1 / 37

Structural and Failure Analysis: Tasks, WBS, and Cost Estimates Shahram Sharafat and Nasr Ghoniem University of Calif

Structural and Failure Analysis: Tasks, WBS, and Cost Estimates Shahram Sharafat and Nasr Ghoniem University of California Los Angeles, CA. US ITER TBM Costing Kickoff Meeting AmeriTel Inn – Idaho Falls Spectrum Idaho Falls, ID Aug. 9 – 12, 2005. Topics. Objectives Interdependencies

kamuzu
Download Presentation

Structural and Failure Analysis: Tasks, WBS, and Cost Estimates Shahram Sharafat and Nasr Ghoniem University of Calif

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Structural and Failure Analysis: Tasks, WBS, and Cost Estimates Shahram Sharafat and Nasr Ghoniem University of California Los Angeles, CA. US ITER TBM Costing Kickoff MeetingAmeriTel Inn – Idaho Falls Spectrum Idaho Falls, IDAug. 9 – 12, 2005

  2. Topics • Objectives • Interdependencies • Scope and Tasks • WBS Strawman • Task Force Skeleton • Preliminary Cost Estimates

  3. Structural and Failure Analysis Objectives • Mission Statement: “To assure the structural integrity of the TBM during normal and off-normal conditions for safe ITER operation.” • Scope: To perform Structural and Failure Mode Analysis (SFA) of the entire TBM (global SFA), TBM substructures (local SFA), and TBM auxiliary structural components (supports, pipes, joints,…) • Impactof SFA: • - Design modifications, • - Fabrication & manufacturing specifications, • - Defining sub-module test requirements, • - Safety assurance.

  4. Topics • Objectives • Interdependencies • Scope and Tasks • WBS Strawman • Task Force Skeleton • Preliminary Cost Estimates

  5. DESIGN MATERIALPROPERTIES Interdependency of Structural & Failure Analysis FABRICATION (Joining) DAMAGE (Operation)

  6. Structural and Failure Analysis Interdependencies • SFA Requirement: Concurrent material property data, material property models, and large-scale FEM analysis.

  7. Topics • Objectives • Interdependencies • Scope and Tasks • WBS Strawman • Task Force Skeleton • Preliminary Cost Estimates

  8. Structural and Failure Analysis Scope & Tasks Structural &Failure Analysis Computations (Task A) TBM - Design (Task B) TBM–Operation Damage (Task D) TBM–Fabrication & Engineering (Task C) Integration (Task E)

  9. Topics • Objectives • Interdependencies • Scope and Tasks • WBS Strawman • Task Force Skeleton • Preliminary Cost Estimates

  10. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main Expand All TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Modeling & Computations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.7 Justify3-D Models used for Geometry and Loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with Analytical or Experimental Results A.2.3 Compare results with Acceptance Criteria A.2.4 Determine Uncertainties A.2.5 Establish "Design by Experiment" Needs A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results in Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database

  11. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main Expand All TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Modeling & Computations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.1.1 Thermal A.1.1.2 Mechanical A.1.1.3 Thermo-Mechanical A.1.1.4 Multiphysics A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.7 Justify3-D Models used for Geometry and Loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with Analytical or Experimental Results A.2.3 Compare results with Acceptance Criteria A.2.4 Determine Uncertainties A.2.5 Establish "Design by Experiment" Needs A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results on Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database

  12. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Modeling & Computations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.2.1 Global SFA (entire components) A.1.2.2 Local or Substructure Analysis A.1.2.3 TBM Structural Component A.1.2.4 Breeder A.1.2.5 Structure-Breeder Interaction A.1.2.6 TBM Support Structure A.1.2.7 Piping A.1.2.8 Solid Joints (HIP, welds, brazes, coatings) A.1.2.9 Frictional Joints (flanges, bolts, fittings) A.1.2.10 Flexible Joint A.1.2.11 Cooling Manifolds A.1.2.12 Other: Keys, Gaskets, etc. A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.7 Justify3-D Models used for Geometry and Loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with Analytical or Experimental Results A.2.3 Compare results with Acceptance Criteria A.2.4 Determine Uncertainties A.2.5 Establish "Design by Experiment" Needs A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results on Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database Expand All

  13. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Modeling & Computations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.3.1 Normal Operation A.1.3.2 Off-Normal Operation A.1.3.3 Transients A.1.3.4 Cyclic A.1.3.5 Creep A.1.3.6 Disruption A.1.3.7 Start-Up A.1.3.8 Shut-Down A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.7 Justify3-D Models used for Geometry and Loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with Analytical or Experimental Results A.2.3 Compare results with Acceptance Criteria A.2.4 Determine Uncertainties A.2.5 Establish "Design by Experiment" Needs A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results on Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database Expand All

