120 likes | 138 Views
Learn about challenges in merchandise exports and production overstating economic activity in Netherlands due to globalization. Explore solutions and recommendations for accurate trade statistics and value-added production.
E N D
World Trade and World Production Mike Berends-Ballast Jan van Laaden
Problem • Merchandise export figures are only weakly linked to economic activity in the Netherlands • Merchandise production overstates economic activity in the Netherlands • Both growing problems because of globalisation
Merchandise exports - scope • Include: • Exports of domestically produced goods • Re-exports (imported goods exported after some processing) • Exclude: • Goods in transit • Quasi-transit (like re-exports but no change of ownership) • Transito trade (merchanting?)
Trade problems (1) • Export – import – re-export • Drugs in bulk from A, sent to B for packaging, imported and subsequently re-exported. • Double counting – twice in imports and twice in exports T
Trade problems (2) • Contract processing • Country A sends goods to country B for processing. Country A supervises the processing and retains ownership • The processing enterprise may be an affiliate or it may be an independent firm • Included in country A’s exports even though almost all the value added occurred abroad
Trade problems (3) • Distribution centres • Goods – e.g. cars – imported into Netherlands and owned by the distribution centre. The cars are subsequently exported to other countries • Overstatement of Netherlands exports • The car producer decides to retain ownership of the cars while in the distribution centre • The cars now become quasi-transit and should be excluded from trade statistics
Production problems • Contract processing • When country A sends goods to country B for processing, retaining control of the work and ownership of the goods, the value of the processing work appears as production in both countries • Netherlands production is 10% overstated
Recommendations • Exports • Separate re-exports and exports from domestic production • Record both total value and value added of re-exports • Record quasi-transit trade • Production • Record separately sales of goods made under contract abroad • Distinguish between intra-firm and extra-firm processing abroad
Comments • Ownership not relevant for international trade statistics (ITMS 1998). Quasi transit not a problem! • What is value-added? Increase in value or national accounts definition? • Use “net exports” for goods typically re-exported – chemicals, transport and other machinery.