1 / 9

Corporate Rehabilitation in Pakistan

Learn about Pakistan's journey towards maximising NPL recovery through the implementation of creditor-friendly laws and the establishment of a comprehensive Corporate Rehabilitation Act.

Download Presentation

Corporate Rehabilitation in Pakistan

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Corporate Rehabilitationin Pakistan Feisal Hussain Naqvi

  2. The story till last year • In order to maximise NPL recovery, Pakistani governments introduced several creditor friendly laws • First effective bank recovery law in 1997 • Revised and tightened in 2001 • New recovery law with criminal provisions (NAB) • Up to 14 years in jail • Strict liability and presumption of guilt • Fine equal to defaulted amount • No bail • Asset recovery vehicle set up (CIRC)

  3. All stick and no carrot makes Jack a dull boy • Despite all the laws, NPL increased further • NAB law failed to result in recoveries due to court decisions • CIRC turned into a (lousy) auction house • Businessmen stopped borrowing • Hence decision taken to set up a more debtor friendly insolvency regime • English, US and Indian models considered • US model adopted primarily because: • no shareholder-management divide in Pakistan • Availability of judicial precedents

  4. The CRA last year • Comprehensive law • I.e. covered both liquidation and rehabilitation • Deliberately copied large portions of the US Bankruptcy Code • Super-priority loans • Automatic stay • Government debt given same priority as unsecured debt • Compressed timelines • Included UNCITRAL model cross-border provisions • Provided support to judges through an “Advisory Committee”

  5. The CRA this year • Work on CRA slowed by transition to democracy • Upon re-examination, major changes made • No longer a comprehensive law • Mandatory mediation • Institutional capacity building • CIRC replaced with private vulture capital companies • Modified automatic stay • Automatic discharge of personal guarantors

  6. Comprehensive vs. limited law • CRA originally covered both liquidation and rehabilitation • Revised CRA only covers rehabilitation because: • Previous caselaw and legal structure is minimally disturbed • Previously almost 1/3rd of Company Law being rewritten • Entire debate about whether a particular company is “insolvent” becomes redundant • Debtors will now come into rehabilitation out of their own choice • Rehabilitation available as of right but with strong anti-fraud provisions • Failure of rehab means mandatory liquidation

  7. Mandatory Mediation • All cases will be referred to mediation upon filing • Mediator must be qualified to serve as an administrator • Aim is to familiarise parties with new law, their rights and probable range of outcomes • Timelines not affected by mediation • Plan deadline can be extended only by mutual consent • Debate now over timing of mediation • I.e. whether mediation should be prior to – or after – advisory committee report • General practice is to have mediation before court takes cognizance of matter

  8. Institutional Capacity Building • Self-evident fact that Pakistan lacks qualified personnel • Problem exacerbated by complexity of law • Solution is to set up specific independent body – Institute of Administrators • Institute will train, regulate and license mediators, administrators and liquidators • Institute will also arrange specialised training for judges • Idea is to build a pool of qualified personnel who can serve system in all capacities

  9. Other changes • CIRC replaced with enabling provision for “vulture capital” companies • Modified Automatic Stay • Unlike US version, stay will expire after four months • But, stay will remain valid against execution proceedings • Again, idea is to increase pressure on debtors Automatic Discharge of Guarantors • Under US law, personal guarantors are not discharged by insolvency of principal • But, if same rule was applied in Pakistan, would remove incentive for rehabilitation • Under SBP regulations, all directors and major shareholders must give personal guarantees

More Related