1 / 15

Lessons (Not) Learned: Reforming Public Internal Control

This article explores the challenges and lessons learned from the implementation of Public Internal Control (PIC) reforms, highlighting the importance of policy before prescription, a revised legal framework, planning ahead for sufficient resources, avoiding excessive segmentation, and aligning internal control with the Public Financial Management (PFM) system.

marykeith
Download Presentation

Lessons (Not) Learned: Reforming Public Internal Control

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Reforming Public Internal Control: Lessons (Not) Learned Raymond Hill, CGAP European Commission DG Budget

  2. Content • European Commission's long tradition of coaching PIC development • Challenges in reforming PIC • Lessons not learned • Conditions for successful reforms

  3. 2009 PIC Conference in Brussels • Purpose: To review and learn lessons from the implementation of PIC in the recently-joined EU Member States • Delegates provided positive feedback on: • Comprehensiveness of the PIC reform model • Our coaching on the sequencing of reform steps • Our guidance on the competency requirements of key staff in the PIC environment

  4. Many challenges to PIC implementation were identified • Absence of hard law: only reliance on non-binding international standards • Various good practices: no definition of best practice • Long time needed for reforms • Political pressure for fast visible results • Short term nature of technical assistance • Reforms were sometimes pushed too fast by the donor community: outstripping national absorption capacity • Management traditions and resistance

  5. Managerial Traditions and Resistance • Sometimes the top manager tries to control every detail • Lack of understanding of Managerial Accountability • Sometimes there is no manager! • Unclear delegation procedures do not allow to identify the task manager • Managers have a fear of transparency • Transparency is often only seen as highlighting negative aspects: however it can also serve to highlight good performance • Better internal control is not the same as more controls

  6. PIC Reform – Lessons (not) learned • Policy before Prescription • A revised legal framework is not a reform • A hasty legal transplant leads to problems at implementation • Plan ahead for sufficient resources • Avoid excessive segmentation – keep an eye on the big picture • Internal Control should match the PFM system

  7. Lesson 1: Policy before Prescription • A government approved Reform Policy should set the direction for Internal Control reforms • Pilot Projects are an effective way to test a new approach • Pilot Projects should come before legal prescription • There is no point in adopting a law and then testing its application through Pilot Projects!

  8. Lesson 2: A revised legal framework is not a Reform • As well as a solid legal foundation, fundamental public sector reform requires a long term change management strategy for modernising administrative culture • Change management strategy includes: • Visible political leadership • Reasoning for the change • Milestones: champions and role models • Feedback and a learning perspective • Encourage civil society interest in public governance

  9. Lesson 3: A hasty legal transplant leads to problems at implementation • Law-making takes time • New laws require wide consultation of stakeholders • New laws should be developed in line with the national administrative culture and national cost/benefit analysis. National ownership is required. • Non democratic law-making can move quickly but it will often break down at implementation

  10. Lesson 4: Plan ahead for sufficient resources • Reforms take time. Allow for plenty. • Need for skilled, motivated and empowered staff at central level • Need for sustainable training facilities • Seek agreement for medium/long term Technical Assistance support

  11. Lesson 5: Excessive segmentation – Not seeing the big picture • Excessive segmentation can produce hyper-focussed approaches that ignore systemic problems and fail to add up to an integrated effective whole. • Co-ordination and sequencing of all related PIC reforms (especially Public Administration reform, Budgeting and Accounting reform) is required – at strategic level.

  12. Lesson 6: Internal Control should match the PFM system There are 3 basic stages of Public Financial Management development: Stage 1: Enforce basic financial compliance Characterized by traditional input controlled budget Stage 2: Ensure fiscal stability over the medium term Characterized by medium term budget frameworks Stage 3: Attain policy objectives in efficient/effective way Characterized by “performance budgeting/management”

  13. Development path of PFM systems

  14. PIC Reform: Conditions for success • Ownership: • Political commitment: politicians lead, technicians follow • Top managers accept that reform is necessary • Ensuring change in administrative culture: • Understanding that law-making and adherence to legal rules is not enough but that there is a need for managerial accountability and real delegation • Sufficient resources: • An adequately resourced and skilled Central Harmonisation Unit to drive the change and face stakeholder expectations

  15. PIC Reform: Conditions for Success (cont) • An integrated approach: • PIC is not a stand-alone, technical fix but part of the overall public Finance Management and Public Administration reforms • A comprehensive reform is better than piecemeal changes • Long-term project management • Ongoing and sustainable training for all

More Related