Listing Rules – sale of main undertaking, share issues to related parties etc • Adoption of remuneration report

  29. Decision-making without a meeting • In single member companies, resolution is passed by the member recording and signing it (s249B) • Proprietary companies may use “flying minutes”, in which all members entitled to vote must sign a document agreeing to the resolution (s249A)

  30. Irregularities • Section 1322: outcome of meeting may be valid despite some irregularity (ie failure to follow required procedure) • Applies to “proceeding under the Act” – includes directors’ and members’ meetings • Automatic validation (valid unless a court says no) or curing declaration

  31. Procedural irregularity • Section 1322(2): includes absence of quorum, defect of notice or time • Not invalid unless court is of the opinion that a substantial injustice has resulted or may result, and declares it invalid • Onus on the person arguing invalidity

  32. Other automatic validation provisions • Examples are non receipt of notice, technology failure, voting in contravention of s259D • Person seeking to overturn proceeding must establish “substantial injustice”

  33. Requirements for court order • Section 1322(6): court can declare that an act, matter, or thing, or a proceeding, is not invalid so long as: • it is procedural in nature • the person acted honestly • it is just and equitable to make the order • no substantial injustice • Onus on the person asserting validity

More Related