  14. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Modeling & Computations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.4.1 Elastic A.1.4.2 Inelastic A.1.4.2.1 Load Limit & Elastic-Perfectly Plastic A.1.4.2.2 Elastic-Plastic A.1.4.3 Buckling A.1.4.4 Modal A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.7 Justify3-D Models used for Geometry and Loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with Analytical or Experimental Results A.2.3 Compare results with Acceptance Criteria A.2.4 Determine Uncertainties A.2.5 Establish "Design by Experiment" Needs A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results on Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database Expand All

  15. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Modeling & Computations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements A.1.5.1 Operational A.1.5.2 Likely A.1.5.3 Unlikely A.1.5.4 Extremely Unlikely Event A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.7 Justify3-D Models used for Geometry and Loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with Analytical or Experimental Results A.2.3 Compare results with Acceptance Criteria A.2.4 Determine Uncertainties A.2.5 Establish "Design by Experiment" Needs A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results on Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database Expand All

  16. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Modeling & Computations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.6.1 Model A.1.6.1.1 Component/design geometry details A.1.6.1.2 Interface information A.1.6.1.3 Boundary conditions A.1.6.1.4 Loads A.1.6.1.5 Loading History A.1.6.1.6 Explanatory Diagrams A.1.6.1.7 CAD model transferability A.1.6.2 Material Property Data and Models A.1.6.2.1 Property data A.1.6.2.2 Property models (constitutive eqs., damage functions) A.1.7 Justify3-D Models used for Geometry and Loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with Analytical or Experimental Results A.2.3 Compare results with Acceptance Criteria A.2.4 Determine Uncertainties A.2.5 Establish "Design by Experiment" Needs A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results on Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database Expand All

  17. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Modeling & Computations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.7 Justify3-D Models used for Geometry and Loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.8.1 Import or create 3-D models A.1.8.1 Justify 3-D model simplifications (if any) A.1.8.1 Justify loading model A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with Analytical or Experimental Results A.2.3 Compare results with Acceptance Criteria A.2.4 Determine Uncertainties A.2.5 Establish "Design by Experiment" Needs A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results on Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database Expand All

  18. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Modeling & Computations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.7 Justify3-D Models used for Geometry and Loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.1.9.1 FEM: A.1.9.1.1 Establish computational needs A.1.9.1.2 Upload and run FEM A.1.9.1.3 Archive model, loading, and results A.1.9.2 Perform analytical calculations (when possible) A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with Analytical or Experimental Results A.2.3 Compare results with Acceptance Criteria A.2.4 Determine Uncertainties A.2.5 Establish "Design by Experiment" Needs A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results on Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database Expand All

  19. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Modeling & Computations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.7 Justify3-D Models used for Geometry and Loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with Analytical or Experimental Results A.2.3 Compare results with Acceptance Criteria A.2.2.1 Identify and classify stresses (primary, secondary, bending, membrane, etc.) A.2.2.2 Determine stress and/or strain concentration factors A.2.2.3 Compare with SDC-IC design rules (stresses, strains, deformations, damage fractions, etc.) A.2.4 Determine Uncertainties A.2.5 Establish "Design by Experiment" Needs A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results on Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database Expand All

  20. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Modeling & Computations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.7 Justify3-D Models used for Geometry and Loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with Analytical or Experimental Results A.2.3 Compare results with Acceptance Criteria A.2.4 Determine Uncertainties A.2.5 Establish "Design by Experiment" Needs A.2.4.1 Unacceptable uncertainties A.2.4.2 Non-justifiable simplifications A.2.4.3 Insufficient material property data or models A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results on Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database Expand All

