1.17k likes | 1.71k Views
Emergency Relief. Gary Van Sciver September 16, 2008 · . Gary Van Sciver. Process Engineer – 8 years Risk Analyst – 22 years ETC – 2 ½ years. Presentation Overview. Terminology (ERS). E mergency R elief S ystem. 1. Normal Vent.
E N D
Emergency Relief Gary Van Sciver September 16, 2008 ·
Gary Van Sciver Process Engineer – 8 years Risk Analyst – 22 years ETC – 2 ½ years
Terminology (ERS) Emergency Relief System
What is the difference between the normal vent & the emergency vent?
What are the differences? (between the normal & emergency vents) • No blocking devices in ERS • No flame arresters in ERS • ERS usually bigger • Normal vent also handles vacuum • Pollution abatement for normal vent • Normal vent opens first • Manifolding for normal vent .
Manifolds One pollution abatement device will normally handle the discharge of multiple vessels
Upset Scenario... Series of events leading to high vessel pressure
Concept Sciences 1999 Allentown, PA 5 fatalities hydroxylamine
Concept Sciences • The plant was designed to concentrate hydroxylamine (HA) up to 50% • HA is known to be explosive above 70% concentration • Due to startup problems, the actual concentration was 86% HA .
BP - 2005 Texas City, Texas 15 fatalities Vapor cloud explosion of hexane/heptane (44ºC) 7700 gallons released < 2 minutes from 35 m height
BP - 2005 Tower – 170 feet tall Blowdown drum – 115 feet tall
BP - 2005 Truck parked, but idling about 25 feet from blowdown drum Eyewitness saw engine over-revving and backfiring sparks
Bhopal - 1984 >2000 off-site fatalities due to toxic relief valve discharge
Bhopal1984 • Relief valve on an MIC storage tank lifted in the middle of the night releasing 80,000 lbs • >2,000 people died within a short period • ~30,000 people were permanently or totally disabled • MIC reacted with water, source of contamination uncertain • Incident had long-term ramifications for Union Carbide and the chemical industry as a whole.
Design Basis Procedure 1. Identification 2. Sizing 3. Selection
Pressurized gas addition(line blowing, pressure transfers, pads or purges)
Design Basis Procedure 1. Identification 2. Sizing
Sizing vents is straightforward but we do need kinetics data for reactive scenarios
Types of runaway reaction • Vapor Pressure • Gas Generating.
Vapor PressureRunaway Reaction • Pressure related to temperature • Control temperature by evaporative cooling.
Emulsion Runaway • 1995, one-shot emulsion process • Water charging system failed • New operator being trained, batch not stopped • 2,000-gallon, 120-psig reactor • Broke 35-psig, 18-inch rupture disk • ~1200 lbs ethyl acrylate released.
Emulsion Runaway Odor complaints 13 miles away in Karlsruhe, Germany