1 / 42

Constitution, Society, and Leadership Week 3 Unit 1 The Constitution in Historical Context:

Constitution, Society, and Leadership Week 3 Unit 1 The Constitution in Historical Context: Overview and Non-American Influences. Christopher Dreisbach, Ph.D. Johns Hopkins University. Week 3 Overview- i. There were many historical precursors to and influences on the U. S. Constitution

marly
Download Presentation

Constitution, Society, and Leadership Week 3 Unit 1 The Constitution in Historical Context:

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Constitution, Society, and LeadershipWeek 3 Unit 1 The Constitution in Historical Context: Overview and Non-American Influences Christopher Dreisbach, Ph.D. Johns Hopkins University

  2. Week 3 Overview-i • There were many historical precursors to and influences on the U. S. Constitution • And the Constitution has had a big influence on American and international history since its adoption • This week looks at some of the more noteworthy pre-constitutional and post-ratification influences.

  3. Week 3 Overview-ii • Pre-constitutional influences • Unit 1: Non-American people and events • Unit 2: Social Contract Theory • Unit 3: Early American people and events • The Constitution’s post-ratification influences • Our focus will be on the national influences on • People • Events

  4. Week 3 Overview-iv • Unit 4: From Ratification through the Civil War • Unit 5: From Reconstruction through WW II • Unit 6: From 1945 to the Present

  5. Pre-Constitutional InfluencesNon-American: Overview • There are two major historical forces that precede and aim toward the Constitution • Secular • Religious • Look for these aspects as we examine • The Code of Hammurabi (Secular, with religious undertones) • The Israelites and the First Covenant (Religious) • Athenian Democracy (Secular) • The Roman Republic (Secular) • Christianity: The City of Man v. The City of God (Religious) • The Magna Carta (Secular)

  6. The Code of Hammurabi-i • Around 1760 BC, Hammurabi, King of Babylonia took over most of Mesopotamia. • In time he issued a set of 282 laws, written in cuneiform on a stone stele, 7.3 feet high and 6.75 feet in circumference at the base. • Now in the Louvre The Code of Hammurabi

  7. The Code of Hammurabi-ii • This was a novel and noteworthy attempt to establish a permanent law—etched in stone--rather than leaving legal matters up to the caprice of the ruler. • The foundation of the code was the lex talionis—law of retribution: “eye for an eye” • Hammurabi claimed to have received these laws from God • But he replaced priestly judges with civilian judges

  8. The Code of Hammurabi-iii • In brief, the code included laws about • Offences and crimes such as witchcraft, robbery, and perjury: #1-25 • Land and houses: #26-65 • #66-99 are missing • Commercial law: #100-126 • Marriage:#127-161 • Inheritance: #162-177 • Women of religion: #178-184 • Adoption and wet-nursing: #185-194 • Assault and damage to persons or property • Agricultural work and offences: #241-267 • Rates of hire and wages #268-272 • Slaves:#278-282

  9. Israelites and the First Covenant-i • Judeo-Christianity has had a profound influence on American thought and history. • Key to the Jewish influence is the Ancient Israelites’ commitment to • Law • Covenant • Jewish Law or Halakha (=“the way to go”) is said to • Come from God • Be transmitted through the prophets, especially Moses

  10. Israelites and the First Covenant-ii The best known are the 10 Commandments • Exodus 20: 2-17 and Deuteronomy 5:6-21 The Jewish Bible, or Tanakh, lists 613 laws, commands, or mitzvot, according to Maimonides, an influential 12th Century Jewish philosopher.

  11. Israelites and the First Covenant-iii • In Jewish history, according to the Tanakh, God made 6 sequential covenants with His people. These included covenants with • Adam (Gen. 1-3; c. 3950 BCE) • Based on good works • Made by God gratuitously • Broken when Adam and Eve “ate the apple.”

  12. Israelites and the First Covenant-iv • Noah (Gen. 6-9; c. 2800 BCE) • Six basic features of this covenant • Initiated and dictated by God • Made with Noah and all successive generations • A universal covenant covering all humans and animals • Unconditional • God’s promise never again to destroy the world by flood. • The rainbow as sign

  13. Israelites and the First Covenant-v • Abraham (Gen. 12; c. 2000 BCE) • Three basic promises • Land • A long line of descendants • Other blessings • A great reputation • Protection • Key to Abraham’s blessing is his unswerving obedience to God. • Unconditional and Eternal • Circumcision as sign

  14. Israelites and the First Covenant-vi • Moses • Sinaitic (Ex. 19-24; c. 1450 BCE) • Ten Commandments • God makes the Covenant because of his love for the Israelites (Deut. 7:6-10) • The Book of the Covenant: Ex. 20:24-23:19 • The Law as sign • Palestinian (Deut. 29-30; c. 1400 BCE) • God’s clarification of the Sinaitic covenant • Stresses human responsibility over God’s promise

