1 / 14

Rethinking supermarkets

Rethinking supermarkets. Andrew Bowman, Julie Froud, Sukhdev Johal, Karel Williams CRESC, University of Manchester. Outline. Outline. The importance of supermarkets to local economies The damage they do: the case of food manufacturing The false necessity of the business model

nowles
Download Presentation

Rethinking supermarkets

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Rethinking supermarkets Andrew Bowman, Julie Froud, Sukhdev Johal, Karel Williams CRESC, University of Manchester

  2. Outline Outline • The importance of supermarkets to local economies • The damage they do: the case of food manufacturing • The false necessity of the business model • Based on recent research on meat and dairy supply chains

  3. Why supermarkets matter: 1 • A £1bn per week industry taking 4/5ths of household spend across key products. • Over ¾ of this goes through “big 4” • As buyers, supermarkets wield immense power to shape local and national employment and supply chains.

  4. Why supermarkets matter: 2 • The largest private sector employer within the foundational economy – key influence on wages and working conditions. • A further 836,000 dependent jobs in food manufacturing and agriculture, fishing, etc.

  5. The supermarket The supermarket tithe • Household spend PP remarkably stable across income groups and across regions. • Supermarkets have a licenced local monopoly to receive a tithe (in the old English sense of a 10% tax) on household spend – guaranteed stable demand.

  6. Social alibi • Supermarkets social alibi = they deliver shareholder value and (superficially) low prices for customers. • Local variant = we bring you investment and jobs. • Safe from serious government intervention as long as deemed competitive: inquiries have not found collusion. • To ease tensions: Local CSR stunts, Union Jack stickers, and pictures of smiling farmers

  7. The reality: extraction

  8. The question: what have you done for me lately? If supermarkets take out, what should they put back in? • A bigger share of the spoils: not meaningless CSR. E.G. Hypothetical 5% Levy on smkt profit in Wales would yield over £12m = more than Welsh Assembly spend on homelessness. 2) Commitment to better local employment – e.g. living wage. 3) Supermarkets (alongside public sector procurement) are the key demand anchor that can increase local and sustainable food production initiatives … instead we have wrecked supply chains.

  9. Food manufacturing: the forgotten victim … but a very big victim. • Unglamorous but employs 378,000 in 2011 (compared to 124,000 in motor vehicles, 41,000 in pharma) • Key agent in improving sustainability and working conditions. • Largest manufacturing sector by sales and prop for huge machine-tool supply chain

  10. The squeezed middle

  11. Sector consequences • Demand: Continual uncertainty over demand and throughput • Output: Poor capacity utilization = wasted investment = inefficiency • Trade deficit: with high wage N.Europe. • Forced irresponsibility: on labour and environmental standards.

  12. Alternatives • Morrisons shows example of how vertically integrated supply chain aligns social and company interests. • Guaranteed demand = • Full capacity utilisation • Stable employment • Ability to plan for the future and invest • Ability to control sourcing and conditions (e.g. provenance, animal welfare, working conditions)

  13. Morrisons vs others: Outcome • Neerock: step-like reductions in labour’s share – indicator of high capacity utilisation • Low labour’s share = funds for reinvestment, price cuts or increased profits. Unsurprisingly Morrisons is expanding VI… • The options are there and political pressure can select the outcome.

  14. Conclusion • Local government needs to make supermarkets work harder for their social franchise: • Give more back in return • Act as demand anchor for local food production • Longer term / bigger picture: Disintegrated adversarial chain is a false necessity – problem is as much cultural as economic. Business models can be different - and alternatives are hidden in plain sight.

More Related