1 / 11

Beck’s Cognitive Therapy

Beck’s Cognitive Therapy.

Download Presentation

Beck’s Cognitive Therapy

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.


Presentation Transcript

  1. Beck’s Cognitive Therapy • Challenge irrational cognitions and replace them with more realistic appraisals:- therapist helps the client identify negative - keep a record of thoughts and anxieties to be revised later and negative automatic thoughts recognised- therapist draws attention to positive incidences, regardless of their triviality • REALITY TESTING: comparison of the irrational and reality

  2. Behavioural techniques to encourage positive behaviour: - make a list of small goals – developing a sense of personal effectiveness- training in problem solving skills – relaxation techniques to reduce anxiety

  3. Ellis & Rational-Emotive Behavioural Therapy (REBT) • Similar to Beck’s:- therapist and client work together: identify situations and negative reactions- therapist helps rationalise situations, giving a more realistic perspective- more confrontational approach – challenges the clients beliefs in debates

  4. Evaluation of CBT (Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy) • CBT – structured approach – acknowledges complex cognitive processes are important in psychological disorders • Depression may be rational – it is necessary for the therapist to acknowledge this and not give the impression it is always unjustified • Effective for depression and social anxiety – evidence CBT lasts longer than antidepressant drugs exist • Less effective on phobias and more serious conditions e.g. schizophrenia

  5. Evaluation of CBT (Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy) • Ignores genetic and biological factors • The idea of schemata lacks detail – no clear description of mechanism for how negative schemata develop in the first place • Less time consuming & more cost effective than psychoanalytic therapies • Avoids in depth probing – unpleasant or damaging in psychoanalysis though some may find self monitoring and analysis in CBT threatening

  6. Effectiveness of Therapies Elkin et al (1989) • Several treatment centres participated • 240 patients with depression treated with CBT, psychotherapy or antidepressant drugs and placebo control group • Treatment lasted for 16 weeks

  7. Findings: • Large placebo effect (35-40%) • All therapies more effective than placebo but all therapies similar • Drugs more effective in severely depressed participants • Significant factor in effectiveness of psychotherapy is the therapist • Across all groups, 30-40% did not respond

  8. Additional: • 16 weeks too short – ideally 6-12 months • CBT in anxiety conditions are longer lasting than drugs (Bechdolf et al 2006) • No treatment is ever 100% effective

  9. Davidson et al (2004) • 295 patients with generalised social anxiety (fear of social situations) treated with either CBT, fluoxetine (antidepressant) or combined Findings: • Overall placebo effect = 19% • All therapies effective over placebo effect • At 14 weeks, no differences between therapy groups – combination wasn’t superior • 40-50% did not respond • Drugs and CBT equally effective in treating social anxiety

  10. Methodological Issues • Matched pairs for comparison • Length of study should be long enough for effects to be observed – ideally a year • Control groups:- for drugs therapy, placebo drug can be given- for psychological therapy, ‘interaction’ is used – participants talk to a therapist but no attempt to apply specific techniques are used • Measurement of improvement should be consistent and thorough across groups -questionnaires and ratings of clinical improvement (by staff who are unaware of treatment – avoids bias and investigator effects)

  11. Ethical Issues • Informed consent – people with disorders may be less able to understand full consequences of treatment • Avoid psychological harm – debrief participants • If treatment are effective, control groups are being denied help • Drugs have side-effects

More Related