1 / 12

International Business Structures & Regulation Sol Picciotto

Law School. International Business Structures & Regulation Sol Picciotto. 4: Investment Agreements and their Impact on National Regulation host state regulation of foreign investment controlling market access & contestability investor protection in public international law

adin
Download Presentation

International Business Structures & Regulation Sol Picciotto

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Law School International Business Structures & Regulation Sol Picciotto 4: Investment Agreements and their Impact on National Regulation host state regulation of foreign investment controlling market access & contestability investor protection in public international law expropriation; National Treatment investment protection treaties bilateral multilateral: draft MAI, NAFTA, WTO? arbitration: state-state, investor-state enforcement of arbitral awards impact of investor rights on domestic regulation IBSR Topic 4

  2. Host State Control of Admission/Establishment restricted sectors: e.g. defence, transport, communications screening & authorisation, conditions: minimum capital requirements development criteria location restrictions/requirements restrictions on form of entry new/green-field, not M&A local incorporation investment incentives capital grants/loans; tax holidays IBSR Topic 4

  3. Host State Measures on Ownership/Control Limits on Foreign Ownership (e.g. 49%) obligation to transfer over time Joint Venture requirements: Public: National Development Agency etc Private: local shareholder requirement Restrictions on Shareholders’ Rights voting/control; government `golden share’ dividend payment limits Technology Licensing Restrictions prohibiting e.g. grant-back, territoriality limits, etc Land Ownership restrictions IBSR Topic 4

  4. Performance Requirements & Operational Controls Local Content/ Sourcing to prevent `screwdriver’ assembly plants Import Restrictions/ Trade Balancing Foreign Exchange Limits/ Balancing Personnel Restrictions/ Obligations entry only for key foreign staff indigenisation & staff training obligations Access Restrictions telecomms networks, membership of business associations, clearing arrangements IBSR Topic 4

  5. Investor Protection: Public International Law No Obligation to Allow Admission State Responsibility- to Home state not to person directly Minimum IL standard of treatment? exhaustion of local remedies Treatment equal to nationals? Calvo doctrine, Calvo clause Taking property: 19C state bond defaults; 20C nationalisations (USSR, Mexico, oil & natural resources) non-discriminatory, public purpose, no breach of contract compensation: prompt, adequate, effective: Hull formula OR `appropriate’: CERDS 1974 art.2 `creeping’ nationalisation via regulation? ICJ: Barcelona Traction 1970; ELSI (Raytheon) 1989 (bankruptcies) cancellation of contracts/concessions refusal of necessary permit, e.g. waste landfill? IBSR Topic 4

  6. Liberalisation of Investment Regulation Reduction/elimination of border barriers (entry restrictions) regulatory requirements as a barrier; `level playing field'? Non-discrimination: National Treatment (NT) NLFT - treatment no less favourablethan for domestic firms Most-Favoured-Nation MFN: no preferences between different home countries Fair & Equitable Treatment: open-ended De facto discrimination by facially neutral regulation? `in like circumstances'? e.g. requirement to use domestic waste disposal facilities; recycle bottles granting of licences, eg. TV stations, telecomms, banks membership of associations, exchanges, distribution networks national deregulation introduces competition for local firms; TNCs may dominate? IBSR Topic 4

  7. Investment Protection Treaties ML drafts: Abs-Shawcross 1959; OECD 1967; MAI 1998 Bilateral Investment Treaties: BITs since 1959 1989: 385 >>1999: 1,857, among 173 countries Investor = national of Contracting Party directly or indirectly owned (via subsidiaries: only in some BITs) Investment =Assets: contractual rights? IPRs? NT/ Fair & equitable treatment: post-entry pre-entry NT = Right of Establishment (no admissions controls) expropriation compensation - varying standards US Model 1980: 31 in force by 2001 USDoS pre-entry NT = right of establishment, open door subject to listed exceptions (opt-out) IBSR Topic 4

  8. Towards a Multilateral Agreement? WTO > OECD – MAI (failed) >WTO Doha Declaration, Cancun 2003 High Standard (of protection) Investor = national/permanent resident of CP Investments = directly/indirectly owned/controlled Assets = include contractual rights, debts, claims, concessions/permissions, IPRs Treatment: NT/MFN NLFT: no less favourable than Expropriation: direct or indirect; must be: in public interest; non-discriminatory; due process of law; compensation Disciplines on states: transparency; performance requirements; entry of key personnel IBSR Topic 4

  9. Impact on National Regulation Exceptions (General): national security; public order; culture? Exclusions: Opt-Out (MAI)/Opt-In (WTO = GATS): national commitments (balance via negotiations) subject to standstill, roll-back Carve-Outs (from NT and anti-expropriation) taxation; IPRs; privatisation; state monopolies, etc Social/environmental Deregulation? Non-lowering of standards clause: draft MAI State’s `right to regulate in the public interest’? WTO Doha Declaration para. 22 IBSR Topic 4

  10. Enforcement: Dispute-Settlement Negotiation: informal pressures Right to Arbitration: State-State; Investor-State? (NAFTA, BITs) Arbitration Panels Ad Hoc/ chosen from Roster (e.g. NAFTA) 3-Person Panel: one by each side, they choose Chair Confidential to Parties: publication of Award optional (ILR/ILM) NAFTA: Commission. Cross-Border Trucking Applicable Law often unspecified `general principles of law’; `public international law’ Effect of Award binding in international law Treaty (& Award?) may be directly applicable in domestic law of CP IBSR Topic 4

  11. Investor-State WB Washington Convention 1966: ICSID ICSID investment disputes, not commercial transactions Negotiation/conciliation pressures: e.g. 26 claims pending against Argentina Arbitration: ICSID CP and investor of another CP Additional Facility Consent: may be Advance Consent BITs: may be conditional, requires ad hoc agreement Rapid growth of claims: 63 claims now pending at ICSID IBSR Topic 4

  12. Investor-State: enforcement of award Binding in IL, may be directly applicable Enforceable under law of place of arbitration Metalclad: BC Sup Ct review, partially set aside Ad Hoc awards: not binding precedent effects of review decisions by national courts? `interpretation’ by CPs? amendment of treaty? Effects on Host State Sovereignty legal certainty for investors, against arbitrary actions? special supranational law for TNCs? private property protection may block social regulation? IBSR Topic 4

More Related