1 / 23

Is There Such a Thing as “Evidence-based Management”?

Is There Such a Thing as “Evidence-based Management”?. Denise M. Rousseau President, Academy of Management Heinz School of Public Policy & Management and Tepper School of Business Carnegie Mellon University. A blue collar child’s view: Managers are villains.

wells
Download Presentation

Is There Such a Thing as “Evidence-based Management”?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Is There Such a Thing as “Evidence-based Management”? Denise M. Rousseau President, Academy of Management Heinz School of Public Policy & Management and Tepper School of Business Carnegie Mellon University

  2. A blue collar child’s view: Managers are villains

  3. Three Things I Learned in Business School as a Professor • Many MBAs never had a ‘great boss’ but hoped for better (and to become one) • Never worked for a great company (a reason for going to B-School), but wanted to (or to start one) • Looked for ways make a business case for organizations that were good for people too

  4. The Great Hope • Through research and education . . . • Managers will make less arbitrary and more reflective decisions • Managers can better fulfill the aspirations they have for themselves (“their better nature”) • The Great Disappointment . . . • Research-based learning doesn’t transfer well to their workplaces • Managers rely on personal experience with no real evidence whatsoever (“shoot from the hip”) or • Managers follow bad advice on weak evidence > 35,000 business books in English (source: Pfeffer and Sutton, in press, “what’s new isn’t necessarily true)

  5. The “Evidence-based Movement” Zeitgeist • E-B Policing (Treating criminal suspects politely lowers repeat offenses) • E-B Education (In secondary schools, social promotion’s benefits outweigh its costs) • E-B Medicine (Caregiver hand washing reduces infections. Extensive infrastructures in many nations promote evidence-based healthcare, e.g. in US National Institute of Health, Institute of Medicine, etc.) • E-B Practice is paradigm for making decisions that mobilizes cause-effect knowledge to guide practice toward more desirable results.

  6. Why Evidence-based Management Matters • RESULTS--Informed decisions, better outcomes • IMPROVED INFORMATION--Create demand for better quality information—continue trends QWL introduced 30+ years ago • BETTER IMPLEMENTATION—NIH moratorium • COMPETENCE: More systematic and valid managerial learning over time—learning to learn • ORGANIZATIONAL LEGITIMACY--Basis for a “trustworthy” culture where information is systematically gathered, shared and evaluated (e.g., Open-Book Management)

  7. What Evidence-based Management Is (Denise’s view) • Learning about cause-effect connections in professional practices (Goal setting & Cognitive Capacity) • Isolate the variations that measurably affect desired outcomes (Number of goals can matter) • Culture of evidence-based decision making (Big “E” & little “e”) • Building decision supports to promote practices that the evidence supports (e.g., checklist: #, specificity, timeframe of goals) • Community information sharing to reduce over-use, under-use and mis-use of organizational & managerial practices

  8. Links Between Management Practices and Research? • Unexplained wide variations in managerial practice patterns (e.g., goal setting, feedback) • Poor uptake of management practices of known effectiveness (e.g., developmental goal setting) • Persistent use of practices (e.g., downsizing, punishment) known to be ineffective • The result is a Research-Practice Gap • Little EVIDENCE-BASED Management

  9. Research-Practice Gapis Familiar in Medicine • Germ theory of disease is well-accepted and understood (Simmelweiss in 1860s) • Yet observation in hospitals indicates that hand washing occurs <33% of time needed to control infections • Knowledge is not enough (Solution-focus is also needed: feedback, environmental facilitators of hand washing such as sinks in room, hand sanitizers carried in caregiver’s pocket)

  10. Why This Gap among Managers? • Manager’s don’t know the evidence • < 1% of HR managers read academic literature regularly-- in contrast to marketing (Rynes et al.) • Fear loss of control (recall Scientific Management’s greatest resistance was from supervisors/managers) • Few organizations do their own managerial research NONETHELESS: Some countries like Singapore and Finland promote management research and its dissemination

  11. …Why the gap? • Management is not a “profession” • Instead, managers have diverse disciplinary backgrounds • No formal body of shared knowledge • No shared language or terminology • Personal experience dominates how managers approach their jobs • Managerial decisions often involve others and many require compromise, politics, and responses to contradictory incentives

  12. ….Why the gap? • Little appreciation for scientific method • Uniqueness paradox interferes with transfer of research findings between settings • No good access to management research— • We do not have bibliographic services to index and make research available to managers (e.g. in medicine, Medline/Cochran Collaboration)

  13. One Other BIG Reason for Lack of Evidence-Based Management… • We typically don’t educate managers (e.g., UG, MBA, Execs) to read the research literature or use evidence. • My biggest surprise as AOM President (and most frequent email topic from members)….. • AOM member/educators say our journals aren’t useful

  14. Evidence-based Mgt & Teaching • Weak Research-Education connection (Herzberg lives! But perhaps not Weber.) • Student expectations drive course content (don’t know—yet—that E-B mgt exists and works) • Dearth of models for how real managers use research evidence or systematically gather data. (Check the cases) • The expectations students leave with upon graduation (Do they know the evidence-based is growing? Do they know how to tap into it? )

  15. Creating E-B Managers Starts with Educators • WHAT CAN WE DO TO PROMOTE EVIDENCE-MANAGEMENT THROUGH OUR TEACHING?

  16. Creating E-B Managers Starts with Educators • Manage student expectations! (Learning Contract with an Ever-Increasing E-B) • Encouraging student awareness, appreciation and active use of evidence: Identifying where to look for research evidence; Understanding underlying principles, Practicing applying them. We give them “Evidence” (lecture/textbook), but they don’t OWN it. Telling them may not be enough. Students must actively acquire evidence, use it where possible, and reflect—and try again.

  17. Creating E-B Managers Starts with Educators • Modeling E-B practice in our teaching: Use psychological research on learning to guide course/curriculum practices: • Model expert level of behavior: Identify novice-to-expert pathway • Develop skill and competence through practice (e.g. projects) • Evaluate skills, student learning over time. Redesign course PRN

  18. Need to Change Management Attitudes and Behavior • Regarding Business Knowledge • Champions • Networks • Access • Partnerships • Meta-skills: turning evidence to action

  19. A member of the rare evidence-based manager species “De Scientia Procurator"

  20. Cochran Collaborative:A Healthcare Example Mgt Can Emulate? Worldwide community devoted to promoting access to evidence-based healthcare Members collaborate to summarize state of the art knowledge on specific practices identified as important and under/over/mis-used Face-to-face meetings promote community building, commitment, and learning Free on-line access to information, designed for ease and speed of use (How about a Mgtline?)

  21. Encore: Why Evidence-based Management Matters • Better outcomes, improved implementation [Those who use evidence (E & e) and learn to use it well have comparative advantage] • Managers and Educators (and Researchers?) learn more systematically throughout their careers • Researchers/Educators/Practitioners become part of a lively community with many feedback loops where information is systematically gathered, evaluated, disseminated, implemented, evaluated, and shared

More Related