560 likes | 773 Views
INTRODUCTION. PONDEROSA PINE
E N D
1. RESTORAION AND REHABILITATION OF WATERSHEDS FOLLOWING WILDFIRES Dan Neary1 and Pete Ffolliott21USDA Forest Service, Flagstaff, AZ2University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ
2. INTRODUCTION PONDEROSA PINE & MIXED CONIFERS
PINON-JUNIPER, CHAPARRAL, SAVANNAS
FIRE ADAPTED ECOSYSTEMS
FIRE CESSATION FROM 1880 ONWARDS
3. INTRODUCTION
4. Presentation Objectives DISCUSS
Current Wildfire Situation
Watershed Responses
Restoration vs Rehabilitation
Rodeo-Chediski Example
8. FIRE OUT OF BOUNDS
10. RODEO-CHEDISKI FIREJUNE 18 – JULY 7, 2002 Landscape Scale
Size 183,000 ha
High severity
Out of Natural Range
Phoenix Watershed
High Erosion
Vegetation Shifts
High Costs of Suppression and Restoration
11. MATRIX OF SEVERITIES
12. HIGH SEVERITY FIRE
14. WATERSHED RESPONSES
16. WILDFIRES & FLOODS Range of response
0 to 2,230 X pre-fire
Function of Severity
Largest on small streams
Many Contributing Factors
Most Devastating
Post-fire Effect
17. PEAKFLOW INCREASESMISCELLANEOUS FORESTS
20. POST-FIRE WATERSHEDS RESTORATIONVSREHABILITATION DEFINITION CONFUSION
BIG PROBLEMS
WHAT RESOURCE?
TIME FRAMES (1, 10, 100, etc Years)
COST
ENVIRONMENTAL HURDLES
22. WATERSHED RESTORATION DEFINITION:
1. Putting back into near the original form or unimpaired condition.
2. IS THIS REALLY POSSIBLE?
OBJECTIVE: Speed the return to pre-fire conditions
TIME: 1, 10, 100, 1000, 10000 Years?
23. WATERSHED RESTORATION NATIONAL FIRE PLAN DEFINITION:
“Taking passive or active management actions to increase resiliency and improve landscape conditions so fire and other natural processes can fulfill their appropriate ecological roles.
TIME: 1, 10, 100, 1000, 10000 Years?
24. WATERSHED RESTORATION RESOURCES:
1. Overstory
2. Understory
3. Forest Floor
4. Soils
5. Biota
6. Hydrologic Function
7. Cultural
COMPONENTS: Is everything still there?
TIME: 1, 10, 100, 1000, 10000 Years?
25. WATERSHED REHABILITATION DEFINITION:
1. To return to a former capacity or function
2. THIS IS NOT RESTORATION
OBJECTIVE: To reduce post-fire damage to function in the short-term
TIME: 1-2 Years
26. WATERSHED REHABILITATION BAER: BURNED AREA EMERGENCY REHABILITATION
OBJECTIVES:
Stabilize Soil
Reduce Erosion
Prevent Floods
Stabilize Channels
Prevent Road & Trail Wash Out
Mitigate threats
27. WATERSHED REHABILITATION BAER: BURNED AREA EMERGENCY REHABILITATION
TREATMENTS:
Hillslope
Channel
Road
TIME: Immediately post-fire
A FEW EXAMPLES PROVIDED
33. Waugh Creek Treatments Averaged
34. RODEO-CHEDISKI FIRESTERMER RIDGE STUDY Apache-Sitgreaves NF
Black Mesa RD
Slopes <10%
Little Colorado Basin
Established 1972
Ffolliott & Baker 1977
Soils Typic Cryoboralfs
Vegetation Pondersa Pine and Gambel Oak
Mixed Grass and Forb Understory
35. STERMER RIDGE WATERSHEDS Size 24 ha
WS 3 High Severity
WS 4 L – M Severity
1 m H-Flume Gaged
Vegetation and Soil Sampling Plots – 30 per Watershed
2 Weather Stations at Original Sites
39. STERMER RIDGESTREAMFLOW Ephemeral Channels
Snowmelt Dominated
High and Low Severity
Peakflow Out of Natural Range
Contributed To Larger Basin Flows
Recovery Within 4 Years
44. STERMER RIDGEWATER REPELLENCY 2002 Strong -Mod
100 % WS 3
50 % WS 4
2005
WS 3 & 4 = 0 %
No Slope or Aspect Differences
45. STERMER RIDGEEROSION FIRST YEAR
60 TO 100 Mg/ha
SECOND YEAR
62 TO 79 Mg/ha
46. CHANNEL SEDIMENT
47. STERMER RIDGE VEGETATION RECOVERY
48. STERMER RIDGE LITTER
50. SUMMARY
53. POST-WILDFIRE RESTORATION vs REHABILITATION RESTORATION
Pieces All There
Very Long term
Variable Cost
Works if You Wait
Functions Returned
Natural Process
Hazards Natural
REHABILITATION
Pieces Missing
Short Term (BAER)
Very Expensive
Doesn’t Always Work
Some Function Returns
Human Managed
Mitigate Some Hazards
55. RESTORATION