Decision relevant climate change impact assessments using weap21
Download
1 / 37

Decision Relevant Climate Change Impact Assessments using WEAP21 - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 96 Views
  • Uploaded on

Decision Relevant Climate Change Impact Assessments using WEAP21. Stockholm Environment Institute-Boston Center National Center for Atmospheric Research Natural Heritage Institute with support from: U.S. EPA, Office of Research and Development.

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'Decision Relevant Climate Change Impact Assessments using WEAP21' - sybil


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Decision relevant climate change impact assessments using weap21

Decision Relevant Climate Change Impact Assessments using WEAP21

Stockholm Environment Institute-Boston Center

National Center for Atmospheric Research

Natural Heritage Institute

with support from:

U.S. EPA, Office of Research and Development


Let’s start with a quick introduction to the original version of WEAP, and most other water resource management simulation models for the matter.


A simple system
A Simple System version of WEAP, and most other water resource management simulation models for the matter.


What are we assuming
What are we assuming? version of WEAP, and most other water resource management simulation models for the matter.

  • That we know how much water is flowing at the top of each river.

  • That we know how much water is flowing into or out of the river as it moves downstream.

  • That we know what the water demands are with certainty.


What are we assuming1
What are we assuming? version of WEAP, and most other water resource management simulation models for the matter.

  • That we know how much water is flowing at the top of each river.

  • That we know how much water is flowing into or out of the river as it moves downstream.

  • That we know what the water demands are with certainty.

  • Basicly, that this system has been removed from it HYDROLOGIC context.


What do we do now
What do we do now? version of WEAP, and most other water resource management simulation models for the matter.


Add hydrology
ADD HYDROLOGY! version of WEAP, and most other water resource management simulation models for the matter.


Hydrology model
Hydrology Model version of WEAP, and most other water resource management simulation models for the matter.

Critical question: How does rainfall on a catchment translate into flow in a river?

Critical question: What pathways does water follow as it moves through a catchment? Runoff? Infiltration? ET? Seepage?

Critical question: How does movement along these pathways impact the magnitude, timing, duration and frequency of river flows?


Planning model
Planning Model version of WEAP, and most other water resource management simulation models for the matter.

Critical question: How should water be allocated to various uses in time of shortage?

Critical question: How can these operations be constrained to protect the services provided by the river?

Critical question: How should infrastructure in the system (e.g. dams, diversion works, etc) be operated to achieve maximum benefit?

Critical question: How will allocation, operations and operating constraints change if new management strategies are introduced into the system?


Weap with its integrated hydrology molude provides a framework for answering both set of questions
WEAP, with its integrated Hydrology Molude, provides a framework for answering both set of questions.


WEAP Hydrology framework for answering both set of questions.


The weap 2 bucket hydrology module
The WEAP 2-Bucket Hydrology Module framework for answering both set of questions.

Surface Runoff =

f(Pe,z1,1/LAI)


One 2 bucket model per land class
One 2-Bucket Model Per Land Class framework for answering both set of questions.





Calibration and Validation representation

  • Model Evaluation (1961-1999):

  • Flows Along Mainstem and Tributaries

  • Reservoir Storage and Release

  • Trinity Diversion

  • Agricultural Water Demand

  • Groundwater Storage Trends

  • Yolo Bypass Flood Inundation

  • Sacramento River Water Temperature


Reservoir Storage representation

SHASTA



Phenologies of reproductive events in freshwater phase of Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration


River temperature model
River Temperature Model Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

  • First-order DO and temperature patterned after Chapra (1997)

  • Water quality simulated for select rivers, where tributaries, discharges, and return flows prescribed.

  • Mass balance equations for each stream segment

  • Hydrologic inflows from rivers and groundwater sources simulate the water balance and mixing of concentrations and temperature along each reach.

  • Same River network for the water resources and the water quality simulation, and assumes complete mixing.


Temp profile kms downriver of shasta dam
Temp. Profile – Kms Downriver of Shasta Dam Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration


Current decision relevant activity
Current Decision-Relevant Activity Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

  • Collaborating with PCWA and EID on the development of a WEAP21 model of the American River Watershed for exploration of potential climate change impacts.

