Advertisement
1 / 35

Assessment and Differentiation


Assessment and Differentiation. Timothy Shanahan University of Illinois at Chicago. Instructional differentiation. Adjustments to instruction that are made in order to increase learning for different children (made on the basis of need or circumstances). Instructional differentiation.

Presentation posted in : General

Download Presentation

Assessment and Differentiation

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other sites. SlideServe reserves the right to change this policy at anytime.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.











- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -




Presentation Transcript


Assessment and differentiation l.jpg

Assessment and Differentiation

Timothy Shanahan

University of Illinois at Chicago


Instructional differentiation l.jpg

Instructional differentiation

  • Adjustments to instruction that are made in order to increase learning for different children (made on the basis of need or circumstances)


Instructional differentiation3 l.jpg

Instructional differentiation

  • Four kinds of adjustment:

    --Content coverage

    --Amount of teaching provided

    --Level of instruction

    --Intensity of instruction


Reasons for differentiation l.jpg

Reasons for Differentiation

  • One size definitely doesn’t fit all when it comes to teaching

  • Universal lessons for an entire classroom of kids is the most efficient delivery system (unless one considers learning)


Reasons for differentiation5 l.jpg

Reasons for Differentiation

  • Kids miss out on some instruction

  • Kids don’t succeed with the instruction that is given

  • Kids are at very different levels of performance

  • Kids learn at different rates


Role of assessment l.jpg

Role of Assessment

  • Differentiation implies decisions

  • If you are going to raise achievement, then you need to make the right decisions

  • This leads to the use of assessment (data on student learning on which to make decisions about differentiation)


Some basic assessment terminology l.jpg

Some basic assessment terminology

  • Validity: estimate of how well a test measures what it claims to measure


Some basic assessment terminology8 l.jpg

Some basic assessment terminology

  • Reliability: estimate of how stable test scores are (without reliability, can’t have validity)


Some basic assessment terminology9 l.jpg

Some basic assessment terminology

  • Benchmark: establishing cut scores on a test that have predictive value


Some basic assessment terminology10 l.jpg

Some basic assessment terminology

  • Efficiency: ratio of benefit to cost (how much information do you get for the amount of resources, including time, needed to get the information)


Slide11 l.jpg

????

So what data can we use?


Accountability assessment l.jpg

Accountability Assessment

  • Large-scale, standardized assessment data is available (group administered standard tests commercially available or from the state)

  • These tests are often high quality in terms of reliability and validity

  • They tend not to match well with instruction or the instructional calendar (too “expensive” to give more than once or twice a year, and usually not given even that often)


Accountability assessment13 l.jpg

Accountability Assessment


Informal reading inventories l.jpg

Informal Reading Inventories

  • These have developed since 1914 (William S. Gray, Emmett Betts)

  • They can provide an assessment of sight vocabulary, phonics, oral reading fluency, and comprehension

  • Used to establish three reading levels (independent, instructional, frustration)

  • Aligned with instruction

  • Take about 30 minutes to an hour to administer

  • Commercial versions


Informal reading inventories15 l.jpg

Informal Reading Inventories


Running records l.jpg

Running Records

  • Developed in the 1970s (Marie Clay, Ken Goodman)

  • Provide a reading process analysis

  • Identify degree to which students use context and decoding

  • Most useful in Grade 1

  • Can be given frequently, but take ~10 minutes per administration


Running records17 l.jpg

Running Records


Curriculum based assessment l.jpg

Curriculum-Based Assessment

  • These developed since the 1970s (Stan Deno, Roland Good)

  • Can evaluate student performance in any basic skill area

  • Just a dipstick, not an analysis

  • Most useful in Grade 1

  • Can be given frequently, but still take about 2-3 mins. per administration


Dibels l.jpg

DIBELS


Four kinds of differentiation l.jpg

Four kinds of differentiation

--Content coverage

--Amount of teaching provided

--Level of instruction

--Intensity of instruction


Content coverage and amount of instruction l.jpg

Content coverage and Amount of instruction

  • Difficult to separate these

  • Overall low achievement would indicate the need for more time

  • Specific weaknesses would suggest additional time on particular elements

  • Two patterns of poor readers


Content coverage time l.jpg

Content coverage / time

--Informal reading inventories can guide greater time allocation to sight vocabulary, oral reading fluency, and comprehension instruction

--However, their ability to identify decoding problems is limited, and they are likely to overestimate fluency as children get older


Content coverage time23 l.jpg

Content coverage/ time

--Running Records can guide greater time allocation to oral reading fluency, decoding, and reading comprehension

--However, they may encourage teaching of context use for decoding, and tend not to alter content coverage (typical response is to change levels, not content)


Content coverage time24 l.jpg

Content coverage / time

--CBMs can guide greater time allocation to letters, phonemic awareness, decoding, oral reading fluency

--CBMs only guide alteration of time to basic skills (they are silent on higher level skills, which may discourage teachers from emphasizing these)


Level of instruction l.jpg

Level of instruction

  • Instruction can be too hard or too easy

  • One way to facilitate learning is to put children at a level where they can make optimum progress

  • Mixed research results on the effectiveness of this

  • Can overdo it to the point that it leads to a reduction in the amount of teaching


Level of instruction26 l.jpg

Level of instruction

--Informal reading inventories can guide changes in level of instruction (and can give guidance for independent reading)

--Informal reading inventories usually neglect speed which can lead to overestimates of reading levels—particularly in the upper grades


Level of instruction27 l.jpg

Level of instruction

--Running Records can guide changes in level of instruction (particularly within grade 1)

--Running Records are not used much beyond Grade 1, but they likely suffer the same problem that IRIs do in terms of overplacement


Level of instruction28 l.jpg

Level of instruction

--CBMs can guide changes in level of instruction (not clear what this means overall)

--With the exception of fluency, basic skills don’t have clear gradations in levels of instruction, so CBMs don’t provide a specification of what is needed within the category


Intensity of instruction l.jpg

Intensity of instruction

  • Increased attention

  • Increased interaction

  • Increased repetition and guidance


Intensity of instruction30 l.jpg

Intensity of instruction

--Informal reading inventories are unlikely to guide changes in intensity (except grossly)


Intensity of instruction31 l.jpg

Intensity of instruction

--Running Records are unlikely to guide changes in intensity (except grossly)


Intensity of instruction32 l.jpg

Intensity of instruction

--CBMs can guide changes in intensity of teaching because of the levels of performance identified


What is needed l.jpg

What is needed?

  • Assessments of key components

  • Schedule or plan for assessment

  • Group decisions

  • Ability to move resources


What is missing l.jpg

What is missing?

  • Even more frequent attention to learning success

  • Need for frequent observation within instruction

  • Assessment cards


Slide35 l.jpg

Thank you very much!

Timothy Shanahan

University of Illinois at Chicago