1 / 20

Partial equilibrium B/C - A

Partial equilibrium B/C - A. (Cost Benefit Analysis DEC 51304) R. Jongeneel Zerbe & Dively Ch.7-8. Lecture Plan. Partial equilibrium analysis CS and PS revisited Examples - monopolist with constant costs - taxation - technical progress - external effects

marlo
Download Presentation

Partial equilibrium B/C - A

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Partial equilibrium B/C - A (Cost Benefit Analysis DEC 51304) R. Jongeneel Zerbe & Dively Ch.7-8

  2. Lecture Plan • Partial equilibrium analysis • CS and PS revisited • Examples- monopolist with constant costs- taxation- technical progress- external effects • Multiple market - equilibrium analysis • Multiple price changes + Footnote on welfare economic analysis and applied CBA

  3. Partial equilibrium analysis • Assumption only one one market is affected • Examine effects in this market only • Partial equilibrium (PE) analysis • PE  MME  GE (general equilibrium)

  4. CS and PS revisited • Demand curve  approx WTP • CS: excess of WTP over what is actually paid • Supply curve  opportunity costs of output provision • PS: excess of payments over opportunity costs (quasi-rents) • External effects give rise to CS and PS changes • Transfers: neither benefit nor cost

  5. CS and PS revisited Fundamental equation of welfare change W = CS + PS + GR + EE CS: consumer surplus PS: producer surplus GR: government revenue EE: external effects

  6. price DWL-triangle A P1 B C P0 MC E demand MR Q0 Q1 butter Examples: Monopolist W = CS + PS = A - (A+B+C) + (B-0) = -(B+C) + B = -C

  7. price A P1 S+t t B C P0 S(=MC) Q1 Q0 quantity Examples: Taxation W = CS + PS + GR = -(B+C) + 0 + B = -C excess burden of taxation

  8. price S1=S0+t t A S0 PD B C D P0 F E PS G D Q0 Q1 quantity Examples: Taxation W = CS + PS + GR = -(B+C+D) - (E+F) + (B+C+E) = -(D+F) = DWLcons + DWLprod

  9. Example: taxation & welfare loss Bishop’s rule : absolute values of elasticities t: percentage tax (e.g. 0.25) Lessons ….?

  10. Some Lessons • Distortionary taxation is not P-Eff. • DWL is quadratic function of t (broad tax base-argument) • DWL increase the more elastic are demand and supply (Ramsey) • The relative inelastic-side of the market pays the main burden

  11. price S0 A S1 P0 B C D P1 E F D Q0 Q1 wheat Examples: Technical progress W = CS + PS = (B+C+D) + (F-B+E) = C+D+F

  12. A LRS+t P1 B C P0+ D LRS+D (=soc. cost) G t D E F P0 LRS=MC D Q1 Q0 Q1 Examples: External effects + tax W = CS + PS + GR + EE = -(B+C+D+E+F)+ 0 + (B+D) + (E+F+G) = -C+G

  13. Multiple Market Equilibrium (MME) analysis • MME analysis takes into account relevant related markets • Harberger’s ruleAdd to the standard PE-analysis the change in GR’s in the related distorted markets • In non-distorted related markets marginal costs and marginal benefits of changes in production and consumption will just offset each other.

  14. Multiple price changes • Multiple price changes require sequential welfare measurement W = CS + PS + GR + EE

  15. CBA in Individual consumer economy & Small project A footnote on welfare economic (surplus) analysis and applied cost benefit analysis

  16. CBA in Individual consumer economy & Small project • Single individual • Single price change / income kept constant • No 2nd market price effects • First-best economy (no other distortions) • Marshallian CS good approximation • PS good approximation

  17. CBA in Individual consumer economy & Small project Tax/levy a P1.0 d e P2.0 b P1.1 c q1.0 q1.1 q2.0 q2.1

  18. CBA in Individual consumer economy & Small project • Change in CS : P10 a b P11 • Income constant : change in spending is zero! • q10 c b q11 – P10 a c P11 – q21 d e q 20 = 0 • Change in welfare (dU) • dU = P10 a b P11 = P10 a c P11 + abc • dU = q10 a b q11 + q21 d e q 20

  19. CBA in Individual consumer economy & Small project a P1.0 d e P2.0 b P1.1 c -- + q1.0 q1.1 q2.0 q2.1

  20. CBA in Individual consumer economy & Small project • Change in welfare: dW continued • . • Small project: price changes small • . Total benefits-method => income effect-method

More Related