1 / 17

Banking & Finance Technology Forum 2005

Banking & Finance Technology Forum 2005. Basel II – The Implementation Phase Simon Topping Hong Kong Monetary Authority / City University of Hong Kong 9 March 2005. Basel II – The Implementation Phase. HKMA’s approach to implementation: Timing / available approaches

lilian
Download Presentation

Banking & Finance Technology Forum 2005

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Banking & Finance Technology Forum 2005 Basel II – The Implementation PhaseSimon ToppingHong Kong Monetary Authority /City University of Hong Kong9 March 2005

  2. Basel II – The Implementation Phase • HKMA’s approach to implementation: • Timing / available approaches • Consultation documents / guidance issued • Hong Kong banking industry’s implementation plans • Choice of approaches • Progress being made • Basel II in the context of other concurrent “regulatory” initiatives: • Is there a danger of over-regulation? • If so, what can we do about it?

  3. HKMA’s approach to implementation (1) Timing / available approaches: • 1 Jan 2007 • Credit risk: basic, standardised & foundation IRB approaches • Operational risk: basic indicator & standardised approaches • Pillars 2 & 3 • 1 Jan 2008 • Credit risk: advanced IRB approach • 31 Dec 2009 • End of transitional period • To be determined: • Operational risk: AMA approaches

  4. HKMA’s approach to implementation (2) Consultation documents / guidance issued: • October 2001 (12) • Proposed implementation approach (high level) • July 2003 (63) • Proposed implementation approach (detailed) • August 2004 (200) • Timing / available approaches • New “basic” approach • Scope of application (e.g. bank holding companies) • Standardised approach (e.g. retail / SME) • National discretions under standardised & IRB • Minimum requirements for internal rating systems / risk quantification under IRB

  5. HKMA’s approach to implementation (3) Consultation documents / guidance issued: • September 2004 (155) • Standardised approach (RMLs, past dues, collateral) • IRB application / recognition process • IRB self-assessment of compliance with qualifying criteria • December 2004 (42) • Draft Banking (Amendment) Bill 2005 • Power to make capital rules & disclosure rules • Designation of BHCs • Upper level for minimum CAR increased to 16%

  6. HKMA’s approach to implementation (4) Consultation documents / guidance issued: • February 2005 (173) • Weighting framework for credit risk under standardised & IRB approaches • Credit risk mitigation under standardised approach • Criteria for transition to IRB approach • Weighting framework for operational risk • Coming soon… • Calculation of capital base • Credit risk under basic approach • Asset securitisation • Market risk • Pillars 2 & 3

  7. Hong Kong banking industry’s implementation plans (1) • HKMA has made adoption of the more advanced approaches (i.e. foundation / advanced IRB) optional, stressing that each AI should weigh up the costs & benefits • It transpires that more AIs than originally expected plan to adopt IRB: 17 AIs comprising mostly the larger banks plus some smaller subsidiaries of foreign banks • This reflects the fact that there is now wider acceptance by the industry that Basel II can deliver real benefits in terms of improved risk management - & market expectations that major banks will adopt IRB

  8. Hong Kong banking industry’s implementation plans (2) • Not all of the 17 will implement IRB immediately (transitional period runs to end-2009) • A number of small & medium-sized banks have also initiated IRB-type development programmes focused initially on developing internal ratings • AIs are making extensive use of external assistance (IT / model vendors, management consultants, etc.) • Around 40 RLBs & DTCs will adopt basic approach • HKMA has begun bilateral discussions with AIs on their plans • HKMA’s assessment is that the industry has “bought into” Basel II & is making good progress on implementation

  9. Basel II in the context of other concurrent regulatory initiatives (1) • In addition to Basel II, AIs also need to make concurrent changes to systems & procedures in relation to, e.g., changes in international accounting standards & new anti money laundering requirements • This could place a strain on management / IT resources, & create a cost burden • It also raises system integration & prioritisation issues • Is there, therefore, a danger of over-regulation? • If so, what can we do about it?

  10. Basel II in the context of other concurrent regulatory initiatives (2) • There are 5 main themes to the regulatory initiatives being pursued currently: • Stability of the banking system / protection of depositors • Improvement of risk management • Enhanced public disclosure / market discipline • Consumer interests • Wider public interests

  11. Basel II in the context of other concurrent regulatory initiatives (3) “Stability of the banking system / protection of depositors” initiatives: • Basel II • Deposit protection scheme “Improvement of risk management” initiatives: • Basel II • Commercial credit reference agency • Consumer credit data sharing • Supervisory policies on interest rate risk, FX risk, stress-testing, etc.

  12. Basel II in the context of other concurrent regulatory initiatives (4) “Enhanced public disclosure / market discipline” initiatives: • Basel II (Pillar 3) • Adoption of international accounting standards • Listing rules • Corporate governance initiatives

  13. Basel II in the context of other concurrent regulatory initiatives (5) “Consumer interests” initiatives: • Basel II • Enhancement of securities regulatory regime • Customer complaints • Deposit protection • Code of Banking Practice • Product regulation “Wider public interests” initiatives • Anti money laundering & terrorist financing

  14. Basel II in the context of other concurrent regulatory initiatives (6) From this long list it is clear that: • Basel II is a key initiative which is central to several of the themes • There is a real danger that, unless properly managed, the regulatory burden on AIs could become onerous, notwithstanding the worthiness of each of these initiatives in their own right • In large part this reflects a global trend towards increased regulation & is, therefore, unavoidable (e.g. adoption of international standards & best practices is necessary in order to maintain Hong Kong’s reputation as a well-regulated IFC)

  15. Basel II in the context of other concurrent regulatory initiatives (7) However, in order to keep the regulatory burden manageable, & in keeping with a business-friendly orientation, the HKMA is committed to working with the banking industry (&, for that matter, LegCo & consumer interest groups) to try to get the right balance between the risks & rewards of regulation For example, in relation to Basel II the HKMA has: • Consulted the industry extensively throughout • Liaised closely with AIs to ensure that the approaches offered, the timetable for implementation, & the qualifying criteria for approval, are acceptable to the industry

  16. Basel II in the context of other concurrent regulatory initiatives (8) • Made adoption of the advanced approaches optional • Developed the basic approach for smaller AIs • Put on hold the proposed regulatory regime for BHCs • Liaised closely with other supervisors to try to encourage harmonisation of requirements • Indicated a willingness to be pragmatic in relation to use test / validation Such an approach – a risk-based approach focusing on cost/benefit analysis, pragmatism, proportionality, & close co-operation with the industry – is aimed at ensuring that Hong Kong gets the right amount - & right type – of regulation

  17. Basel II in the context of other concurrent regulatory initiatives (9) Basel II, which is modelled on banks’ own best practices, & can deliver benefits in terms of (1) stability of the banking system / protection of depositors, (2) improvement of risk management (3) enhanced public disclosure / market discipline & (4) consumer interests, is an example of the right type of regulation The winners - in terms both of financial centres & of individual institutions - will be those who implement it most effectively – those who have the best strategy, the best solutions, & get their prioritisation right

More Related