100 likes | 168 Views
Learn essential counteranalysis techniques in case law and enacted law, including debunking misplaced reliance and analyzing differing interpretations, with practical examples and insights.
E N D
Chapter 12— Counteranalysis Counteranalysis Techniques—Case Law
Techniques—Case Law • Reliance misplaced—key fact difference. • Reliance misplaced—rule of law/principle does not apply.
Techniques—Case Law • Court opinion is subject to different interpretation. • Rule/principle adopted in opinion relied on is not universally followed.
Techniques—Case Law • Opinion presents several solutions—one being urged is not mandatory or is not best choice.
Techniques—Case Law • Position relied on no longer represents sound public policy. • Other relevant cases do not support position adopted in the case.
Chapter 12— Counteranalysis Counteranalysis Techniques—Enacted Law
Techniques—Enacted Law • Elements of statute are not met. • Statute is sufficiently broad—different construction.
Techniques—Enacted Law • Statute is misconstrued or does not apply. • Statute relied on as a guide does not apply.
Techniques—Enacted Law • Statute relied on is not adopted in jurisdiction. • Interpretation of statute is unconstitutional or violates legislative act.
Techniques—Enacted Law • Statute relied on is unconstitutional.