1 / 10

Data Processing Procedures

Data Processing Procedures. CSTS Teleconference 23.02.2012 M. Götzelmann. Framework. Fall Meeting Approach. Data Processing Procedure PDO unconfirmed. Sequence Controlled Data Processing Procedure PDO confirmed. Buffered Data Processing Procedure PDO unconfirmed.

rosie
Download Presentation

Data Processing Procedures

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Data Processing Procedures CSTS Teleconference 23.02.2012 M. Götzelmann

  2. Framework Fall Meeting Approach Data Processing Procedure PDO unconfirmed Sequence Controlled Data Processing Procedure PDO confirmed Buffered Data Processing Procedure PDO unconfirmed Forward Synchronous Frame Processing Procedure Forward CLTU Processing Procedure Forward TC Frame Processing Procedure Specification adopted from the original DPP: Processing starts in the sequence data units are received but does not need to terminate in the same sequence Forward Space Packet Processing Procedure CSTS Teleconference - DPP

  3. Problem 1 – Reporting of Incidents 5 4 6 5 7 4 6 7 Data unit last processed Data unit last processed Data unit last OK Status: interrupted Status: completed Data unit last OK 11 6 14 10 7 9 4 13 5 8 12 Data unit last OK Data unit last processed Status: started FSP: packet-identification-list:5, 6, 8, 10, 11, 12 waiting processed completed CSTS Teleconference - DPP

  4. Option A Basic Procedures can handle everything, derived procedures constrain Framework Data Processing Procedure PDO unconfirmed Sequence Controlled Data Processing Procedure PDO confirmed Buffered Data Processing Procedure PDO unconfirmed Forward Synchronous Frame Processing Procedure Forward CLTU Processing Procedure Forward TC Frame Processing Procedure allow concurrent processing Forward Space Packet Processing Procedure strict sequential processing CSTS Teleconference - DPP

  5. Option B Basic Procedures only support sequential processing, derived procedures add concurrency Framework Data Processing Procedure PDO unconfirmed Sequence Controlled Data Processing Procedure PDO confirmed Buffered Data Processing Procedure PDO unconfirmed Forward Synchronous Frame Processing Procedure Forward CLTU Processing Procedure Forward TC Frame Processing Procedure allow concurrent processing Forward Space Packet Processing Procedure strict sequential processing CSTS Teleconference - DPP

  6. Is Option B possible? Viewpoints Data (notify Operation) Behaviour specialised basic behaviour extended behaviour general CSTS Teleconference - DPP

  7. Problem 1 - Conclusions • Constraining basic procedures to sequential processing one data unit at a time • Simplifies the specification and implementation • Can already support a wide range of applications • Derivation of procedures supporting concurrency • Is possible for data via extension parameters • Can be argued for the behaviour (although the counter argument has some validity as well) • Proposal: in the framework only support strict sequential processing CSTS Teleconference - DPP

  8. Problem 2 – Queue Overflow Reporting Policies: • Discard latest • Data unit last OK = 3 • Data unit last processed = 4? 9? • Discard latest • Data unit last OK = 3 • Data unit last processed = 4? 5? • Flush Queue • Data unit last OK = 3 • Data unit last processed = 4? 8? • Add data unit identification list? • User always in spite of overspecification? 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 CSTS Teleconference - DPP

  9. Problem 3 – Inherited Notification PDO unconfirmed Policy: undefined Notification: Queue Overflow Data Processing Procedure PDO unconfirmed Sequence Controlled Data Processing Procedure PDO confirmed Buffered Data Processing Procedure PDO unconfirmed PDO unconfirmed Policy: undefined Notification: Queue Overflow PDO confirmed Policy: always discard latest Queue overflow preventedby rejecting via negative return BUT: notification queue overflow inherited CSTS Teleconference - DPP

  10. Questions to the WG • Shall the simple DPP support concurrent processing of data units or only serialised strictly sequential processing? • Shallwe add a parameter data-unit-identification to all notifications to identify affected data units? • How shall we inform the user of what data have been discarded following a queue overflow event? • Can derived procedures simply ignore the notification type 'queue overflow' specified in the simple DDP? CSTS Teleconference - DPP

More Related