  • Collaborating with DWR to see if the WEAP21 Framework can contribute to the “quantitative climate change assessment” envisioned for B160-2010.

  • Working with the California Climate Center on a case study for the Sacramento Valley as part of a climate change assessment report called for under Governor Schwarzenegger’s Executive Order S-3-05.


Approach
Approach Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

  • Develop refined WEAP model of the American River watershed.

  • Apply the model to understand hydropower potential of PCWA system.

  • Apply the model to understand the drought vulnerability of the EID water supply system.

  • Potentially integrated with a model of the Yuba River watershed which is managed by Nevada Irrigation District and has substantial transfers into the American River watershed.


The american river watershed in weap21
The American River Watershed in WEAP21 Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration


North fork american
North Fork American Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration


Preliminary calibration 1990 1999
Preliminary Calibration 1990 - 1999 Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration


Warmer and drier climate scenario
Warmer and Drier Climate Scenario Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration


Current decision relevant activity1
Current Decision-Relevant Activity Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

  • Collaborating with PCWA and EID on the development of a WEAP21 model of the American River Watershed for exploration of potential climate change impacts.

  • Collaborating with DWR to see if the WEAP21 Framework can contribute to the “quantitative climate change assessment” envisioned for B160-2010.

  • Working with the California Climate Center on a case study for the Sacramento Valley as part of a climate change assessment report called for under Governor Schwarzenegger’s Executive Order S-3-05.


Approach1
Approach Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

  • Train DWR staff on the use of WEAP.

  • Develop a link between Sacramento Valley application and a Delta Water Quality Model.

  • Develop a link with a future demand scenario generator developed by RAND.

  • Embed the Sacramento Valley application in a more stylized system-wide model.

  • Run a series of climate change scenarios.

  • Evaluate with DWR if the WEAP framework can be used for quantitative climate change analysis in Bulletin 160-2010.


Current decision relevant activity2
Current Decision-Relevant Activity Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

  • Collaborating with PCWA and EID on the development of a WEAP21 model of the American River Watershed for exploration of potential climate change impacts.

  • Collaborating with DWR to see if the WEAP21 Framework can contribute to the “quantitative climate change assessment” envisioned for B160-2010.

  • Working with the California Climate Center on a case study for the Sacramento Valley as part of a climate change assessment report called for under Governor Schwarzenegger’s Executive Order S-3-05.


Approach2
Approach Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

  • Disaggregate HUCs to ID level

  • Calibrate model

  • Run climate change scenarios

  • Modify assumptions (e.g. changing irrigation technology/efficiency, varying cropping patterns, conversion of farmland to urban use, etc.)

  • Re-run scenarios

  • Perform economic assessment


Spatial disaggregation
Spatial Disaggregation Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

Sacramento Valley

WEAP Model


Spatial disaggregation1
Spatial Disaggregation Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

Before

After

Stone Corral HUC


Model calibrated for stone corral
Model Calibrated for Stone Corral Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

  • Regional water consumption and delivery within Sacramento-Stone Corral HUC corresponds to historic data.

  • Irrigation district level water consumption and delivery reflects historic observations.

  • Groundwater levels follow historic trend.


Future work
Future Work Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

  • Disaggregate and calibrate Lower Butte HUC

  • Run climate change scenarios

  • Modify Assumptions (e.g. add dynamic cropping patterns)

  • Perform economic assessment


Conclusions
Conclusions Chinook salmon life-cycle in the SV watershed.□ = adult immigration; ∆ = spawning and hatching; ◊ = juvenile emigration

  • The hydrology module is a powerful tool for considering changing catchment dynamics.

  • Hydrology is essential for conducting rigorous analysis of climate change impacts.

  • Hydrology could be very interesting for sectoral economic analysis because it considers several resources in a catchment, rainfed and irrigated agriculture, forest and range management, fish appropriate flows.

  • Increasing activity is taking place with the WEAP21 Framework in California, with the real potential to influence decision-making processes.


ad