slide1
Download
Skip this Video
Download Presentation
Karin Neergaard, David Scotney, Ilse Vleugels & Carina Aschan

Loading in 2 Seconds...

play fullscreen
1 / 37

Karin Neergaard, David Scotney, Ilse Vleugels & Carina Aschan - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 66 Views
  • Uploaded on

Workshop D2 Improving a city’s sustainable transport policies by benchmarking and quality management. Karin Neergaard, David Scotney, Ilse Vleugels & Carina Aschan. Programme. Introduction Schemes for reviewing city performance Max Q – the swedish experience Break-out Groups

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'Karin Neergaard, David Scotney, Ilse Vleugels & Carina Aschan' - vinson


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
slide1

Workshop D2Improving a city’s sustainable transport policies by benchmarking and quality management

Karin Neergaard,

David Scotney, Ilse Vleugels & Carina Aschan

programme
Programme
  • Introduction
  • Schemes for reviewing city performance
  • Max Q – the swedish experience
  • Break-out Groups
  • Feedback from Groups
  • Open floor
  • Conclusion
programme1
Programme
  • Introduction
  • Schemes for reviewing city performance
  • Max Q – the swedish experience
  • Break-out Groups
  • Feedback from Groups
  • Open floor
  • Conclusion
introduction what
Introduction – what?
  • The mobility challenge for cities –
    • increasing traffic, chronic congestion, air and noise pollution, increased traffic accidents
    • against a background of global warming and the need to reduce carbon consumption
  • Need to alter the balance of priorities from motorised vehicles to more sustainable and active modes
  • .......The EcoMobility SHIFT project is establishing a process –
    • to help cities to put a process in place to make the change
    • to measure the effectiveness of the change
    • to compare their achievements with other cities

..........which will raise the international status of successful cities!

introduction who
Introduction – who?
  • An activity of the Global Alliance for EcoMobility
  • Co-funded by the European Agency for Competitiveness and Innovation (EACI) - part of its Intelligent Energy Europe (IEE) program
  • Taken forward by eight partners: ICLEI - Local Governments for Sustainability, Edinburgh Napier University, Mobiel 21, Traject, Trivector Traffic, I-CE – Interface for Cycling Expertise, Municipality of Burgas and Municipality of Miskolc
programme2
Programme
  • Introduction
  • Schemes for reviewing city performance
  • Max Q – the swedish experience
  • Break-out Groups
  • Feedback from Groups
  • Open floor
  • Conclusion
prerequisites for the scheme
Prerequisites for the scheme?
  • A widely recognized & highly valued Ecomobility label for urban areas
  • A user friendly Quality Management Scheme for mobility departments in local authorities so that they can understand where/why they are performing well and how they can improve
  • So, the scheme should ideally:
    • Cover process, outputs and outcomes
    • Be dynamic (change related) & static (measuring achievements)
    • Allow for comparison/benchmarking
    • Award labels to recognise achievements in process, outputs and/or outcomes
does this scheme already exist
Does this scheme already exist?
  • Desktop review of about 25 schemes
  • Focus on different aspects, e.g. use of indicators, functioning of QMS, labelling mechanisms, audit procedures, popularity
  • Look at transport sector and beyond
  • Expert interviews

Inspiring list for SHIFT scheme ..

slide13
Traffic safety audit
  • Process:
  • Standard questionnaire on efforts & standards in place
  • Analysis of quantitative data (accident statistics)
  • 36 indicators in 7 categories
  • Site visitwithindividual interviews
  • Lead byexternal consultant
existing schemes
Existing schemes.................
  • Review report available from http://www.ecomobility.org/shift/achievements/
programme3
Programme
  • Introduction
  • Schemes for reviewing city performance
  • Max Q – the swedish experience
  • Break-out Groups
  • Feedback from Groups
  • Open floor
  • Conclusion
max q the swedish experience

Max Q – the swedish experience

Karin Neergaard, Trivector Traffic

Carina Aschan, Sustainable Travel Umeå Region

lund test audit 2009 region of ume 2010 2011 varberg 2010 helsingborg 2011
Umeå

Lund, ”test- audit”, 2009

Region of Umeå, 2010 & 2011

Varberg, 2010

Helsingborg, 2011

Varberg

Helsingborg

Lund

slide18
MaxQ
  • 4 components
  • 12 elements (5-7 elements per component)
  • For each element: up to 10 questions
the region of ume
The region of Umeå

Evaluation of the

MM effects:

Evaluation of the

MM process:

MaxQ

  • SUMO/MaxSumo
the maxq process in ume
The MaxQ-process in Umeå

Kick-Off Meeting (Trivector & MM team Umeå)

