1 / 12

Are prediction markets robust against manipulation? A lab experiment

Are prediction markets robust against manipulation? A lab experiment. Martin Strobel, University of Maastricht Feb. 2005. Reality. Mani- pulator. Market. Action. Price. Prediction. Prediction Markets: General Idea. Experiment Design: Fundamental Values.

olympe
Download Presentation

Are prediction markets robust against manipulation? A lab experiment

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Are prediction markets robust against manipulation? A lab experiment Martin Strobel, University of Maastricht Feb. 2005

  2. Reality Mani- pulator Market Action Price Prediction Prediction Markets: General Idea

  3. Experiment Design: Fundamental Values • Futures traded: BLACK and WHITE • Fundamental values: • BLACK: number of black balls • WHITE: number of white balls • Information:each trader knows a randomly drawn subset 100 balls Trader 1 Trader 2 …

  4. Experimental Design: General Setup • Double auction • Similar to PSMs (bundles = 100 ECU, portfolios were liquidated afterwards for fundamental values) • 8 sessions (S1 … S4 and M1 … M4) • Same instructions for S and M sessions • 12 traders per session (10 for S2 and M2) • Per session 7 markets with 7 minutes duration • Endowment for each market: 1000 ECU and 20 shares either BLACK or WHITE

  5. Experimental Design: Manipulation I • Robot player for manipulation • Focus on one simple method:excessive buying leads to price increases • 90 sec quiet240 sec manipulation90 sec “recovery”(60 sec) Asks Lowest ask+10 Lowest ask Random bid was placed Highest bid Bids

  6. Experimental Design: Manipulation II • Money was spread evenly among future time • Cash of manipulator is limited to 2 * 20 * fund. value (corresponds to an average endowment if value = 50) Asks Lowest ask+10 Lowest ask Random bid was placed Highest bid Bids

  7. Experiment Design: Software

  8. price best case 100 baseline case manipulation case fund. value 100 Expectations

  9. BeforePrice AfterPrice EndPrice • Manipulation has no effect • Manipulation has a temporary effect • Manipulation has a durable effect Hypotheses: Analysis start of market start of manipulation end of manipulation end of market 90 sec 270 sec 60 sec 420 sec

  10. Results

  11. Critique and Preliminary Conclusions • Proof of existence • No final answer to: Are markets vulnerable to manipulation? • 60 sec for recovery time is too short!? • Short-selling would solve the problem!? • After some time traders would incorporate manipulators in their reasoning!?

  12. Further Plans • Varying knowledge, uncertainty, discreteness, … • Allow for short-selling? • Compare results to Hanson, Oprea and Porter (forthcoming)

More Related