1 / 18

Why Theory Matters

Jackie Green. Why Theory Matters. “There is nothing so practical as a good theory.” (Kurt Lewin). Concerns. Seen by some as Reductionist Incompatible with holism and empowerment Inconsistent with respect for human agency and voluntarism. Theory practice gap.

xenia
Download Presentation

Why Theory Matters

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Jackie Green Why Theory Matters “There is nothing so practical as a good theory.” (Kurt Lewin)

  2. Concerns Seen by some as • Reductionist • Incompatible with holism and empowerment • Inconsistent with respect for human agency and voluntarism

  3. Theory practice gap Attributed to a narrow view of theory – linked to natural sciences and positivism and attempts to offer universal explanations (Buchanan, 1994)

  4. But ……… • A broader view of theory can and should: • Enhance understanding of complex situations • Consider the influence of contextual factors • Include the experience of practitioners and communities

  5. Evidence based practice • Empirical evidence necessary but not enough. • Need to extract THEORETICAL PRINCIPLES to avoid drowning in a mass of information

  6. Definitions • Theories – offer explanations of how or why something happens by identifying key variables and establishing the relationship between them • Concepts are the main elements of theories • Constructs operationalise concepts for use in building theory • Models provide a looser, possibly untested, framework to help understand reality and the relationship between concepts. They may draw on one or more theories.

  7. Two broad types of theory • Explanatory theory theory of the problem – identifies key variables which need to be addressed • Change theory theory of the solution – identifies the best means of changing key variables

  8. Theory can …… • Ensure that all relevant variable are addressed and key elements of a programme are in place • Take account of contextual factors It therefore avoids • Type III error – an intervention failing to achieve successful results when it was so poorly designed that it could not possibly have had the desired effect (Basch and Gold, 1986: 300-1)

  9. Like an expert chef, a theoretically grounded health education professional does not blindly follow a cookbook recipe, but constantly recreates it anew, depending on the circumstances. Without a theory, she or he has only the skills of a cafeteria line worker. (National Cancer Institute, 1997)

  10. Ecological approach – levels of influence • Intra-personal • Interpersonal • Institutional or organisational • Community • Public policy (National Cancer Institute, 2005)

  11. Examples of relevant theory Health Belief Model Stages of Change Theory of Planned Behaviour Health Action Model • Intrapersonal • Interpersonal • Community Social Cognitive Theory Community organisation e.g. Locality (Community) Development Social Planning, Social Action Diffusion of innovations Communication Theory (based on National Cancer Institute, 2005)

  12. The challenge …… • Not an absence of theory but • Which theory to select from the plethora available or rather • Which combination of theories to cope with the complexity of health issues • How to select theory

  13. Which theory • Does it include all relevant variables? • Does it not contain redundant variables? • Does it logically make sense to use it in a particular situation? • Has it been used by others for similar purposes? • Are there published studies supporting its use for similar purposes? • Is it consistent with the values integral to the work? (Tones and Green (2004)

  14. behavioural intention self personality belief motivation normative The Health Action Model HAM ROUTINE Environment Physical Socio-economic Socio-cultural HEALTH ACTION Skills Psycho-motor Social interaction Self-regulatory relapse confirmation Knowledge

  15. Community organisation • Community capacity • Social capital • Participation • Control and Empowerment • Critical consciousness • Awareness • Motivation

  16. Diffusion of Innovations • The characteristics of the innovation • relative advantage • compatibility - with values, previous experience and current needs • complexity • trialability • observability • Communication channels • Time • The social system

  17. Analysing the determinants of health issues Understanding what needs to be changed THEORY Identifying what needs to be done Programme planning and development SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS Outcomes: short, medium and long term Predicting likely effects Establishing how to assess effects Selection of process and outcome indicators • Contextual factors • Community insights • Practitioner insights Evaluation

  18. References • Basch, C.E. and Gold, R.S. (1986) ‘Type V errors in hypothesis testing’, Health Education Research, 1(4): 299-305 • Buchanan (1994) ‘Reflections on the relationship between theory and practice’, Health Education Research, 9(3): 273-283 • Green, J. (2000) ‘The role of theory in evidence-based health promotion practice’, Health Education Research, 15(2): 125-129 • National Cancer Institute (2005) Theory at a Glance: a Guide for Health Promotion Practice (2nd edition) (Website: http://www.cancer.gov/PDF/481f5d53-63df-41bc-bfaf-5aa48ee1da4d/TAAG3.pdf) • Nutbeam, D. and Harris, E. (2004) Theory in a Nutshell. Sydney: McGraw-Hill • Tones, K. and Green, J. (2004) Health Promotion Planning and Strategies. London: Sage

More Related