1 / 40

U.S. Science Policy - Some Challenges

U.S. Science Policy - Some Challenges. Arthur Bienenstock October 7, 2000 Innovative Structures in Basic Research Conference of the Max Planck Society. Bienenstock. Physicist & Materials Scientist Physics and structure of disordered and amorphous materials

ledell
Download Presentation

U.S. Science Policy - Some Challenges

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. U.S. Science Policy - Some Challenges Arthur Bienenstock October 7, 2000 Innovative Structures in Basic Research Conference of the Max Planck Society

  2. Bienenstock • Physicist & Materials Scientist • Physics and structure of disordered and amorphous materials • Director of Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Laboratory through much of its development • Since 11/97, OSTP associate director for science • Concerns about funding for physical sciences & engineering

  3. OSTP Director • Neal Lane • Assistant to the President (President's Science Advisor) • Director, Office of Science and Technology Policy

  4. OSTP Mission • Advise the President on policy related to science and technology • Advise the President on other policy matters where science and/or technology is relevant • Coordinate interagency activities

  5. Office of Science and Technology Policy

  6. U.S. almost unique among industrialized nations • No national universities (except for military) • Instead, system of private and state-funded universities • Federal support of university-based research • >60% of Federally supported basic research • ~1/3 of Federally supported civilian R&D • Federal government is extremely dependent on a system which it does not support or control directly • Large fraction of research support is provided to individuals, or groups of individuals, on basis of competitive, peer-reviewed proposals. • Any faculty member, junior or senior, can apply

  7. Some Federal Agencies Supporting S&T-Related Research • Agriculture • Commerce • Defense • Education • Energy • Environmental Protection Agency • Health and Human Services • Interior • Justice • National Aeronautics & Space Administration • National Science Foundation • Transportation

  8. Importance of Research to the United States • Economy • Health • Environment • National Security • Transportation • Justice • Human Curiosity • Science and Technology Workforce Development

  9. X-Rays • Discovered in 1896 by Roentgen as part of particle physics experiments (1901 Nobel Prize in Physics) • Used for diagnostic and therapeutic radiology within year

  10. CT-Scanner - www.imaginis.com

  11. CT-Scan Image of Brain Tumor • FromThe Whole Brain Atlas • Neuroimaging Primer, Keith A. Johnson, M.D. • http://www.med.harvard.edu/AANLIB/hms2.html

  12. Why CAT-Scans So Long After X-rays? • Computers • Solid-state physics • Materials scientists • Engineers • Computer scientists • Detectors • Physicists • Engineers • Algorithms • Mathematicians • Computer scientists • Almost all working on goals unrelated to CT-Scans

  13. Accelerator Complex - Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Laboratory

  14. In vivo microscopy of trabecular bone image area anesthetized J.H. Kinney, N.E. Lane, D.L. Haupt, J Bone Miner Res 10:264–270 (1995)

  15. Estrogen deficiency induces rapid bone loss and altered architecture before estrogen loss after estrogen loss Scan bone volume(%) connectivity(mm-3) Baseline 23.0±2.5 (n=5) 100±5 (n=6) Post OVX 9.2±5.6 (n=3) 15±10 (n=3) Kinney & Haupt 94

  16. Interdependencies of Sciences • High energy physics storage ring • Developed by materials scientists and solid-state physicists for synchrotron radiation • Team of physician, materials scientists and computer scientists apply to osteoporosis • Need social scientists to alter women’s behavior

  17. Increasing Balance • 15-20% increases for NSF Core Research Divisions • Biological Sciences • Engineering • Mathematical and Physical Sciences • Social and Behavioral Science

  18. Question: What instruments does the Office of Science and Technology Policy employ for redirecting research to new frontiers? • Answer: Interagency Initiatives

  19. Interagency Initiatives in FY 2001 Budget • Plant Genome • Information Technology - ~$2,200M • Nanotechnology - ~$500M • Interagency Education Research Initiative - ~$50M

  20. Interagency Education Research Initiative • PCAST Panel on Educational Technology calls (3/97) for "major program of experimental research" at $1.5B level • basic research in various educationally relevant technologies... • early stage research aimed at developing new forms of educational software… • rigorous, well-controlled, peer-reviewed, large-scale empirical studies designed to determine which educational approaches are in fact most effective in practice • PCAST Education Panel and OSTP consider structure through mid-98

  21. Interagency Education Research Initiative • OSTP brings together, in 1998 • DoEd's Office of Educational Research & Improvement • National Institute of Child Health & Human Development • National Science Foundation • Single program planned • Single solicitation (after many workshops) • Single evaluation process • "Assignment" of projects to specific agencies for funding as part of evaluation process • Interdisciplinary • Large scale

  22. Second question • How can research and funding organizations reliably identify innovative researchers with radical new programs not yet established within existing disciplines?

  23. "Reliably" ? • Demanding reliability in this process will necessarily discourage decision-makers from supporting "innovative researchers with radical new programs not yet established within existing disciplines" • There have to be failures - and decision makers will fear being blamed for them

  24. Revert to Experience as SSRL Director • Beam time extremely scarce • Proposal Review Panel rated "safe" experiments higher than high payoff-high risk • I asked them to identify latter anyway • On some, I overruled Panel and scheduled experiments anyway - explaining afterwards • Viewed such decisions as my responsibility

  25. Politicians and Universities • Many political issues depend on science or technology • Few members of Congress understand science • Rockefeller statement at PCAST • They all went to OUR universities - why didn't we educate them?

  26. Workforce - View from OSTP • Very low unemployment rate • Statements that unavailability of workers is limiting economic growth • Requests for increases in H-1B visas • Are these short-term phenomena?

  27. Growth in Fraction of Total U.S. Workforce Employed in ST&E • 1962 - 11% • 1995 - 15% (OSTP analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics statistics)

  28. BLS Projections - Job Growth • Professional specialty occupations • Includes scientists, engineers, medical personnel • 1986-1996 - Grew by 34% • 1996-2006 - Projected growth - 27% • Ten specific occupations with highest projected growth • 6 - health-related • 4 - computer-related

  29. Bureau of the Census Demographic Projections - 18-64 year olds

  30. Percent of 22 Year Olds Earning Science & Engineering Degrees - 1995 • African-Americans - 5.7 • Asians - 21.6 • Hispanic - 4.8 • non-Hispanic White Females - 11.8 • non-Hispanic White Males - 13.8

  31. Projections of Future Situation • If participation rates of all the groups remain the same and demographic projections are correct, • then fraction of workforce that is ST&E will decrease significantly at time when increase is likely to be needed.

  32. Calculated Fraction of 22 Year Olds Receiving Bachelors Degrees in Science & Engineering if Award Rates of Various Groups Remain Constant

  33. Immigration & the ST&E Workforce - 1995 • 12% of people in U.S. holding S&E bachelor’s degrees were naturalized citizens or non-U.S. citizens • Would have to increase immigration significantly to hold ST&E fraction of workforce constant if don’t increase domestic participation rates • Nations providing immigrants are building their own ST&E workforces and economies

  34. Basic Conclusion • Must remain attractive for immigration • Must increase participation rates of all groups in ST&E • Under-represented minorities, women and persons with disabilities represent largest potential pools

  35. Progress Over Last Two Decades

More Related