E N D
1. Welcome to Pritzker Summer Research Program University of Chicago
2. Objective #1: Conduct research Prepare you to conduct mentored- research projects
Mentor
Mentor’s staff and faculty collaborators
Cluster group leaders
Peers
Offer input on progress
Sounding board
3. Objective #2: Get Inspired Inspire you to want to do research
June 20th 10am
Neil Shubin, PhD
Associate Dean, Organismal Biology & Anatomy
Provost, The Field Museum
Best selling author!
4. Objective #3: The Paper Provide a framework for scientific writing
References (Deb Werner)
Introduction
Methods
5. Before you write Who are you writing for?
Goal: to identify ‘target’ journal
Readership
Impact factor
6. Next… Download instructions for authors
VERY detailed
Follow format
Word limit
Table/Figure
Reference
Subheadings
First page specify the journal format you are using
7. Can’t decide? Use JAMA original research as default
Chicago-based, high impact, general audience
Maximum word limit of 3000 words
5 Tables/Figures
Double spaced
Easy on the eyes for the reviewers (including me!)
8. This is not ‘creative writing’
9. IMRaD Unlike a novel, newspaper article or an essay…a scientific paper has a required structure and style
By international consensus "Introduction Methods Results and Discussion" or IMRaD
10. Introduction Opening line
Start broad with something that interests your audience “the hook”
But not too broad
“Sleep is a required biological function”
Could frame it as a problem with scope
“Sleep deprivation is a common problem worldwide”
Funnel method to end
with your specific aim and your hypothesis
11. Introduction Routinely 2 to 3 paragraphs
Think about the 3 main items that someone needs to know to understand your aim
Each of these items could be a separate paragraph
Create topic sentences for each paragraph carefully that introduce the next idea
Need good ‘flow’
Transition words and phrases between ideas
12. Transitions Words Similar idea
In addition
Furthermore
Moreover
also
Likewise
Similarly
As a result
For example
Opposite idea
However
Nevertheless
In contrast
Regardless
13. Strategic References Avoid “reference rehash”
“Chang et al showed X. Towle et al demonstrated Y. Alexander et al demonstrated Z.”
OK to do this for 1-2 landmark studies
Goal is to synthesize prior work
“Prior studies have showed…”
“Some studies showed that X…. In contrast, other studies showed Z.”
14. Create tension or ‘gap’ Given that other studies have taken place, why is your study needed
Highlight potential links to therapy, policy, scientific discovery
15. Pitfalls of Introduction Too long
Reference rehash or overlaod
Not making the case for the study – WHY?
Jargon or abbreviations not explained
Too broad
Poor flow
16. Methods Step by step detailed protocol
In general, 3 main paragraphs
Study Design
Data Collection
Data Analysis
17. Study Design…including Setting & Population Design
Retrospective or prospective?
RCT, pre-post, observational?
Setting: Where conducted?
Multicenter, single institution, in a lab, in the community.
Population: Who or what was studied?
People, cell lines, etc.
In enough detail so reader can assess generalizability
Often end with IRB/IACUC approval or exemption statement
18. Data Collection Step by step, how was data collected
May use sub-sub headings if many types of methods
Give examples
how a survey question was worded & scale used
Describe any products/instruments used (inc manufacturer) and units reported
Reference studies that use these methods or validate these methods
Past tense (since ideally it was done!)
19. Data Analysis Calculations used to arrive at the results
Data were analyzed using.. .
Specific tests
Qualitative or Quantitative
Any software or product used
How statistical significance was defined
Multiple comparisons may necessitate more conservative p values
20. Pitfalls of Methods No data analysis section due to a fear of statistics
Too short
Not enough detail to understand study
Assuming that others know what your method is
No mention of IRB/IACUC
No methods references
21. Conquering Fear of Statistics FIRST use your mentor and resources of your mentor’s lab, Dept, colleagues etc.
May have a statistician for the project
Or someone they curbside for stats questions
Revisit notes from Dr. Lauderdale’s class
If your mentor needs help…
biostatistics assistance available to faculty (and their students)
Save for when you need it –at critical point
Costs $$$ after 2h of use (to your mentor)
http://biotime.uchicago.edu/
23. STATA and other software During the Winter, STATA is provided FREE of charge (thanks to Dr. Lauderdale and her team!) to avoid licensing fees
licenses would expire by Summer
Your mentor is responsible for providing you with the statistical programs & resources you need to carry out research
Usually done via computer in their lab with software
24. Want STATA after hours? Visit the Library!
Beware PHI & leaving research info on the computer
Load on PERSONAL computer
26. SRP ? S&D Project?
28. Common Issues in SRP Mentor NOT available
Plan ahead
Find out who the other resources in the ‘lab’ are
Make it easy for them (phone, email, meet them in clinic)
29. Project not working? It is OK if…
Hypothesis is disproven
p value is >0.05
enrollment is low
results are slow
30. What are the hours? Expectation is to contribute full-time
Natural ebb & flow
May feel like its easy now…
“Crunch time” as final paper & presentation nears
Plan ahead
31. Too much free time? Talk to your mentor
Related project
Troubleshoot difficulty
Work ahead
Paper
Power point (Aug lecture)
32. START Program Scholars in Translational Aging Research Training Program
sponsored by the National Institutes on Aging
Hear about different research & clinical topics related to aging
Monday mornings but ends before “crunch time” (Jun 20th to Aug 1st)
Sign up sheet GOING around OR email kblythe@bsd.uchicago.edu
33. Logistics
Cluster Group
Student liaisons help arrange meeting & communicate with student
Groups named by dominant themes or leader expertise
Note down presentation date/time
Invite mentor, family & friends
Payment – increased to $5400!!
Made in 2 installments
mid & end of summer
Requires assignments completed
34. Uploading Assignments http://srp.uchicago.edu
35. SRP Questions
36. Questions?