1 / 27

Human resources for health in Europe

Human resources for health in Europe. Martin McKee European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies Vilnius September 2005. The issue. Health care is a labour intensive sector

roxanne
Download Presentation

Human resources for health in Europe

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Human resources for health in Europe Martin McKee European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies Vilnius September 2005

  2. The issue • Health care is a labour intensive sector • Demanding an appropriate mix of highly motivated people in the right place at the right time with the right set of competencies • Effective, efficient and high quality health services will be delivered • People and communities will enjoy a better health status • The health care workforce is key to improving the delivery of effective health care

  3. Challenges facing health care • Changing patterns of disease • Socio-demographic transition • Emerging technologies • Emerging models of care • Changing expectations of consumers • Changes in the political and economic environment: globalisation, economic constraints, European integration and enlargement,…

  4. Current imbalances in the health care workforce in Europe • Skills shortages • Inadequate deployment • Disconnection between the education system and health policy objectives • Poor working conditions • Perverse incentives • Shortcomings of regulatory arrangements

  5. “OK, we’ll vote. How many say the heart has four chambers?” … Trained staff don’t appear overnight

  6. Two approaches (among many) • Changing skill-mix • Enhancing performance

  7. Enhancement • For medicine – a continuous process • Thoracic surgeons →cardiac surgeons → transplant surgeons • For nursing and other health professionals • often involves encroaching on role of physicians • Consistent evidence that nurses achieve better results than physicians in management of chronic diseases • However in some other areas (e.g. paramedics) results mixed

  8. Substitution • When nurses replace doctors seeing patients with undifferentiated primary care problems, satisfaction is greater but consultations longer and more investigations ordered • In general, nurses have greater interpersonal skills than doctors but physicians better at solving technical problems • Results highly context specific

  9. Nurse-led clinics • Growing uptake in primary and secondary care • Especially in countries where team working already established (which most often are tax-funded systems) • Widespread evidence that outcomes better than with traditional physician-led care

  10. Examples of better outcomes with nurse-led care • Reduced mortality and admissions with heart failure (Sweden) • Better glycaemic control in diabetes (Netherlands) • Improved detection of diabetic nephropathy (UK) • Better management of anticoagulation (UK) • Better management of COPD (UK)

  11. Transmural care in The Netherlands • As in other social insurance funded countries, hospital and home care delivered by separate organisations • Transmural nurse-led clinics established to bridge the gap • Evidence of benefit inconclusive

  12. Potential substitutes for nursing roles

  13. Delegation • Greater use of higher grade nurses associated with higher quality of care • General practitioners achieve better results than junior doctors in emergency departments • Conclusion: experience counts

  14. Innovation • Emergence of new jobs – phlebotomists, specialist nurses, IT specialists • Impact of changing technology – near patient testing displacing laboratory staff

  15. New settings for care • New skills needed for: • Stand alone emergency centres • Telephone triage systems • Enhancements in community pharmacy

  16. The issues • Does what is being done work, whoever is doing it? • Is there sufficient training and support for new roles? • Are there legal or regulatory barriers to change? • Do the incentives support or obstruct change?

  17. However • The status quo is not an option • Health systems are complex adaptive human systems • A change in one area often has unintended consequences in another • You cannot change someone’s role and keep their status the same

  18. Enhancing performance • High quality health services require the right mix of resources: • Human resources • The right mix of people with the right skills • Physical resources • With the tools of the trade • Intellectual resources • In a knowledge-based system • Social resources • Built on trust and co-operation

  19. Theoretical approaches to changing practice

  20. What works? • Consistently effective • Managerial approaches (supervision, audit and feedback); group processes; • Mixed results • Combined managerial and educational; economic incentives; computer-based training; distance learning; telemedicine; community participation • May be useful with other interventions • Dissemination of guidelines; job aids; self-assessment; • Other • Training ineffective with large groups and didactic teaching, better with small groups and focused discussion Rowe et al., Lancet 2005

  21. Putting it into practice • Health worker factors • Patient factors • Work factors • Health facility environment • Administrative environment • Political and economic environment

  22. In conclusion … • There is no magic bullet • Improvements are more likely to come from doing a lot of things well • … responding to emerging problems and monitoring the effects of change • … and making sure that someone is in charge of seeing that things happen

More Related