  15. Israelites and the First Covenant-vii • David (2 Sam. 6-7; c. 1060 BCE) • God’s promise to give Israel its own place • All who sit on the throne of Jerusalem will be descendants of David • Jeremiah (Jer. 31; c. 600 BCE) • Israel will be restored for good. • God will write his word on everybody’s heart. • Note: From Gen. 1 to Jer. 31 more and more people become direct parties to the Covenant

  16. Israelites and the First Covenant-viii • Comparing Hammurabi’s Code with The Israelites’ notions of law and covenant • Similarities • Common Semitic roots • Israelites were in Canaan and Babylon • Many similar or identical judgments concerning, e.g. • Sorcery • Law of deposit • Punishment of kidnapping • Injury to pregnant women • Regulation of shepherds

  17. Israelites and the First Covenant-ix • Differences • Hammurabi’s society was more settled than Israel. • The Israelite Code of the Covenant is couched in history, unlike the Code of Hammurabi. • The Code of Hammurabi makes clear class distinctions; the Israelite code does not. • The Israelite code is much more theocratic than the Code of Hammurabi. • The Israelite code is based on a covenant with God; the Code of Hammurabi is not.

  18. Athenian Democracy-i • Greek democracy flourished to varying degrees and with occasional breaks from 600-322 BCE. • Ancient Greek Democracy had 6 stages • Solon (600-561 BCE) elected leader in 594 • Divided Athens into four political groups • Created civilian assembly, allowing lowest class to serve on juries. • Tyranny of the Pisistratids (561-510): Benevolent despots

  19. Athenian Democracy-ii • Moderate democracy of Cleisthenes (510-462) • Gives many more people citizenship • Gives all citizens the right to vote in the assembly • Divides Athens into ten tribes, each sending 50 people to the Council of the 500 • Radical democracy of Pericles (462-431) • Oligarchy (431-403) • Peloponnesian War • Two oligarchic attempts to destroy democracy: 411, 404 • Radical democracy (403-322): • 80 years of stability for Athens • Over 1500 democracies throughout Greece • Socrates (d. 399), Plato (d. 347), and Aristotle (d. 322) lived during this period • And had as much influence on western thought as anybody.

  20. Athenian Democracy-iii • During this period, Athens had 7 constitutions. • The Constitution during Aristotle’s time • Allowed all citizens to participate in government • Required most magistrates and council members to be elected by lottery • Two comparisons worth making for our purposes • Hebraic Law v. Hellenistic (Greek) Law • Greek Democracy v. American Democracy

  21. Athenian Democracy-iv • Hebraic Law v. Hellenistic Law • Similarities • Both develop in the eastern Mediterranean, so • Common cultural background • Common mindset • Both aim at “man’s perfection or salvation.” • Both societies determined by “a sovereignty of law.” • Graeco-Hebrew literature can be distinguished from the rest of Ancient Near East literature. • Phoenicians as “main carriers of Semitic culture to the West. • Similar sets of values, especially honor and shame. • Analogy between Athenian assembly and Deut 16:18-18:22 • Adult free males singled out • Responsible for electing judges • “Remarkable democratic tendency”

  22. Athenian Democracy-v • Differences • Different means to achieving the same end • Hebraism: conduct and obedience • Hellenism: seeing things as they really are • Different notions of happiness • Hebraism: “He that keepeth the law, happy is he…” • Hellenism: “Happy is he who thinks aright.” • Different governing ideas • Hebraism: Strictness of conscience • Hellenism: Spontaneity of consciousness • Different moral focus • Hebraism: Diligently doing one’s duty • Hellenism: Knowing grounds of one’s duty • Different sources of growth • Hebraism: Semitic • Hellenism: Indo-European • Different “triumphs” • Hebraism: Christianity • Hellenism: The Renaissance • Note: Puritanism as a reaction of Hebraism against Hellenism.

  23. Athenian Democracy-vi • Greek Democracy v. American Democracy • Scale: Athens had a much smaller population • Level of participation: direct v. representative • Eligibility: Greek citizens were free males and made up about 25% of Athens’ population • Different Court systems, e.g., in Athens’ Courts • Jury duty voluntary • No evidence allowed • No public prosecutor • No cross examination of witnesses • Defendant defended self with a speech before the jury.

  24. Roman Republic-i • The Roman Republic lasted from approximately 510 BC to between 44BC and 29 BC with the rise in power of the Caesarian dictatorship and the Empire. • Note that The Republic started about the same time the Athenian Democracy of Cleisthenes started, • Which suggests a Zeitgeist of sorts at work

  25. Roman Republic-ii • The Roman Constitution, like the British Constitution over a millennium later, was not a single document, but a loose set of laws, customs, and judicial decisions. • Although the 12Tables, a set of Roman laws written down c. 495 BCE, often stand as the centerpiece of the Roman Republic’s legal thought.