  21. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main A.1.6 Assess Analysis Requirements A.1.6.1 Model A.1.6.1.1 Component/design geometry details A.1.6.1.2 Interface information A.1.6.1.3 Boundary conditions A.1.6.1.4 Loads A.1.6.1.5 Loading History A.1.6.1.6 Explanatory Diagrams A.1.6.1.7 CAD model transferability A.1.6.2 Material Property Data and Models A.1.6.2.1 Property data A.1.6.2.2 Property models (constitutive eqs., damage functions) A.1.7 Justify 3-D models used for geometry and loadings A.1.8 Develop 3-D Geometry Models A.1.8.1 Import or create 3-D models A.1.8.2 Justify 3-D model simplifications (if any) A.1.8.3 Justify loading model A.1.9 Perform Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.1.9.1 FEM: A.1.9.1.1 Establish computational needs A.1.9.1.2 Upload and run FEM A.1.9.1.3 Archive model, loading, and results A.1.9.2 Perform analytical calculations (when possible) A.2 Analysis of Results A.2.1 Assessment of Validity of Results A.2.2 Compare with analytical or experimental results A.2.3 Compare results with acceptance criteria: A.2.2.1 Identify and classify stresses (primary, secondary, bending, membrane, etc.) A.2.2.2 Determine stress and/or strain concentration factors A.2.2.3 Compare with SDC-IC design rules (stresses, strains, deformations, damage fractions, etc.) A.2.4 Determine uncertainties A.2.5 Establish need for "design by experiment" (too complex for SFA alone): A.2.4.1 Unacceptable uncertainties A.2.4.2 Non-justifiable simplifications A.2.4.3 Insufficient material property data or models A.3 Reporting Results A.3.1 Report and Archive Results on Analysis Database A.3.2 Write and Archive Results Summary Report on Analysis Database TASK-A: Structural and Failure Analysis A.1 Structural & Failure Analysis Calculations A.1.1 Establish Analysis Category A.1.1.1 Thermal A.1.1.2 Mechanical A.1.1.3 Thermo-Mechanical A.1.1.4 Multiphysics A.1.2 Establish Component-Type Analysis A.1.2.1 Global SFA (entire components) A.1.2.2 Local or Substructure Analysis A.1.2.3 TBM Structural Component A.1.2.4 Breeder A.1.2.5 Structure-Breeder Interaction A.1.2.6 TBM Support Structure A.1.2.7 Piping A.1.2.8 Solid Joints (HIP, welds, brazes, coatings) A.1.2.9 Frictional Joints (flanges, bolts, fittings) A.1.2.10 Flexible Joint A.1.2.11 Cooling Manifolds A.1.2.12 Other: Keys, Gaskets, etc. A.1.3 Establish Event Category A.1.3.1 Normal Operation A.1.3.2 Off-Normal Operation A.1.3.3 Transients A.1.3.4 Cyclic A.1.3.5 Creep A.1.3.6 Disruption A.1.3.7 Start-Up A.1.3.8 Shut-Down A.1.4 Determine Analysis Type (mechanical only) A.1.4.1 Elastic A.1.4.2 Inelastic A.1.4.2.1 Load Limit & Elastic-Perfectly Plastic A.1.4.2.2 Elastic-Plastic A.1.4.3 Buckling A.1.4.4 Modal A.1.5 Establish Service Requirements (allowable damage limits) A.1.5.1 Operational A.1.5.2 Likely A.1.5.3 Unlikely A.1.5.4 Extremely Unlikely Event

  22. Structural and Failure Analysis Scope & Tasks

  23. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-B: Design Evaluation B.1 Design Engineering and Analysis B.1.1 Receive, Approve, Archive SFA Work Order Request (SFA-WO) B.1.2 Record Design Feature Details (thickness, fillets, rounds, chamfers, welds, brazes, etc.) on Analysis Database B.1.3 Determine Design Tolerances B.1.4 Identify Material Choices B.1.5 Identify Loads and Load Histories B.1.6 Establish Event Category B.1.7 Complete SFA-WOR B.1.6 Archive B1.1.1 - B1.1.7 in Analysis Database B.2 Archiving Results B.2.1 Channel SFA Result Report to Design Team B.2.2 Report Key SFA Findings to Design Team B.2.3 Archive Design Team Response to SFA Results B.2.4 Establish further Need for SFA B.2.5 Archive Future Action on Analysis Database

