1 / 16

Interactive Storytelling and Identity Management in Adolescent Males

Interactive Storytelling and Identity Management in Adolescent Males. michael bamberg & luke moissinac Clark University Department of Psychology. Three kinds of narrative approaches. Life-Story Approaches Life-Event Approaches “Small” Stories Short narrative accounts

tgalvan
Download Presentation

Interactive Storytelling and Identity Management in Adolescent Males

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Interactive Storytelling and Identity Management in Adolescent Males michael bamberg & luke moissinac Clark University Department of Psychology

  2. Three kinds of narrative approaches • Life-Story Approaches • Life-Event Approaches • “Small” Stories • Short narrative accounts • Embedded in every-day interactions • Unnoticed as ‘stories’ by the participants • Unnoticed as ‘narratives’ by researchers • But highly relevant for identity formation processes

  3. Identity as iterative, everyday performance • Drawing on Judith Butler’s work (1990) • Identity constituted in performance • Fashioned and revised in everyday interactions • Re-enacted and re-experienced continuously to achieve personal currency • Conversational narrative as a site for iterative identity projects

  4. Narrative dimensions(Ochs & Capps, 2001) • Tellership • one active teller vs. many • Tellability • high vs. low • Embeddedness • detached from surrounding talk vs. situational embeddedness • Moral stance • one moral message vs. different + conflicting messages • Linearity & Temporality • closed temporal + causal order vs. open + spatial

  5. with this in mind:Let’s turn to SMALL stories • Characteristics of “small” stories • Functions of “small” stories • in everyday conversations • in the process of identity formation • in learning to present ‘coherent’ selves • What these small stories accomplish in everyday situations

  6. Characteristics of “SMALL” stories • Short • Conversationally Embedded + Negotiated • before • during • after • Fine tuned positioning strategies • fine-tuned vis-à-vis the audience • fine-tuned vis-à-vis dominant + counter narratives • multiple moral stances (testing out and experimenting with identity projections) • Low in tellability, linearity, temporality + causality

  7. Functions of “SMALL” stories • Practice in doing identity work • Continuous editing of experience • Retelling of experience • Re-tuning these tellings according to • different audiences • different master-narratives • different (developing) senses of ‘who-I-am’ • Resulting in some sense of coherence • though one that is constantly reworked

  8. “Mister Lanoe hit on my mom” 01 A: the lowest grade I ever got was a zero when I forgot to pass in my homework 02 B: miss Brown I remember that my pro- 03 V: SHE WAS THE COOLEST huhhuhhuh {enthusiastically gesturing} 04 B: my project was one day late my China project and she gave me a zero cos it was one day late my mom flipped out at her and I remember when mister Collins gave me a Ben detention= 05 A: =[a Ben detention?] 06 K: [a Ben detention?] 07 B: [he left me] in a room and he left {V nods knowingly} 08 V: DUDE THAT DUDE HIT ON MY MOM

  9. Setting the theme • Teachers and grades • Positioning teachers as adversarial • “she gave me a zero cos it was one day late” • “mister Collins gave me a Ben detention” • Ratifying, then pushing the positioning • “DUDE THAT DUDE HIT ON MY MOM” • Voicing ‘coolness’ • “DUDE” • Displaying knowledge of adult sexuality • “hit on my mom”

  10. 08 V: DUDE THAT DUDE HIT ON MY MOM 09 B: huh[huhhuh] 10 K: [mister Lanoe hit] on my mom he goes to my school (.) he at at summer school= 11 V: =WHO? 12 K: he he’s in my school= 13 V: =who? >what’s his name< 14 K: mister La:: Noe:: {deliberately pronounced} 15 A: I thought you said mister Rabado= 16 V: =uh huhhuh I was about to say what [ (…………..)] 17 K: [anyway he’s in my summer school]

  11. Attempted second story and challenges to narrative reliability • Second story attempt • “mister Lanoe hit on my mom” • Challenges to reliability • “WHO” • “who? What’s his name” • “I thought you said mister Rabado” • Weak responses to challenges • “my school,” “summer school” • over pronunciation

  12. 17 K: [anyway he’s in my summer school] and you know the teachers had to come in I mean the parents you know for the uh >whatever (.) you know (.) look around the school< and then you know mister Lanoe ev’ry see everytime he’d see my mom he kept going “Kev uh your mom comin tomorrow?” <“no mister Lanoe uh the thing (.) is in 2 weeks”> (deliberately) “oh awright” 18 V: [huhhuhhuh] 19 B: [huhhuhhuh] 20 K: he he liked (.) you know (.) yeah=

  13. Neutralizing the challenge • Using a dismissive marker as initiator • “anyway” • Providing additional credible detail • “parents….look around the school” • Recruiting agreement • “you know” • Styling the teacher’s voice as importunate • “everytime,” “comin tomorrow?” • Inverting teacher-student power relationship • Styling own voice as didactic and patient

  14. Positioning: Fine tuning • Vis-à-vis his interlocutors • My experiences are equivalent to yours • We share solidarity against badly behaved teachers • Vis-à-vis master narratives of heterosexuality and adulthood • We can identify and criticize undesirable, desperate forms of sexual conduct • We can turn the tables on adults • Vis-à-vis a ‘sense-of-self’ • Practicing/working toward/testing out a sense of “this is me”

  15. Conclusion • So, rather than assuming the existence of identity + sense of self – and viewing narratives as reflections thereof, we are suggesting studying the emergence of a sense of self by way of exploring the SMALL stories people tell in their EVERYDAY interactions

More Related