  26. Roman Republic-iii • There were two major governing bodies • The Senate • The Legislative Assemblies • With a third group, the magistrates, playing a central roll across both bodies, as heads of various political constituencies • Akin to governors and mayors, for example

  27. Roman Republic-iv • The Senate • Controlled the treasury and foreign affairs • Offered advice to the magistrates • Which magistrates usually treated as legal edicts • Consisted of unpaid members appointed by a type of magistrate—the Consuls and, later, the Censors • Could appoint a dictator during emergencies • Had a strict ethics code prohibiting senators from • Engaging in public commerce • Leaving Italy without Senate permission

  28. Roman Republic-v • The Legislative Assemblies • Were elected by the people • Were the ultimate sovereigns of the Republic • Voted on legislative, executive, and judicial matters • Appointed the magistrates • Consisted of different assemblies populated according to ethnicity, military status, or wealth, for example.

  29. Christianity-i • Greco-Roman and Hebraic influences converge in Christianity • The first Christians were Jews who believed that Jesus Christ was their Messiah or Savior • Jesus was executed c. 30 CE by the Romans • Whose empire included the Jewish Middle East • And according to Christianity • Jesus rose from the dead three days later • As an act of sacrifice for the sins of his followers

  30. Christianity-ii • Originally Gentiles who wanted to convert to Christianity had to become Jewish first • But this requirement was soon waived. • One of the most influential early Christians was Paul, a Greek-speaking Jew, whose letters make up a major part of the New Testament.

  31. Christianity-iii • For its first 3 centuries, Christianity had little political influence • But in 313 the Emperor Constantine, in the Edict of Milan, gave Christianity new authority, • After which Christianity quickly grew to be the major political and cultural force in Western culture and in many other parts of the world.

  32. Christianity-iv • The Church was a fairly cohesive body until 1054 • When the Church split into an Eastern bloc and a Western bloc • The Western church was controlled by Roman Catholicism until the Protestant Reformation began in 1517 • First under Martin Luther • Then joined by John Calvin and other reformers

  33. Christianity-v • A vast majority of the non-native founders of the United States of America were Protestants. • A common political model in Christianity distinguishes • The City of God, the eternal heaven that awaits believers • The City of Man, the condition of humans in this world—both believers and non-believers

  34. Christianity-vi • Four influential Christians who accepted this model: • Augustine (d. 430) • The City of Man • Civil society=”an assemblage [of people] associated by a common acknowledgement of right and by a community of interest.” • Justice is the main virtue of civil society • 1. Justice is “the right ordering of all things according to reason” • 2. Justice is realized where body is ruled by soul, soul is ruled by reason, and reason is ruled by God. • City as the locus of justice • City as punishment for original sin • Civil society cannot cause virtue, but it can restrain vice. • Self-love as the driving dynamic in the City of Man • Temporal law • A bad law is no law at all. • Natural man as the denizen of the City of Man • The City of Man complements the City of God

  35. Christianity-vii • Augustine (ctd) • The City of God • The city of spiritual man • Following Christ as the driving dynamic of the City of God • Eternal law • Sovereign in City of Man appointed by God • So Christians have a duty of civil obedience

  36. Christianity-viii • Thomas Aquinas (d. 1274) • City of Man= “the truly self-sufficient human association, the only one capable of securing conditions of virtue and satisfying all of man’s earthly needs and aspirations.” • Directs people toward their temporal end or natural purpose • Justice as the epitome of social virtue • Monarchy as the best form of government • By nature, superior rules inferior • Stability requires the rule of law • City of God • Eternal Law • Directs people toward their supernatural end or purpose

  37. Christianity-ix • Martin Luther (d. 1546) and John Calvin (d. 1564) • Agree about the City of God and the City of Man. • Relation of the two kingdoms • “Spiritual government leads to love of God” • “Temporal government leads us to serve our neighbors.” • State’s dual function • As “dyke against sin” • To protect the church • The sword belongs only to the City of Man. • Preferred type of government • Luther-Monarchy: human corruption is magnified in the collective, so no popular sovereignty • Calvin-Aristocracy: need for checks and balances

  38. The Magna Carta-i • The Magna Carta, first written in 1215, is often said to be the primary forerunner of the Declaration of Independence and the U. S. Constitution • Originally it was drafted by British Barons, wealthy landowners and servants to the King, • Who were fed up with the King’s capricious • Taxing • Administration of justice

  39. The Magna Carta-ii • The charter required the King • Tax fairly • Administer justice fairly • Respect private property • Respect other freedoms

  40. The Magna Carta-iii • In a now famous ceremony, King John confirmed the Magna Carta at Runnymede field on June 15, 1215. • He soon claimed to have been coerced into the confirmation • Eventually the 1215 draft was annulled • But was restored in 1217 by John’s heir, King Henry III • And rewritten in 1225, the version most familiar to us

  41. The Magna Carta-iv • Although the Charter’s purpose was to force the King to redress the Baron’s grievances • The use of the term “freemen” to refer to the Barons was broadened centuries later to cover the ordinary British citizen. • During the American Revolution supporters frequently invoked the Magna Carta to support their grievances against King George III

  42. Constitution, Society, and LeadershipWeek 3 Unit 1 The Constitution in Historical Context: Overview and Non-American Influences Christopher Dreisbach, Ph.D. Johns Hopkins University

More Related