140 likes | 245 Views
Connecting to Literature. Keeping up with the Joneses Preparing the Review of Literature. Who am I? Who are you?. Researcher at a research institution. Responsibilities At the edge of what we know Engage the cutting edges of research Contribute to the flow of learning
E N D
Connecting to Literature Keeping up with the Joneses Preparing the Review of Literature
Who am I? Who are you? Researcher at a research institution Responsibilities • At the edge of what we know • Engage the cutting edges of research • Contribute to the flow of learning I live in the literature
Reading habits • Have a day you read • Monitor new research • Building your library: reading upon arrival • Setting alerts: journal, author, subject • Book reviews: Which journals? • Choosing a level: Walliman, p. 60 • Read for findings and methods • Don’t forget note cards and abstracts
In communication Walliman, pp. 51-53 • Library catalogs: Ours/Scholar/Worldcat • Journal of abstracts: No good ones; in jrnls • Index journal: No gd one • Bibliographic database: • EBSCO – Communication and Mass Media Complete • CIOS (not through our library) • InfoWorld • Comm Yearbook; Rev of Comm
Products • Bibliography: Walliman, p. 87 • For further reading • By subject • Abstracting: Walliman, p. 64 • Journal: Fixing vs. Reviewing • Great ideas folder • By subject?
Reading for the project • Getting started: • Roping • Time per source • Stranding • Backward w/ notes • Forward w/ Scholar • The ten card method
The Research Tornado Reading to find your research question • Read to understand the subject • Read critically • Read to reveal what we know now • Read toward unanswered or next question There is your research question
The Research Onion: What? • Studies answering my question • Studies contextualizing my question • Studies working w/ my concepts
The Research Onion: Who? • Has anyone done my study? • Who are my immediate interlocutors? • Who are our ancestors? • Who has ideas that might help me?
Dangers • The Ocean Problem • 3x5 paper dolls • The unmotivated report
Internet savvy • Vetted Sources • Using non-vetted sources • Wikipaedia • Know the author • Collect reliable sources
Organizing for the Review • Lumping the work • Patterns of Assembly • Serial: Concept by concept; variable by variable • Discovery Narrative • Theory Development Narrative • Outlining • I. Points are always arguments, not studies
Writing the Review • Where does it appear? • Introduction setting the problem • Separate Section culminating in RQ • Conceptualization Section • Texture of writing: Inquiry/Study • Question to Answer • Argument to Support • Lacuna to Fill
A good Rev of Lit is one that convinces your reader that: • No one has previously done what you plan to do; answered your question • You have identified the line of inquiry that will read and respond to your work • You understand the literature of your inquiry; the literature that surrounds your question. • Your study is important to the line of inquiry