1 / 15

The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles

The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles. Philip McCann University of Sheffield. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles.

nate
Download Presentation

The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles Philip McCann University of Sheffield

  2. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles • Innovation features: newness; improvement; overcoming of uncertainty • Edward Glaeser, 2011, Triumph of the City • Cities as hubs of innovation → knowledge spillovers and/or transparency and competition • Cities as testbeds for new technologies – traffic, mobility solutions, health services, public service provision Cities also provide opportunities for governance experimentation → radical local government: “Political Petri Dishes”, The Economist, 22.09.2012 • Urban innovation strategies for city productivity and wellbeing → corporate and science advocates • Innovation challenge-led strategies are much more difficult in difficult urban contexts

  3. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles

  4. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles

  5. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles

  6. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles • Textbook assumptions of how cities (and their regional contexts) work • Assumptions: Cities display a productivity premium and drive economic growth; → Recent evidence: While this is true for many cities it is also true that many cities display no (or even a negative) productivity premium; many cities are not (productivity or population) growth drivers; in some countries productivity-scale relationships are zero or close to zero • EU experience is very different to US - Triumph of the City • In Europe urban advantages relating to employment and productivity post-crisis are oriented towards EU13 economies while EU15 face severe urban disadvantages

  7. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles • Assumption: Largercities are more productiveandresilient→EU cities display both resilience and vulnerability: they exacerbate national post-crisis trends with growing countries driven by growing cities and declining countries weighed down by declining cities • Effects of the real estate-related debt on the real economy are more pronounced in cities; real estate shock effects are dominated by cities → induced effects in the real economy • Assumption: Productivity growth drives wagegrowth→ Recent evidence: the link is rapidly weakening due to job polarisation, especially in cities

  8. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles • Assumption: Regional re-allocationscan drive productivity→ Recent evidence: increasing divergence in many countries; falling US interregionalmigration; static UK interregionalmigration (2 of the 3 most geographically mobile societies); increasingspatialdispersion of yields on investments • Assumption: Innovationandentrepreneurshipdiffusion is criticalforgrowth→ Recent evidence: falling US rates of entrepreneurship; innovationdiffusionprocessesstalled/broken in manycountries UK/US; costs of innovationsincreasing?

  9. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles • Assumption: Bid-rent curves (productivity spikes) are downward-sloping → Recent evidence: upward sloping bid rent curves in European manycities; flat bid-rent curves in manydeveloping country mega-cities • Assumption: Transport infrastructure drives productivitygrowth→ Recent evidence: no specificobservable link whichcanbegeneralised: onlygeneralbroad statements are possiblebased on comparisonsbetweenregionswithand without goodinfrastructure

  10. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles • Assumption: Urban economicmodelsbased on land priceand/or populationgrowth→ Recent evidence: betweenonequarterandonethird of European cities are facingpopulationdecline; a majority of JapaneseandKoreancities are declining • Little or no knowledgeregardinghowto ‘manage decline’ → random vacancies/insolvenciesincreasemarginalcosts of infrastructureandnetwork-based service provisionandinhibit/prohibitnecessary land useconsolidationandcoordination • Assumption: Henry George Theorem→ Recent evidence: human capitalrewards in cities are 50% economicrentsratherthan returns toknowledgeinvestments (Collier andVenables 2018)

  11. The Context for Urban Innovation Strategies: Opportunities, Challenges, Paradoxes and Puzzles • Essential need for urban innovation strategies to address societal challenges which are specific and relevant to the urban context • Need to also consider innovation opportunities and challenges related to the urban context • Need to identify opportunities for experimentation, testing, and trialling in the urban context • Need for urban governance systems which allow for innovation strategies → including allowing for failures • Need to identify intended ex ante outcomes, ongoing monitoring and ex post evaluation for strategic success

More Related