  24. Structural and Failure Analysis Scope & Tasks

  25. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-C: Fabrication Engineering C.1 Interfacing with Fabrication Engineering Team C.1.1 Establish Component Fabrication Methods in Analysis Database C.1.1.1 Forming and Shaping Procedures C.1.1.2 Joining C.1.1.2.1 HIP C.1.1.2.2 Weld C.1.1.2.3 Braze C.1.1.2.4 Bolt C.1.1.2.5 Coating C.1.2 Submit Fabrication Team with Needed Material Property Data C.1.2.1 Physical C.1.2.2 Thermal C.1.2.3 Mechanical C.1.2.3.1 Fracture C.1.2.3.2 DBTT C.1.2.3.3 Creep C.1.2.3.4 Fatigue C.1.2.3.5 Irradiation C.1.2.4 Microstructure C.1.2.4.1 Grain Structure C.1.2.4.2 Defect, bubble, density C.2 Integration of Fabrication Engr. Response C.2.1 Acquire and Archive Fabrication Procedures C.2.2 Archive Material Data and Material Models in Analysis Database C.3 Integration with SFA Calculation Team C.3.1 Inform SFA Team of Fabrication Procedures C.3.2 Request SFA Team to analyze and comment on Fabrication Impact on analysis results (e.g., residual stresses) C.3.3 Archive Response from SFA Team on Fabrication Impact on Analysis C.4 Request for "Design by Experiment" (DBE) C.4.1 Identify Need for DBE (mission critical component; inconclusive SFA results, analysis too comples for SFA alone) C.4.2 Report Requirements/Conditions for DBE to Fabrication Team

  26. Structural and Failure AnalysisScope and Tasks

  27. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-D: Operation D.1 Detailing Operational Conditions and Analysis Requirements D.1.2 Acquire Detailed Operating Conditions of Component from TBM Team D.1.3 Record Details of the Event Category D.1.4 Identify Material Property Data and Modeling Sufficiency for SFA D.1.5 Report to Materials Development and Fabrication Teams any needed Material Property Data D.1.6 Report to Materials Modeling Team any needed Property Models (constitutive eqs., damage functions) D.1.7 Identify Design Rules and Codes (SDC-IC) Sufficiency D.1.8 Archive D.12 - D.1.7 in Analysis Database D.2 Integration with SFA Calculation Team D.2.1 Channel Operational Conditions to SFA Calculation Team D.2.2 Supply SFA Team with Material Property and Model Data D.2.3 Inform SFA Team of ITER Design Rules to be used (SDC-IC) D.3 Archiving SFA Operational Damage Response D.3.1 Archive Response from SFA Team on Impact of Operational Condition on Analysis

  28. Structural and Failure AnalysisScope and Tasks

  29. WORK BREADKDOWN SCHEDULE Back to main TASK-E: Integration of SFA Activities E.1 Organizational E.1.1 Establish SFA Task Force E.1.2 Develop and maintain "SFA-Database" - Intranet Web-Site for Maintaining Rolling Records of SFA Activities E.1.3 Establish Guidelines and Procedures for SFA Calculations E.1.4 Establish Protocols for Interaction with Design Team Members E.1.5 Establish Protocol for Interaction with Fabrication Team Members E.1.6 Establish Guidelines and Protocols for SFA Results Reporting E.1.7 Develop Templates and Forms E.1.7.1 Request for Work Order E.1.7.2 Request for Material Property Data E.1.7.3 Request for Material Property Models E.1.7.4 Request for "Design by Experiment" E.1.8 Channeling and assignment of tasks to SFA members E.2 Material Properties Tracking E.2.1 Submit Request for tailoring and expanding US-Fusion Materials Database for SFA Needs (add Breeder Materials, SiC, Cu, Be, W: as needed) E.2.2 Augment US-Fusion Materials Database with Material Property Models E.2.3 Augment US-Fusion Materials Database with Material Property Data from Fabrication Activities

  30. Structural and Failure AnalysisScope and Tasks

  31. Topics • Objectives • Interdependencies • Scope and Tasks • WBS Strawman • Task Force Skeleton • Preliminary Cost Estimates

  32. Structural and Failure Analysis Task Force Universities: • UCLA (Sharafat, Ghoniem, …) • UW-Madison (Blanchard) • UCSB (Odette) • Other (TBD) National Labs: • ORNL (McGreevy, Zinkle, …) • ANL (Majumdar?) • SNL (Ulrickson?) • INL (?) • Other (TBD) Industries: • Nuclear Power Industries • Steel Industry • Other (TBD)

  33. Topics • Objectives • Interdependencies • Scope and Tasks • WBS Strawman • Task Force Skeleton • Preliminary Cost Estimates

  34. DCLL-TBM SFA Annual Full Time Employee (FTE) • Preliminary Design Stage (2006 - 2009): • Universities ~ 1.5 FTE • National Labs ~ 1 FTE • Industry ~ 0.5 FTE • Design Stage (2009 – 2012½): • Universities ~ 1.5 FTE • National Labs ~ 1.5 FTE • Industry ~ 1.0 FTE • Design and Fabrication (2012½ – 2014): - Universities ~ 1 FTE - National Labs ~ 0.5 FTE - Industry ~ 0.5 FTE

  35. Preliminary SFA Task Force Cost Estimates

More Related