1 / 17

Federal Health Care Reform: Sink or Swim? Will There be a Public Plan?

Federal Health Care Reform: Sink or Swim? Will There be a Public Plan? Will Employers Pay for Reform? How Will the HR Role Change? This just in …. Political Update: Congress:. House compromise bill announced last week of October

tulia
Download Presentation

Federal Health Care Reform: Sink or Swim? Will There be a Public Plan?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Federal Health Care Reform: Sink or Swim? Will There be a Public Plan? Will Employers Pay for Reform? How Will the HR Role Change? This just in …

  2. Political Update: Congress: • House compromise bill announced last week of October • $894 B score from CBO; rumors that re-score will exceed $1.2 T; includes strong public option; • Pelosi promises floor debate beginning Nov 5; • Senate compromise bill announced last week of October • surprisingly contained “opt out” version of Public Plan even though Senate Finance Plan did not have one; • floor debate likely to begin around mid-November; • Democratic leadership wants bill finalized by end of 2009; Senate calendar constraints make Feb more realistic… • President: • Caucus control • Coalition bolstering • Making the case to his base – needs SOMETHING to pass! 2

  3. Major issues of debate • Public Plan v Cooperatives • Taxing high-income people to fund subsidies vs taxing high-cost health plans • National Exchange vs state-run or regional • Employer mandate • Timing and enforcement of individual mandate • Individual subsidy levels • Medicaid eligibility increase (Fed v state responsibility) • Subsidy eligibility levels • System reforms for sustainability 3

  4. Key Differences: House and Senate Compromise Bills • Public Plan • House: Starts in 2013; no opt out; offered through the new “exchange,” based on negotiated payment rates; includes death panels & abortion; Medicare providers presumed in unless they opt out. • Senate: Included with “opt out” provision for states. • Guaranteed issue • House: Begins in 2013; includes guaranteed renewal; no pre-x. • Senate: Begins in 2013 with yearly open enrollment (first O.E. in Fall of 2012); includes renewal; no pre-x. 4

  5. Key Differences: House and Senate Compromise Bills Mandate on individuals House: Starts in 2013; 2.5 % tax imposed on modified adjusted gross income; exempts those with hardship. Senate: Penalty from $200-750 per adult phased in 2014-2017; exempts who cannot afford ins, households with less than 133% FPL ($29,327), individuals who would pay more than 8% of income to buy cheapest plan). Mandate on employers House: Employers pay 8% tax of average wage of workforce; Exempts small employers with less than $500,000 payroll; those between $500-750,000 would pay tax between 2-6%. To comply, ERs must pay 72.5% of the premium for individ coverage & 65% of premium for family. Senate: No mandate; in 2013, employers (over 50 employees) must repay government $400 per employee for tax credits for employees. 5

  6. Key Differences: House and Senate Compromise Bills Rating reformsg reforms House: 2:1 for age, geography and family size (no gender, health) Senate : 4:1 for age; geography and family composition also allowed. Same rating rules would apply to small group, phased from 2013 to 2018 Minimum loss ratios House: 85/15; rebates required for plans who don’t qualify Senate: 85/15 Subsidies House: up to 400% FPL sliding scale; range from 1.5% max premium for those at 133% FPL to 12% for those at 400% FPL. Senate: Phased in tax credits for 134-300% FPL in 2013; 100-133% FPL in 2014; cap of 12% prem for those between 300-400% FPL; cost-sharing subsidies avail for 100-200% FPL and less out-of-pocket for less than 400%. 6

  7. Key Differences: House and Senate Compromise Bills Insurance Exchange House: Creates national exchange offering to individuals & small groups who don’t have coverage through employer or public plan 2013 open to ERs with less than 25 EEs; 2014 open to less than 50 EEs; 2015 less than 100 EEs; Health Choices Commissioner would set standards for plans, audit/sanction, enforce reforms & collect data for quality improvement, etc. Senate: States create and manage exchanges through which individuals and small groups may purchase by 2010; no price differential allowed within/outside of exchange; open to legal immigrants only; open to employers with less than 50 employees for first 5 years; states can opt to open up to 100 employees; after 2015, mandatory for employers up to 100 ee’s; states can opt out starting in 2015. 7

  8. Key Differences: House and Senate Compromise Bills Benefits (qualifying coverage) House: 4 categories, Bronze to Platinum with all products meeting a minimum standard to include ambulatory patient services, ER, hosp, maternity, newborn, mental health, substance-abuse, Rx, rehab, devices, labs, wellness/prevention and pediatric; depend covg thru age 26; rescissions only for fraud w/IR; HHS approves premium increases; pre-x “look back” ltd to 30 days and exclusions for 3 mos max; no lifetime limits. Senate: Bronze to Platinum plans covering diff shares of expenses (65-90%); additional “young invincible” basic cat plan (25 and under); basic package includes preventative & primary, MD, outpatient, ER, Hosp, day surgery, dx imaging, maternity, newborn, pediatric, medical/surgical, Rx, radiation/chemo, mental health, substance abuse. Prohibits abortion in min pkg. Current individual products grandfathered. 8

