1 / 30

Ergonomics – What Works?

Ergonomics – What Works?. Dr Richard Graveling FIEHF Principal Ergonomics Consultant IOM, Edinburgh. Ergonomics – What Works?. Brief overview of E rgonomics Comments on two Cochrane reviews Exploration of what works in Ergonomics. Ergonomics – What Works?. Brief overview of ergonomics

Download Presentation

Ergonomics – What Works?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Ergonomics – What Works? Dr Richard Graveling FIEHF Principal Ergonomics Consultant IOM, Edinburgh

  2. Ergonomics – What Works? • Brief overview of Ergonomics • Comments on two Cochrane reviews • Exploration of what works in Ergonomics

  3. Ergonomics – What Works? Brief overview of ergonomics • What ergonomics isn’t!

  4. Ergonomics – What Works? Brief overview of ergonomics • There is a lot more to ergonomics than office chairs (and computers). • Ergonomics is about designing for people, wherever they interact with other people, products, systems or processes.

  5. Ergonomics – What Works? Brief overview of ergonomics • The scientific discipline concerned with the understanding of interactions among human and other elements of a system, and the profession that applies theory, principles, data and methods to design in order to optimise human well-being and overall system performance. (ISO 26800)

  6. Ergonomics – What Works? Brief overview of ergonomics • When a pilot misunderstands a poorly designed control and a plane crashes into the Atlantic – that’s ergonomics. • When systems don’t prevent a patient from being given ten times the safe dose - that’s ergonomics. • When a catalogue of design, system and human mistakes result in the worst ever offshore oil disaster – much of that is ergonomics.

  7. Ergonomics – What Works? Two Cochran reviews: • Hoe et al (2012) Ergonomic design and training for preventing work-related musculoskeletal disorders of the upper limb and neck in adults. • Verhagenet al (2013) Conservative interventions for treating work-related complaints of the arm, neck or shoulder in adults.

  8. Ergonomics – What Works? Two Cochran reviews: • Few, if any of the interventions appeared to attempt to relate the nature of the problem to the nature of the disorder. • For example, one review finding was for moderate evidence that providing a different mouse didn’t prevent neck/shoulder disorders. Why would you expect it to?

  9. Ergonomics – What Works? Other evidence for prevention: • There are a number of case studies in the literature – but they don’t meet the rigours of reviews such as Cochrane due to no control group, no blinding, etc.

  10. Ergonomics – What Works? Other evidence for prevention: • For example, Tesh (2014) identified a problem with the design of a medical equipment production process. • A focussed intervention produced positive benefits in a reduction in the incidence of MSDs amongst the workforce and a financial payback time within less than two years.

  11. Ergonomics – What Works? Other evidence for prevention: Make the punishment fit the crime: • In a similar vein, Anema et al (2004) reported on a study of RTW interventions in sufferers of chronic LBP. • The interventions weren’t the same in each case – but were tailored to the needs of the individual. • The outcome was a significant reduction in sickness absence.

  12. Ergonomics – What Works? Make the punishment fit the crime: • Not all MSDs are caused by work. • Intervention must relate to nature of injury and understanding of probable causal mechanism. • For example, where is the value in providing new seats for sewing machine operators suffering from neck and shoulder problems (as was reported in one ineffective study)?

  13. Ergonomics – What Works? Problems stem from prolonged neck flexion and/or shoulder elevation • Any solution must address these sources – modifying the ‘offending’ posture.

  14. Ergonomics – What Works? Why fixate on this? When faced with this?

  15. Ergonomics – What Works? What does work? • Understand aetiology • Observe • Apply ergonomic principles

  16. Ergonomics – What Works? Understand aetiology: • Shoulder impingement reduces blood flow – both mechanically and hydrostatically.

  17. Ergonomics – What Works? Observe

  18. Ergonomics – What Works? Provided new tool which was a more appropriate shape.

  19. Ergonomics – What Works? Understand aetiology: • Wrist flexion/extension increases pressure in carpal tunnel (now part of PD A12)

  20. Ergonomics – What Works? Understand aetiology: • Gripping (and lifting) increases pressure in carpal tunnel (not part of PD A12) From: Rempel et al, 1994

  21. Ergonomics – What Works? Understand aetiology: • Work with computer keyboard or mouse can increase carpal tunnel pressure. From: Rempel et al, 1994

  22. Ergonomics – What Works? Understand aetiology: • Epidemiology suggests relationship between CTS symptoms and computer work NOT causal. Supported by pressure studies which suggest greater pressure required for vascular effects in nerve.

  23. Ergonomics – What Works? Observe: Provocation not causation – but still need to address. Make sure mouse fits hand and enables a straight wrist posture

  24. Ergonomics – What Works? Different keyboard or mouse can be helpful – if it reduces gripping (mouse) or improves wrist posture when mousing or keying.

  25. Ergonomics – What Works? Different keyboard or mouse can be helpful – if it reduces gripping (mouse) or improves wrist posture when mousing or keying.

  26. Ergonomics – What Works? Observe

  27. Ergonomics – What Works? Observe: How do we deal with these?

  28. Ergonomics – What Works? Apply ergonomic principles: • The human body is designed for movement. • There is a growing body of evidence that the absence of movement plays a significant role in the causation of (office) MSDs. • The effects of lack of movement are exacerbated by (relatively) high muscle forces. • The further away a joint angle is from neutral – the greater the potential strain.

  29. Ergonomics – What Works? Keep moving?

  30. Ergonomics – What Works? Questions or comments? (thanks to Calman and the Royal College of Psychiatrists)

More Related