140 likes | 174 Views
Explore BSS load balancing strategies for MU-MIMO scenarios, proposing a new control element for optimal STA association and improved throughput.
E N D
BSS load balancing for MU-MIMO Authors: Date: 2010-11-09 Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
BSS load balancing without MU-MIMO • Example scenario with two AP with only legacy STAs • If BSS load of AP1 is lower than AP2 than association with AP1 will give better throughput for the STA Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
BSS load balancing with MU-MIMO • Example scenario with two AP with legacy STAs and MU-MIMO supported STAs • In case BSS load of AP1 similar to AP2 and MU-MIMO supported STAs associated with each AP is different, association with which AP will give more benefits to the STA? Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
Example of BSS load status (1/3) • Example timeline for an AP with only legacy STAs • BSS load is calculated by ratio of idle and busy time in a given measurement window • BSS load status definition will still work for SU-MIMO Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
Example of BSS load status (2/3) • Example timeline for an AP with only MU-MIMO capable STAs • BSS load status definition does not take into account under utilized spatial streams which is available by MU-MIMO STA pairing Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
Example of BSS load status (3/3) • Example timeline for an AP with legacy STAs and MU-MIMO capable STAs • BSS load status definition only give partial information of actual load and does not take into account spatial stream utilization Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
802.11 BSS Load Element [3] • BSS load element contains ‘Channel Utilization’ • Channel Utilization = Integer((channel_busy_time/(dot11ChannelUtilizationBeaconIntervals × dot11BeaconPeriod × 1024)) × 255) • “channel_busy_time” is defined by CS busy time within the measurement window • No consideration of actual system capacity of MIMO-capable APs Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
Issues with 11n BSS load element • Channel Utilization metric • does not take into account additional resource dimensionality the MU-MIMO capable AP has • resource dimensions { time, frequency, space } • Station Count • does not distinguish STAs with MU-MIMO support Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
General observations and Suggestion • General observations • 802.11 BSS load element does not seem to adequately take into account particulars of MU-MIMO operation • BSS load balancing in MU-MIMO environment are especially important since MU-MIMO benefits high data rate transmissions and large number of active STA • Better mechanisms supporting MU-MIMO supported environments seems necessary • Potential solution is to introduce a new control element for MU-MIMO supported STA association Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
MU-MIMO BSS load element (1/2) • Propose to adopt an additional BSS load element (MU-MIMO BSS load element) • Keep existing BSS load indication for legacy load balancing • Support extra BSS load element to benefit 11ac devices • Desired characteristics • Non duplicate information from legacy BSS load element • Information on utilized or under-utilized level of AP’s potential MU-MIMO capacity Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
MU-MIMO BSS load element (2/2) • New BSS load element should strive to utilize medium characteristics of MU-MIMO transmission channel • e.g. Idle / Busy : SU-MIMO transmission (STA-to-AP, AP-to-legacy STA) / Partially Busy : MU-MIMO transmission (AP-to-11ac STA) • Exact Formulation needs further study Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
802.11ac BSS MU-MIMO Load Element • MU-MIMO load element • Proposed load element is entirely optional (Just as the original BSS load element) and only broadcasted if such capability is supported by AP (e.g. only implemented if AP is ‘MU-MIMO capable’ AND ‘dot11QBSSLoadOptionImplemented’ is true) • Does not replace the 802.11 BSS load element, is an addition to existing load element • MU-MIMO load element contains ‘TBD’ • TBD may compose of 1 or multiple information values Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
Pre-Motion • Do you support to define an additional load information element target for MU-MIMO capable devices as shown in slide 12? • BSS load element for MU-MIMO contains 1 octet element ID field, 1 octet length field, and N octet TBD field, in which N is TBD • Yes : No : Abstain : Daewon Lee, LG Electronics
References [1] Greg Breit, Nachiket Desai, “Multi-User AoD Diversity Measurements,” IEEE 802.11-09/0699r0 [2] Kwak, B.-J. et al., “Measured Channel Capacity and AoD Estimation for Multi-User MIMO Scenarios,” IEEE 802.11-09/0543r0 [3] “Wireless LAN Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) Specifications”, IEEE802.11-2007 Daewon Lee, LG Electronics