1 / 15

Targeting Blended Returns

Targeting Blended Returns. CEI Community Ventures (CCVI) Cornell Presentation October 30 th , 2003. Agenda. About Venture Capital Practice Traditional Variations About CCVI State of the industry Blended return: practices and challenges.

pahana
Download Presentation

Targeting Blended Returns

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Targeting Blended Returns CEI Community Ventures (CCVI) Cornell Presentation October 30th, 2003 Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  2. Agenda • About Venture Capital • Practice • Traditional • Variations • About CCVI • State of the industry • Blended return: practices and challenges Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  3. Venture Capital (VC) and Private Equity (PE)The Practice • High risk investment management • Business structure: Ten (10) year limited partnerships: • Invest yrs 1-4, recapture yrs 4-8 • Raise new capital after 4-5 years—i.e. Fund I, Fund II, etc • Proposition: Trade capital for ownership in growth oriented, privately held companies • Relationship: Active partnership with management (Board of Directors) • Returns: commensurate with risk • Types: VC typically early stage, Private Equity later-stage • Process • Source: networking/marketing, direct • Analyze: management, market, bus. model, financial • Negotiate: $ for x% ownership • Govern: Board of Directors role • Sell: Sell/merge company, go public or otherwise recapture capital (with gains) Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  4. Venture Capital (VC) and Private Equity (PE)Traditional and Variations • Traditional • $30B managed by hundreds of funds • Located in major city centers (Boston, Palo Alto/SF, NY, etc) • VC focus on technology investment; PE focus on later stage, often profitable companies • Strictly financial return oriented • Variations • Community Development Venture Capital (CDVC) • Socially Responsible Venture Capital (SRVC) • Venture Philanthopy (VP) Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  5. Venture Capital (VC) and Private Equity (PE)Variations: CDVC • Focus on dual bottom line: financial and social • Financial: high relative return, lower than traditional (10-15% IRR vs. 25-35% traditional) • Social: job creation for Low and Moderate Income (LMI) populations • Industry • Origins: Grew out of lending-oriented economic development groups • Locations: Urban (inner city) and rural focus • Small, growing: 50-60 CDVCs in US managing ~$500M (vs. $30B in traditional) Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  6. Venture Capital (VC) and Private Equity (PE)Variations: SRVC • Focus on multiple bottom lines • Financial: high relative return, lower than traditional • Social: job growth (general), social equity (women, minorities), socially beneficial products/services • Environmental: products/services (e.g. alt. energy), business practices (e.g. sustainability issues) • Industry • Origins: Individuals, increasingly organized funds • Locations: varied • Small, growing: Less formally structured than CDVC Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  7. Venture Capital (VC) and Private Equity (PE)Variations: Venture Philanthropy (VP) • Use of VC practices to channel foundation/grant funds to non-profits and for-profit subsidiaries of non-profits • Charitable giving (not investment management) • VC/business practices, oversight to make giving more efficient, effective, accountable Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  8. Overlap Traditional VC VP SRVC CDVC Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  9. CEI and CCVI • CEI (Coastal Enterprise Inc): • Maine based non-profit organization started in 1977 • Focused on improving lives of people and communities, particularly those of low income through initiatives in: • Financial services: Lending, Venture Capital, Tax Credits • Social services: Affordable housing, LMI job training/placement, childcare • Consulting services: Non-profit consulting, SBDC mgt • Two for-profit venture capital funds in operation • CEI Ventures: Founded 1995, investing second fund ($20M) • CEI Community Ventures (CCVI): Founded 2001, closed $10M first fund April 2003 Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  10. Fund Profile: CCVI • Geography: 80%Maine, New Hampshire and Vermont, 20% anywhere else • Triple bottom line: Financial, Social (job creation, social equity) and Environmental • Multi-sector: technology, manufacturing, service, other • Multi-stage: early, development, later (PE) Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  11. Northeast’s only NMVC • New Markets Venture Capital (NMVC) • SBA/SBIC program providing matching capital • Equity: $10M ($5M from SBA) • Technical Assistance Grants: $3M ($1.5M from SBA) • Targeting underserved/distressed communities in US • One of only six such funds in US, the only NMVC in ME, NH and VT Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  12. State of the CDVC/SRVC industry • Proving the model • Must lead with financial returns • First time funds just beginning to see returns…jury is still out • Most CD and SR fund managers don’t have VC background • Funding sources • Funders for CDVC are mostly banks, foundations and state pension funds (for regionally oriented funds); • Foundations less interested in Financial than in social • Future funding dependent upon minimum financial returns with measurable social/environmental impact • Creating, enforcing and tracking • Social: Standards evolving for reporting • Environmental: No common approach/platform Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  13. Blended ReturnsPractices and Challenges • Social and Environmental • Screens during research (due diligence) • Use of new models (Nat. Cap., C2C) • Get it in writing—MOU, Term Sheet, etc • Use Board role to push for change and progressive practices • Track, analyze and report results • Retention • Cost savings • Revenue/marketing benefits Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  14. CCVI’s Approach • Use leverage of VC relationship to create social and environmental change and progressive practices • Social • CEI’s ETAG • Supporting women and minority-owned businesses • Environmental • Supporting environmentally beneficial products/services—e.g. alternative energy, clean water/air, etc • Commitment and reporting: CERES • New models: Natural Capitalism, Cradle to Cradle Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

  15. Breaking into the industry • Traditional VC experience provides essential foundation for best practice BUT • Very difficult to crack—small industry (in job terms), competitive • CDVC industry may be easier b/c it’s newer, less well known/understood and its managers may not screen the way traditional VC funds do (education, experience) BUT • Smaller industry, more limited jobs • Less VC experience at fund mgt level = different type of learning experience • How to get in • Build your background/experience: entrepreneurial experience, consulting, business development • Research funds and their portfolio companies • Attend industry conferences (sometimes free if you agree to work): CDVCA, Investors Circle, NASBIC, NVCA, Private Equity, Cleantech, etc • Conduct Informational interviews • Persist and be patient: this is the most difficult period to find a job in VC/PE—continue to build experience, network and take a long view Michael Gurau, CEI Community Ventures (mhg@ceicommunityventures.com)

More Related