  9. Key Differences: House and Senate Compromise Bills Medicaid eligibility House: Starts 2013to 150% of FPL (States pay 10% of expansion cost) Senate: In 2014 up to 133% FPL; feds pay most costs until 2019; state option to create “basic health plan” for 133-200% FPL not eligible & no ER coverage; no federal subsidy through exchange if you qualify for Medicaid; states receive 85% of $ that would have been paid as subsidy. Funding House: Budget cuts including “doc fix,” 5.4% surtax on taxpayers over $500,000 ind/$1M joint ($460B); MA cuts ($170B); Medicare Part A hosp cuts ($141B); Medicare home health cuts ($57B); 2.5% tax on medical devices.  Senate: MA cuts ($120 bill.); assess health sector “fees” on device manufacturers, labs, drug importers, and insurance companies ($13B per yr/ $6.7 on ins plans); excise tax (40%) on plans costing more than $8000 indiv./$21,000 family applied to premiums over that threshold) 9

  10. WILL IT PASS? House Whip vote-count as of 10/29/09: 256 Member Democratic Caucus: 168 definite vote “yes” for strong public option; 20 leaning yes 12 undecided 8 leaning no 47 opposed 52 House 52 “Blue Dog” Democrats 12 support strong public option 32 oppose 8 leaning no or undecided 15 in “no” category who do not belong to the Blue Dog Coalition 10

  11. Health Care Reform-Aetna’s View Across the Issues 11

  12. Possible Reform Timeline (Senate Finance example) • Exchanges created • SHOPs created • High risk pool created • Insurance carrier “fee” begins • Co-op formation begins • State ombudsmen required • All Co-op seed money distributed • Small business tax credit begins • Sept-Nov ind. open enrollment • Small group regulatory phase-in complete • Large group “phase-in” to rating rules begins • Sm. Bus. Tax credit only available thru Exchange • Medicaid drug benefit mandatory 2011 2013 2015 • G.I. • Ind. mandate • Individual tax credits • Medicaid eligibility increase required • Reinsurance and risk adjustm’t • High-risk pool sunsets • Small-group and “grandfathered” ind. rating rules apply • Excise tax for high-cost premiums • Cafeteria plan “safe harbor” • State option to expand Medicaid 2012 • States may form cross-border compacts • “National plans” may cross state lines 2018 2014 2010

  13. State policymakers will be busy! • Medicaid program expansion • Addressing new state-level funding needs • Configuration of Exchange/Gateway • Developing reinsurance and risk adjustment function • Maximizing federal funding for quality improvement • NAIC Model Regulation development • Conforming state law to federal insurance reforms • Guaranteed issue • Rating reforms • Market conduct • Individual mandate compliance

  14. Health Care Reform – The Spending Numbers “Waste” accounted for 34% to 50% of the $2.2 trillion spent nationally on health care in 2007* Individual behaviors (e.g., preventable risk factors like smoking, obesity or non-adherence to Rx regimen) ~10% Clinical diversity ~18% (e.g., defensive medicine, uneven adoption of evidence-based medicine) Appropriate spending ~58% ~14% Operational inefficiency (e.g., underuse of HIT, lack of process coordination across system, wasteful administrative overhead) * The estimated range for waste is between 34 and 50 percent of total health spending. Source: PWC, The Factors Fueling Rising Healthcare Costs, 2008

  15. Health Care Reform – More Numbers Net Profit Margin ( Average for 2006) Industry 5.3% Top Ten Managed Care/Health Care Plans Drug Manufacturers Medical Technology Biotechnology Hospitals 24.7% 13.2% 12.8% 6.0% Source: thestreet.com ratio comparison chart for industry, March 2009

  16. March, 2009 Estimates Health Care Reform – The Uninsured Numbers Market Size: 2009 Estimates Approximate Lives in Millions U.S. Population = ~306 Million Lives Government Health Programs and the Uninsured = ~131M Total U.S. Commercial Health Care Market = ~175M Medicaid1, 30 Individual2, 18 Notes: 1 Medicaid enrollment does not reflect the growth of this market from the February, 2009 passage of SCHIP legislation, data not yet available. 2 Individual insurance market enrollment data reported from the US Census Bureau’s 2008 “Current Population Survey”, not yet been updated in 2009. Source: Inductis Analysis of 2009 Dun and Bradstreet data; Census CPS Survey, 2008; Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS); EBRI Issue Brief No. 321, September 2008; Aetna Market Insights Analyses, March 2009.

  17. Shannon Meroney (512) 731-6615 meroneys@aetna.com Updates, resources, communication tools on federal reform: www.americanhealthsolution.org http://www.aetna.com/about/america/ Studies and data supporting industry positions: www.AHIPResearch.org.  

More Related