MaxQ-questionnaire (MM-team answers individually)

Trivector analyze questionnaire and documents and prepare meeting

Consensus meeting

Interviews with partners (the region, the county council, swedish road and rail administration, the municipalities, the traffic operator)

Preliminary report to the MM-team

Presentation of the result (MM-team and partners)

Final report on Max Q-result (and in this case SUMO-results)

maxq result
Overview (see chart)

Identification of strengths and weaknesses

Improvement suggestions

MaxQ result
slide23
Ladder of development (scale 0-5)

5. Total Quality Management Continuous improvements; innovation; good results

4. Chain-oriented policy:Systematicanalysis and evaluation of the MM work; long term commitments

  • System-oriented policy:
  • Same as level 2, but including policy, routines and organisation
  • Process-oriented policy:
  • Someknowledgeaboutpre-conditions and needs. Singlemeasures.
  • Activity-oriented policy:
  • Ad hoc, short term approach

0. No MM work at all

the sumo evaluation region of ume
Performed activities

Knowledge & spread

Use – participants in activities

Usersatisfaction

Behavioural changes

CO2-effects

The SUMO-evaluation (region of Umeå)
what did maxq produce in the region of ume
What did MaxQ produce? (in the region of Umeå)
  • The MM-team were amazed how the set of questions could identify their work and the strengths and weaknesses so precisely
  • All (MM-team and partners) were strengthened by to see the final results, new energy!
  • Telephone interviews with partners created immediate action by those who were interviewed...
  • Improvement suggestions in the report were used as points for discussion at a steering group meeting.
  • Many of the proposals were not the MM-teams responsibility. The responsibilities for proposals were divided among the partners.
  • Many of the improvements are completed
improvement suggestions from ume

Improvement suggestions from Umeå

Suggestion: ensure that within each municipality there is a responsible organization or individual to manage the MM-issues and increase the understanding of the need for mobility management within each organization.

The call came from several directions and has become a regular item for discussion…

We do not have to ask for more involvement anymore.

Cooperation between municipalities strengthened,

More people have been involved - MM proliferation.

Suggestion: Use SUMO to support the planning of projects and for evaluation.

SUMO became an aid when it was put into a context.

Motivation to use SUMO on more activities

improvement suggestions

Improvement suggestions

Suggestion: Important to involve mobility management in key decisions affecting the travel. Seek to ensure that the intentions and goals of the business plan are integrated with other municipal programs and plans.A call to all to work with mobility management

MM – team are invited to strategic meetings, to projects in the planning stage

Mobility management is on the agenda and the need for our knowledge has increased.

Suggestion: discuss the importance of long term funding for the mobility management office.

The evaluation report was an important subject when the decision was taken for continued funding of the MM-office.

Our, and other new, projects got a different and improved organization.

programme4
Programme
  • Introduction
  • Schemes for reviewing city performance
  • Max Q – the swedish experience
  • Break-out Groups
  • Feedback from Groups
  • Open floor
  • Conclusion
break out groups
Break-out Groups
  • How can the effectiveness of a city’s mobility policies be identified and measured? – IlseVleugels
  • What is an EcoMobile City? - Karin Neergaard
  • Why should a city want to get an EcoMobility label and what should it look like? – David Scotney

Please return for Feedback at 16.30!

programme5
Programme
  • Introduction
  • Schemes for reviewing city performance
  • Max Q – the swedish experience
  • Break-out Groups
  • Feedback from Groups
  • Open floor
  • Conclusion
feedback from groups
Feedback from Groups
  • The effectiveness of a city’s mobility policies can be identified and measured by.............
  • An EcoMobile City is .............
  • A city would want to get an EcoMobility label, looking like........., because..............
programme6
Programme
  • Introduction
  • Schemes for reviewing city performance
  • Max Q – the swedish experience
  • Break-out Groups
  • Feedback from Groups
  • Open floor
  • Conclusion
open floor
Open floor
  • Any additional thoughts..............................
programme7
Programme
  • Introduction
  • Schemes for reviewing city performance
  • Max Q – the swedish experience
  • Break-out Groups
  • Feedback from Groups
  • Open floor
  • Conclusion
conclusion
Conclusion
  • With the completion of the development stage of the project in Spring 2013, EcoMobility SHIFT will then be available to assist you in taking forward your city into the future.
slide37

Workshop D2Improving a city’s sustainable transport policies by benchmarking and quality management

Karin Neergaard,

David Scotney, Ilse Vleugels & Carina Aschan

Thank you!

ad